Second Session, 43rd Parliament
Report of Proceedings
(Hansard)
Select Standing Committee on
Finance and
Government Services
Victoria
Monday, June 1, 2026
Issue No. 43
ISSN 1499-4178
The HTML transcript is provided for informational purposes only.
The PDF transcript remains the official digital version.
Membership
Chair: Paul Choi (Burnaby South–Metrotown, BC NDP)
Deputy Chair: Donegal Wilson (Boundary-Similkameen, Conservative Party of BC)
Members: Rohini Arora (Burnaby East, BC NDP)
Bryan Tepper (Surrey-Panorama, Conservative Party of BC)
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat (Cowichan Valley, BC NDP)
Clerk: Darryl Hol
Contents
Budget Consultation Presentations
Restorative Justice Program, Sunshine Coast
Canadian Credit Union Association
Mount Pleasant Neighbourhood House
University of British Columbia
Arrowsmith Health Care (2011) Society
Victoria Youth Empowerment Society
B.C. Marine Parks Forever Society
Downtown Victoria Business Association
Canadian Federation of Independent Business
B.C. Sustainable Energy Association
CUPE Local 5536, B.C. Harm Reduction Workers
Victoria Residential Builders Association
Family Services of Greater Vancouver
Canadian Mental Health Association, B.C. division
Laryngectomee Association of B.C.
Options Community Services Society
Mental Health Recovery Partners, South Island
Conseil scolaire francophone de la Colombie-Britannique
Camosun College Student Society
Victoria Women’s Transition House Society
Association of Service Providers for Employability and Career Training
Monday, June 1, 2026
The committee met at 8:36 a.m.
[Paul Choi in the chair.]
Paul Choi (Chair): Good morning, everyone. My name is Paul Choi. I’m the MLA for Burnaby South–Metrotown and the Chair of the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government Services.
I would like to acknowledge that we are meeting today on the legislative precinct here in Victoria, which is located on the homelands of the lək̓ʷəŋən-speaking People, now known as the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations.
Our committee is currently conducting its annual consultation with British Columbians on their priorities for the next provincial budget. British Columbians who are not presenting to the committee can still share their views by making written comments. The details on how to provide submissions are available on our website at la-bc.ca/consultations.
I will now ask the members of the committee to introduce themselves, starting with the Deputy Chair.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): My name is Donegal Wilson. I’m MLA for Boundary-Similkameen, and I’m honoured to serve as the Deputy Chair on the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government Services.
Before being elected, I had the opportunity to appear before this committee as a stakeholder, presenting recommendations on behalf of organizations and communities I represented. I look forward to working collaboratively with my colleagues on this committee and hearing from British Columbians from all corners of the province.
Bryan Tepper: Hello. I am Bryan Tepper, the MLA for Surrey-Panorama. Good day.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Hi. I’m Debra Toporowski. My traditional name is Qwulti’stunaat, and I’m the MLA for the Cowichan Valley.
Rohini Arora: Hello. My name is Rohini Arora. I am the MLA for Burnaby East and the Deputy Chair of the government caucus. I’m thrilled to hear from all of you about what we should be focusing on here in British Columbia.
Paul Choi (Chair): We are now going to hear from a number of organizations and individuals about their priorities for the next provincial budget. Each participant will have five minutes to speak, followed by up to five minutes for questions from committee members.
First, we have Ian Cochran from Restorative Justice Program of the Sunshine Coast.
I’ll turn it over to you.
Budget Consultation Presentations
Restorative Justice Program,
Sunshine Coast
Ian Cochran: Good morning. Thank you for the opportunity to provide input to the budget process. I am Ian Cochran, representing the Restorative Justice Program of the Sunshine Coast.
I’m coming to you from the unceded territory of the shíshálh People.
Our organization provides restorative justice services to a population of about 35,000 people on the lower Sunshine Coast. We do this with a few paid personnel, who leverage the efforts of many volunteers trained as restorative justice practitioners. Our office is in Sechelt, and we have restorative justice community hubs in Pender Harbour and Halfmoon Bay and are developing hubs in the shíshálh Nation, Roberts Creek and Gibsons. The local RCMP staff sergeant serves on our board of directors.
[8:40 a.m.]
Our ambitious goal is a safe, healthy, supportive, inclusive and conflict-free community on the Sunshine Coast. I aim to convince the committee that sufficient, stable and we-can-count-on-it funding for restorative justice programs in B.C. would not only save taxpayer dollars but help us achieve the goal that I just mentioned.
I don’t have time to educate this community on restorative justice principles, so I will provide a prime example of our activities.
My colleague and I accepted a case referred from the RCMP for resolution through a community justice forum. A young man was charged with assaulting an older man over a disagreement in a public place. Both the RCMP and the ambulance service were called. The older man spent a couple of days in hospital. The younger man was charged with assault. The RCMP judged that both individuals had contributed to the altercation and that the community would be better served if this criminal offence was settled through a restorative justice process instead of the court system.
To understand what happened, my colleague and I interviewed the younger man and the older man separately but each accompanied by their supporters who they chose. Later we held a community justice forum where both men, along with their supporters, sat in a circle facing each other while I asked them each in turn to describe what had happened and to answer open-ended questions that encouraged them to think and speak about who was affected and how people were affected, plus their own responsibility for what occurred.
We then asked a circle of seven people to come up with a consensus agreement on what should be done to resolve the conflict in a fair and equitable way. It took considerable bargaining around the circle to develop a resolution agreement that both parties and all their supporters could agree to. We left the parties to enjoy coffee and snacks together, and they were visiting while we committed the agreement to writing for all to sign.
Two months later the requirements of the resolution agreement were satisfied, and the case was closed. The elderly man had a controlling say in the resolution, and the younger man apologized, admitted responsibility and was restored to the community with no criminal record. It was obvious to us that neither man was a criminally violent person.
All of this didn’t cost taxpayers a dime. Volunteers did it all. The overloaded RCMP didn’t have to process a file. No prosecution services were required. No judges or court services were involved, certainly saving thousands of taxpayer dollars.
We also hold peacemaking circles and dialogue circles to increase understanding on hot issues or address community conflict on the streets, at business places, in schools, in political discourse, in families, etc. The objective here is to address issues before they become matters needing RCMP attention. This provides significant policing and social cost savings.
Our organization requires stable, continuing annual funding to achieve our goal and serve community needs. The district of Sechelt generously provides multi-year annual cash and in-kind support, amounting to about $2.30 per capita. We are in the process of convincing the Sunshine Coast regional district, the town of Gibsons and the shíshálh Nation government district to do the same, and we think it reasonable that the B.C. government should match this per-capita funding.
We are challenging community members and local businesses collectively to contribute funds amounting to roughly $1.15 for each resident on the Sunshine Coast. We have access to funding from public and private granting agencies, but application, monitoring, accounting and reporting requirements for grants can absorb up to 20 percent of the awards. Skills required for administering grants are a serious challenge for folks trained in and focused on restorative justice. Grants are often not awarded and vary in amount year to year, creating an instability for small volunteer-based organizations.
Numerous studies show that restorative justice consistently outperforms traditional….
Paul Choi (Chair): Sorry, Ian. Time is up. If you can wrap it up in the next 20 seconds, please.
Ian Cochran: Okay.
In summary, we’re recommending that the B.C. government provide annual funding to all restorative justice programs operating in B.C. in the amount of $2.30 for every person in the community they serve. There are between 80 and 90 such programs servicing their communities. This funding should be coordinated between the Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General and the Attorney General since restorative justice complements policing, the court system, the judiciary and the prosecution system.
[8:45 a.m.]
I am confident that funding restorative justice will reduce overall government spending. We’re available for further consultation.
Thanks for your attention. Do you have any questions?
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Bryan Tepper: Just before the end there, you mentioned $1.15. I think I missed what that number was in relation to, if you could clear that up for me.
Ian Cochran: It’s just a number we chose. It’s half of $2.30. That’s all.
Bryan Tepper: What are you looking for with that, sorry?
Ian Cochran: That is for expecting local residents and businesses to contribute the equivalent of $1.15 per person on the Sunshine Coast.
Bryan Tepper: Okay. Just to clear up then, are you looking for $2.30 per person, per capita, I guess, from the government or $1.15 then?
Ian Cochran: The $2.30.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): You articulated well what money could be saved and put a lot of emphasis on volunteers. Can you tell me what the funding supports? Is it primarily administration, or are you looking to hire people to do it rather than having volunteers?
Ian Cochran: No. It’s important that it be a volunteer organization. That way it represents the values and issues that are happening in our community.
The money is primarily to hire about 2½ people, an executive director, an administrator and a trainer. We need to always have our personnel trained. I’m trained as a restorative justice practitioner. Those are the three individuals: an executive director; a person who meets the community, the outreach to the community; and someone that keeps us trained and trains new people as they come and volunteer.
Rohini Arora: How many volunteers do you have as part of your organization?
Ian Cochran: We have about 20.
Rohini Arora: Okay, 20 volunteers.
You’re saying that it’s 2.5 FTE to be able to run the organization, but you’re looking to include more volunteers, which would require more training hours.
Ian Cochran: Not only do we want more volunteers, but we continually need to replenish people that volunteer for a certain period of time and then leave.
Rohini Arora: Okay. Got it. Thank you.
Ian Cochran: And there are new issues arising in restorative justice that you need to be trained in as well.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for your presentation.
Now we’ll move on to our next presenter. Next we have Henry Han from Canadian Credit Union Association.
Thanks for joining us today. You have five minutes for presentation and five minutes for questions after.
I’ll turn it over to you.
Canadian Credit Union Association
Henry Han: Thanks for letting me speak today on behalf of the Canadian Credit Union Association. I’ll refer to us as CCUA, going forward.
As you said, my name is Henry Han. I’m the regional director for government relations for CCUA in B.C. We are the national credit union trade association that provides services to Canada’s credit unions across the country; caisses populaires, outside of Quebec; as well as regional central organizations.
Just to note, I won’t be doing a land acknowledgement today as I’m speaking to you from Tokyo, Japan, on holidays, but I wanted to be here to be present, given the importance of our sector and also the unique moment in time we are in with respect to our country and the sector broadly.
For those of you who don’t know much about credit unions, B.C., quite frankly, is the headquarters to credit unions in Canada. While Quebec may have the largest sector as a result of history, culture and government policy and a unique model with respect to Desjardins’ federated entity, the rest of Canada is composed of individual credit unions largely regulated by provincial authorities, provincial credit unions.
[8:50 a.m.]
Most recently we now have federally regulated credit unions. Those are provincial credit unions that have applied to operate across the country as federal credit unions and to be regulated by the federal government.
Today B.C. is home to the largest federal and largest credit union in Canada, Coast Capital Savings; the second-largest federal credit union and originator of the multi-brand model, Tru Cooperative Bank, formerly First West Credit Union, headquartered in Langley; and, of course, the largest provincial credit union, Vancity.
We also have, in B.C., the first attempt outside of Quebec of smaller, regionally focused credit unions attempting to come together to explore a federated model to maintain their local orientation while developing a strategy that will enable them to be viable and sustainable over the next decade as our sector sees cost, regulatory and technology pressures mount.
Historically the province, under various governments, both NDP and Liberal, has focused on attracting new investors, foreign banks, to establish representative offices here or strategies to develop new clusters and sectors like Look West. All the while, in my opinion, it’s taking for granted a credit union sector that is in excess of $100 billion in assets, employs over 9,000 people and drives economic prosperity through the financial services they provide to over two million British Columbians for home mortgages and loans to small businesses.
B.C. is, in fact, a leading cluster nationally of cooperative financial institutions and innovating approaches to growth not seen elsewhere in Canada. We need to retain support and provide as many pathways to continue to grow our credit union sector.
Today provincially regulated credit unions cannot do business outside their province. In the wake of the trade actions undertaken by our neighbour to the south and the current geopolitical environment, Canada has now shifted the conversation on ways to grow our economy through new partnerships and models — notably, the removal of provincial trade barriers and enabling free trade across Canada.
As it stands today, credit unions in B.C. are asking this government to finalize and sign a bilateral agreement with the province of Ontario that would allow B.C. credit unions to operate in Ontario and vice versa and also facilitate merger and acquisition opportunities for B.C. and Ontario credit unions to scale and grow and, also, to a large degree, to be competitive against the larger banks and continue to serve and exist in the many communities where British Columbians use credit unions and where credit unions are the sole financial institution.
The recommendations we are asking for:
One, that B.C. and Ontario formally conclude an extraprovincial agreement for credit unions as soon as possible. Maintaining a provincially regulated credit union sector allows provincial governments to tailor lending in the province via regulatory frameworks to support priorities for British Columbians. Otherwise, B.C. and other provinces may see a future where all large credit unions eventually become federally regulated for competitiveness and growth reasons, effectively deferring all financial institution policy to the federal level.
The second recommendation is that the B.C. government, Ministry of Finance and other key ministries develop a strategy to retain and grow provincially regulated credit unions, maintaining B.C.’s lead nationally as the No. 1 cluster for cooperative financial institutions in Canada.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for that presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you very much for the presentation. If the bilateral agreement could be put through, what would be the economic potential for British Columbia? Is that a complicated answer?
Henry Han: Well, I think that the key here right now is that there requires a certain amount of scale for credit unions in the current environment and going forward. Allowing provincial credit unions to operate in each other’s boundaries allows them to grow through acquiring new members, through new lending activities, accessing another market as well as the opportunity for consolidation between credit unions in B.C. and Ontario.
[8:55 a.m.]
Suffice it to say, the largest credit unions are here in British Columbia, and for them to find opportunities to acquire credit unions in Ontario would allow them to continue to maintain their head offices here in British Columbia and to grow and scale and effectively compete with the larger banks.
Rohini Arora: I just want to clarify. When you said federal and provincial…. Currently some of the bigger…. Coast Capital, you said, is federally regulated because it wanted to enter into other provinces — yes? — or is that a B.C.-based one?
Henry Han: Coast Capital is headquartered here. They were a long-standing provincial credit union, but about eight years ago, they applied to become a federal credit union to achieve a certain scale to be competitive against the banks. They are now regulated federally through OSFI, the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, in Ottawa and no longer through BCFSA, the provincial regulator.
Rohini Arora: What is the…? Let’s say you get the bilateral agreement, which was my initial question, actually, but Donegal beat me to it.
I’m curious then. If that is in place, what is the difference? There’s clearly a barrier that you’re trying to overcome. What is that, just for clarity’s sake?
Henry Han: I think there’s a benefit to British Columbians and the province first, and that is the ability to maintain and regulate financial institutions in the province, to incent them to lend into areas that are priorities for the government of British Columbia and, also, to tailor lending policies here that are unique to the environment in British Columbia.
An example would be…. About five years ago, I had to renew my mortgage. I was going to get a new mortgage to extend the term. I went to TD. I wasn’t approved through TD because they counted my rental at 50 percent occupancy. I live one kilometre from the University of British Columbia. I had maintained 100 percent occupancy during the five years of my term. I went to a local credit union. They applied 80 percent and were able to give me the mortgage.
I think having provincially regulated credit unions also allows the province, if they want to incent lending into the regions — into rural communities, into some sectors they see as higher priorities, into small business or affordable housing — to work with the regulator to adapt that framework to incent that type of lending. Otherwise, you would effectively be deferring all of that lending policy to Ottawa.
I recall former Deputy Minister to the Premier, Don Wright, had said that there are many times when Ottawa and Victoria may have different priorities and policy aims where there is not alignment.
Rohini Arora: Got it. Thank you.
Bryan Tepper: I don’t really have a question. I’ve appreciated this sort of action that we needed to do for a long time. If I can just say anything, I will be pushing for this at the end of the consultation, so thank you for being here.
Paul Choi (Chair): A quick question from me. Could you give us an example of some of the credit unions that are in this dilemma right now?
Henry Han: I think for extraprovincial, both Vancity and Beem…. For them to effectively grow and compete, they need to grow members and they need to grow deposits. They have two pathways. Either B.C. signs an agreement for extraprovincial and allows them to grow into other provinces, or they have to leave the provincial system and become a federal credit union.
The other opportunity is for some of the niche players, like Sharons and Khalsa credit unions, which have a very niche value proposition and very niche demographic that they can cater to in the Ontario market. It would be very competitive to the other financial institutions in that market.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Sounds good. Well, thank you so much for your presentation and answering those questions.
We will now move on to our next presenter. We have next Morie Ford from Mount Pleasant Neighbourhood House.
Welcome, and thanks for joining us. You have five minutes for presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You may begin when you’re ready.
Mount Pleasant Neighbourhood House
Morie Ford: Hi. My name is Morie Ford.
I’m coming to you from the unceded territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm, Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ Peoples.
I’m grateful to speak with you today about the power of literacy programs in British Columbia. I’m going to ask you to do two things. I’m going to ask you to increase the funding support for the literacy outreach coordination in our province, and I’m also going to ask you to enhance the support for the community adult literacy programs — for short, we call them the CALP programs — in our province.
[9:00 a.m.]
A little bit, first, about my own background. I have an education degree, and I’ve been able to teach children from all grades, 1 through grade 12. I also have a TESL certificate, so I have been able to teach adults in English as a second language. I’ve been the co-founder of two non-profits in the province of British Columbia, both of them focused on literacy in our province. I’m currently the chairperson for the Writers Exchange, which serves kids in the Downtown Eastside.
If you look behind me, you would see that I have a nicely framed certificate signed by John Horgan because I’ve also received the COFL Award for the literacy contributions that I’ve made in the province.
I want to speak with you first about the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs, which currently funds LOC programs in 400 communities in British Columbia. As an LOC coordinator, I pull my task force together to help me identify the literacy gaps in our community. Last year we identified many gaps. I wish to share with you information about two of them.
The first one was a digital literacy program that we knew needed to be served for the seniors in our community, so we set up a digital literacy café, which, also, we outsourced to two other locations so that those seniors that were more isolated could receive the digital literacy support that they needed.
We set up homework club for newcomer immigrant students in grades 8 to 12. If you were here on Saturday, you would see that there were 20 kids who came to homework club last Saturday to receive the support that they need to help them, especially with math and English, as they integrate into our school communities.
I’m asking you as a committee to increase funding for the LOCs who, like myself, take that ten or 15 hours a week. I’m asking you to increase their budget to $4.5 million from the current $2.18 million that is now given from the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs.
I’d also like to speak with you about the Ministry of Post-Secondary and Future Skills, which currently funds about 67 CALP programs to our most vulnerable populations. This includes Indigenous families and newcomers and immigrants — those with low levels of literacy. The program that I coordinate, called family literacy outreach, serves 50 newcomer refugee and immigrant families, mostly their mothers, whom I support by providing them with a one-on-one tutor who connects with them each week to deliver a program that helps them enhance their reading, writing, speaking and listening skills.
I wish that I had time to share with you some of the ripple effects that have come from this CALP program. I’m asking you to increase the budget to $4.5 million for that particular program. I know that you know, as well as I do, the ripple effects and the power that literacy has as it helps to break the cycle of homelessness and poverty and helps keep children and teens, our most vulnerable group of young people, away from the justice system in British Columbia.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the presentation. Just seeking some clarification. Were you looking for $4.5 million for each program or for both programs?
Morie Ford: Each.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): The total ask, then, is $9 million?
Morie Ford: That’s right.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Thank you for the presentation. Also just following up, what is the CALP program currently at right now?
Morie Ford: The CALP program is $3.5 million. I think I just wanted to emphasize that I’m telling you a very urban story from the city of Vancouver. There are CALP programs and there are LOC coordinators throughout the whole province of British Columbia, each one serving their communities in a different way.
[9:05 a.m.]
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Just a quick follow-up on that.
The $9 million is not just for your organization. It’s for the programs as a total for the province, or is that just for your program?
Morie Ford: No, that’s exactly right. It’s to increase the funding at the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs to $4.5 million. That would cover the LOCs in the province of British Columbia, but the Ministry of Post-Secondary and Future Skills currently funds $3.4 million for CALP, and that needs to increase to $4.5 million.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Seeing no other questions, thank you so much for presenting to us and for your time today.
We will now move on to our next presentation. Next we have Melanie Stewart from University of British Columbia.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes of questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
University of British Columbia
Melanie Stewart: Thank you and good morning. My name is Melanie Stewart, vice-president, external relations for UBC. Really appreciate the opportunity to speak with the committee at such a pivotal time.
As the government works to strengthen the economy and improve British Columbians’ health and well-being in the midst of a challenging global environment, UBC and the post-secondary sector are key partners in building resilience and unlocking new sources of growth.
UBC is the province’s largest post-secondary institution and one of the world’s top-ranking universities, educating more than 73,000 students and celebrating 16,000 new graduates each year. We are also the largest research university in western Canada, attracting more than $900 million in research funding annually for projects that underpin and drive innovation across all sectors of our economy.
Through continued close collaboration with governments, industry and communities, we can translate our efforts and strengths into new economic advantages that will make B.C. more competitive and prosperous. That is why our first recommendation is to better leverage post-secondary institutions to advance B.C.’s priorities. Foundational to this, we emphasize the need to maintain a strong public system.
We’re thankful for the provincial government’s long-standing commitment to public institutions through robust and predictable operating grants. These annual grants support the core academic mission of B.C. institutions. For UBC, this means that we can deliver excellent, accessible undergraduate and graduate education and that our students, faculty and staff can undertake groundbreaking and innovative research.
Last year the government embarked on a review of the post-secondary system. UBC has appreciated the opportunity to engage in that process. We look forward to the review’s insights and are working with the government on strategies to ensure we have a sustainable system that delivers for British Columbians.
A robust post-secondary system also positions B.C. to take advantage of opportunities to drive significant economic growth through the province’s Look West economic plan and as part of major federal initiatives, such as the defence industrial strategy.
In developing its sector action plans under Look West, we urge the government to partner with UBC on strategies and initiatives that drive growth in areas where the university leads globally — AI, quantum technologies, life sciences, critical minerals and marine and advanced manufacturing.
Second recommendation is for the province to maintain its highly collaborative approach to helping B.C.’s public institutions welcome international students under the federal cap. International students are a vital part of our academic communities and represent an essential talent pipeline for B.C. We encourage the province to continue engagement and advocacy with the federal government to ensure that high-quality public institutions can continue to attract the talent that B.C. needs.
Finally, our third recommendation is to invest in key infrastructure that supports institutions and B.C. communities. Aging academic infrastructure, like UBC’s 1960s-era chemistry building, is limiting our ability to provide modern education, training and research experiences in science, health and engineering programs while, at the same time, imposing high maintenance costs and safety risks. Replacing this building is a top priority for us.
Affordable housing is also key to attracting and retaining talent, students, faculty and staff. UBC is grateful for the government’s investments in student housing, and we’re ready to build more. Our next priority is additional resource space in the Okanagan.
[9:10 a.m.]
Finally, the Broadway subway extension to UBC remains a vital investment in B.C.’s productivity and growth. It will improve the way over 80,000 students, faculty and staff from across Metro Vancouver and the region access campus daily and will unlock major transit-oriented housing development, about 50,000 units. We urge the province to intensify joint efforts to leverage federal infrastructure funds so that these vital projects can move forward to deliver benefits for British Columbians.
Taken together, these recommendations will make significant contributions to a thriving economy and healthy communities in B.C.
Thank you so much for your time today and your consideration of UBC’s input.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the presentation. You mentioned the replacement of the chemistry building. Is there a specific amount or ask included in what is needed for investment in that building from the provincial government?
Melanie Stewart: These are expensive infrastructure developments. I’ll just say that up front. What we have done is taken the significant investment and tried to parse it out into phase 1 and phase 2. We’re calling them “science one and two,” each one of which is about $400 million, so they are significant investments.
Just to be clear about these buildings, chemistry is fundamental to all of our science programs and tech programs across campus. It’s not simply for creating chemists. They’re vital infrastructure. The building currently has things like wood hoods and lab tables nailed to the floor. It’s challenging, and it is starting to become a bit of a safety challenge for us as well.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): A clarifying question then. I’m assuming you’re not expecting the provincial government to fund the full $400 million per phase. I’m just wondering. Are there other partners? What is your funding structure for what the ask is of provincial government? Is it a third? Is it a half?
Melanie Stewart: Well, we are interested in whatever partnership model we can come up with.
Certainly, we are also always engaged in philanthropy, which we’ve been quite successful with, with various buildings, whether it be with the Gateway building or other infrastructure buildings.
Of course, we recognize that the province is in challenging times as well. We will be investing as much as we can, but the scale of this does require partnerships all around. I think it’s important to consider how we might be able to leverage federal funding going forward as well.
Bryan Tepper: Just having mentioned the federal funding, do you know what the, I guess, provincial investment would be to unlock federal funds, or is there an amount on that right now?
Melanie Stewart: I have been in touch with the Ministry of Infrastructure around the federal infrastructure, build communities strong — these kinds of programs that are in development. My understanding is there are still negotiations going on between the province and the federal government about how those programs will look, what the criteria for investment will look like. Most of these are matching programs, so 50-50 between the federal and the provincial for investment.
Paul Choi (Chair): A question from me. My understanding is whenever there are these sorts of projects, major projects like this at the school, there is an internal call for donation or fundraising that’s done. I’m just curious if any of that has been done for this project as well.
Melanie Stewart: Yes, we always engage in fundraising for our projects. We had quite significant fundraising success with the Powerhouse building, which is the Sauder building. We’ll of course be engaged in that effort, as well, around the science one and two buildings, chemistry.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Thank you.
Have there been any commitments or any donations that have been received so far?
Melanie Stewart: I don’t know that anything’s been confirmed at this time, but as I say, it’s our next priority for development.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Sounds good. Thank you so much.
Rohini Arora: This is an aside, but I am curious about this. I know that the TAs organized at UBC recently. I’m wondering about the workers that are in food and janitorial. I’m wondering if there’s any plan to bring them in.
[9:15 a.m.]
Melanie Stewart: I’m not sure where that’s at. I know there have been ongoing discussions with labour relations around all of this, and we’re still in the process of collective bargaining for this round. We still have a number of collective bargaining agreements that are outstanding, but I think that’s something to certainly be alive to, going forward.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
Melanie Stewart: Thank you very much, committee.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. We will be moving on to our next presenter.
Interjection.
Paul Choi (Chair): Oh, well, okay.
Well, we have next Abigail Armstrong.
Thank you so much for joining us. You have five minutes for presentation and five minutes for questions after.
I will now turn it over to you to begin when you’re ready.
Abigail Armstrong: I was wondering if you guys could spend more of the money towards education because there’s…. We lost almost all of our art supplies after the first term. The primaries don’t have…. The intermediates don’t have white card stock anymore, so we can’t do posters for our presentations, and we have to share glue sticks sometimes.
My sister was told that she wasn’t allowed to have a Band-Aid unless she was bleeding because they didn’t have a lot. She had to suck it up till the end of school, and she told me it was really painful for her.
Then there’s the janitors. At the beginning of the year, when they cut janitors, I had…. There was a boy in my class. He threw up, and we had to stay in the counsellor’s room for the rest of the day because there wasn’t a janitor to clean it up.
They also cut band, so we can’t do that anymore as an extracurricular activity. For people who are interested in music, they can’t do that anymore.
There’s also something other, that’s not like education. It’s like…. They’re closing the Michael J. Fox Theatre for other uses, other than the school. It’s the only theatre in Burnaby, I think, and I remember that my…. I was doing a dance competition there, and I was the most happy I’ve ever been in my life on that stage, so I was really sad when I found out they were closing it for the public.
I think that’s it.
Oh, yeah. I am appreciating the money you spent on the Royal Columbian Hospital, though, because that’s a really good use of it. That’s all for now.
Paul Choi (Chair): Well, thank you so much for your presentation, Abigail.
We will now turn to questions, and we’ll now turn to MLA Arora.
Rohini Arora: Well, hello, Abigail. It is so exciting to see you here advocating for yourself and your fellow peers in the Burnaby school system.
You mentioned about janitors and band. I’m curious. You mentioned a number of services that we would consider non-essential, in terms of what is essential to a child’s curriculum. Do you have any thoughts about janitors per school? What have you thought about in terms of what’s needed?
[9:20 a.m.]
You did mention the issue with a child. There was…. Someone had vomited, and you had to stay in the school counsellor’s office during that portion of time.
Have you thought about how many janitors are needed?
Abigail Armstrong: Yes. Well, not particularly, but pretty much, because….
Rohini Arora: Would you say like one or two per school?
Abigail Armstrong: Well, yeah, because we only had nighttime janitors, so we didn’t really learn a lot at that time. We were playing with Lego for two hours in the counsellor’s office.
Rohini Arora: Thanks for sharing that. You said a nighttime janitor. That was what it was before, before it was cut? Is that correct?
Abigail Armstrong: No, they had daytime janitors.
Rohini Arora: Ah, okay. I see. What you’re asking for is that a daytime janitor come back, yes?
Abigail Armstrong: Yeah.
Rohini Arora: Okay. Thank you, Abigail. Thanks for your presentation, and nice to see you.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions by other members?
Abigail, what I will say, one thing, is regarding the Michael J. Fox Theatre. We heard from many students and parents as well, how much that means to them. We completely agree. We need to figure out a way to make sure it stays open and available to the public.
Now, for the Michael J. Fox Theatre, it is not us at the provincial level that deal with that. It’s the school board and the city councillors. I’ve spoken to them, and they are, as we speak, doing everything they can to make sure it can continue to run. We should be able to hear some updates by end of this month.
We are with you. We hear you. We are really working hard to make sure we can keep it open, so stay tuned for that.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you very much. You did a great job on your presentation.
One of the things I heard that I think we need to think about is the loss of the art supplies in your classroom and the sharing of glue sticks, which, to me, is kind of a sad state. How much…? You said that you ran out of art supplies in the first term and that the primary no longer has card stock. Did it all run out in the first term? How were you getting through the rest of the year with your art supplies?
Abigail Armstrong: Well, my teacher bought us a lot of art supplies just for our classroom, but we have two art rooms, one for the primaries and one for the intermediates. The intermediates ran out of card stock, and the primaries ran out of white paper. We got through the rest of the year, but only with the materials that were exclusive to the classroom.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): It sounds like your teacher bought the supplies you needed to get you through the year, but did that from their own personal money.
Abigail Armstrong: Yeah.
And my sister has to write down her spelling words in her planner or on scrap paper because they want to save paper. They have the kids write it down themselves, and sometimes they don’t write it down properly. A lot of the parents have said that their kids haven’t been tested on the right words that they were practising because they didn’t write down the right words because they have different levels.
Paul Choi (Chair): Well, thank you so much for your presentation. Hopefully, next time we can improve it and see some of your drawing as well when you present to us. Thank you so much, Abigail, and thanks to your parents, as well, for giving you space to do this. Hope you enjoy the rest of the day.
All right. We will move on to our next presenter. We have Michael Aikins with us now, from Arrowsmith Health Care Society.
Thank you for joining us. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You may begin when you’re ready.
[9:25 a.m.]
Arrowsmith Health Care (2011) Society
Michael Aikins: Good morning to the select standing committee and Members of the Legislative Assembly. My name is Michael Aikins, and I have the great honour to be the CEO at Arrowsmith Health Care Society. I want to thank you for the opportunity to meet this morning.
I’m addressing this committee from the traditional and unceded territory of the K’ómoks First Nation.
Arrowsmith Health Care Society is a non-profit operator, publicly funded long-term-care, assisted-living adult day program and a Meals on Wheels program located in beautiful Parksville. The organization has been serving the frail elderly of the Oceanside area for 55 years.
I come here today on behalf of the frail and vulnerable citizens, along with their families, to impress upon this committee that this is a critical time when this government needs to get serious about implementing a fair and sustainable funding model for long-term care and strengthening the health human resources strategy for seniors care.
In the 2026 budget consultation paper, one of the priorities was safeguarding critical services in turbulent times. Frail and vulnerable seniors and their families know every day that long-term care provides critical services, and the time is now to safeguard this through a fair and sustainable funding model.
The current system is not sustainable. The organization I represent just finished the last fiscal year with a large deficit, despite not doing anything differently from the last several years, in which we were able to balance our budget through strong financial oversight.
It should be noted that to date, we never did receive a funding letter for 2025-26, and of course, we don’t have a funding letter for this fiscal year. We face the prospect of another large deficit unless the funding model is addressed or we make significant cuts to service. The situation will not be resolved with some belt-tightening as there is simply no slack to cut in seniors care.
As a long-standing, reputable non-profit provider, we understand very well how tight margins are. However, with rising costs and the removal of supplemental overtime funding, it is no longer sustainable.
Service cuts to quality will be necessary. These frail, vulnerable people — who could very well be our mothers, fathers, grandparents or spouse — face the prospect of operators eliminating quality-of-life services such as music therapy; horticultural therapy; bus outings, as the cost of fuel and maintenance of buses is making this unaffordable; special meals; special entertainment — just to name a few. We all know as operators that the actual accountability is to provide direct care hours. This is all the funding model seems to permit.
The sustainability is placed at further risk with the unilateral decision to move all operators to the HEABC agreement, which adds further strain to balance budgets.
With the current human health resources crisis in this province, too many shifts that are vacant need to be filled at overtime. This impacts quality because staff are overburdened, tired, prone to injury and illness by being overworked. These excessive overtime costs have created this unsustainable situation we find ourselves in. The health authority said to us in 2025 that they would no longer fund incremental overtime costs without adequately having a health human resources strategy in place.
I would like to add that Arrowsmith has never had to rely on any agency staff or travel nurses, as they are often referred to, likely one of the smallest of organizations to do this, which should speak to the efforts we make to be an employer of choice. Despite this, the temp and casual staff is not there to support the needs of our frail and vulnerable populations.
[9:30 a.m.]
I do want to recognize the province has made efforts with the health care access program, international recruitment, improving the pathway for interprovincial credentialing, among other efforts. However, we need to work together to find other ways to address the critical health care shortage, and it’s simply too soon to eliminate the incremental overtime funding.
Recruitment is impacted by the new patient-staff ratios in acute care, which draws staff from long-term-care homes. Why would staff want the excessive workload in long-term care? Many job seekers are not seeing long-term care as an attractive workplace because of the increased acuity of residents and feeling of being overworked and overburdened, at risk of injury due to workload and the absence of feeling like they are contributing to the quality of life of residents they are caring for.
The time is now for targeted year-over-year investment to bring the sector up to four hours of care per resident, as well as a targeted strategy to address training, recruitment and retention needs.
Thank you for your time and attention.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation. I hope you can hear me without too much delay.
Now we’ll turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the presentation. You mentioned that you had not received your funding letter for this fiscal. I’m just wondering. What is the current expected budget that you’re thinking you’re getting for this fiscal versus what you need?
Michael Aikins: Well, we’re operating on status quo, and typically, funding letters don’t come until the fall.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): What is the status quo?
Michael Aikins: Operating with the…. We know we have the funding that was in place for last year. We continue with that, and we continue to have to meet our direct care obligations.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): What is your funding ask for the standing committee? What is the ask that you’re putting into the committee for? How much money do you need?
Michael Aikins: Well, that’s with the sustainable funding model, to have up to four hours per resident per day. We understand that may be a committed investment year over year. Currently we’re at 3.36.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for taking the time to present to us today.
Michael Aikins: Well, it’s this sector, right? It’s not just for our organization. It’s long-term care throughout the province. We are currently at 3.36. We need to get incremental costs funded, moving us up to even 3.5, with the goal to get us up to 4.0. The seniors advocate has presented the goal of 4.0 hours per day several years ago.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now take a short recess.
The committee recessed from 9:33 a.m. to 9:51 a.m.
[Paul Choi in the chair.]
Paul Choi (Chair): I will call the committee back to order and move to our next presenter.
We have Julie-Ann Hunter from the Victoria Youth Empowerment Society.
Thanks for coming and joining us in person today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Victoria Youth Empowerment Society
Julie-Ann Hunter: Okay. Thank you so much.
I have the distinct privilege of being the executive director of the Victoria Youth Empowerment Society. We are a community-based organization that has supported youth and families across greater Victoria for more than 30 years. Each year we support more than 1,000 youth and families through prevention, early intervention, wellness, outreach, shelter and crisis services.
Across all these programs, we are seeing the same trend. The challenges facing young people are becoming increasingly complex. Young people are not coming to us with a single issue that can be addressed through a single service. More often we are seeing the intersection of mental health concerns, substance use, financial pressures, social isolation and family conflict. These challenges are interconnected and often reinforce one another.
While community organizations have always played a critical role in supporting youth and families, the growing complexity of needs means that these supports are more important than ever and have to be expanded, because there is hope. We are seeing more youth and families reaching out for support earlier. Parents and youth are looking for guidance, practical support and connection before situations reach a crisis point. We are seeing this change, and despite the increasing complexity, youth and families continue to seek help.
Unfortunately, the willingness to engage is too often met with wait-lists and limited service capacity. Too often there is a gap between prevention and crisis response, leaving youth and families with few options until challenges become significantly more severe and more difficult to address. It often means one bad day or one bad week becomes a whole bad year or multiple bad years.
From our perspective, this represents one of the greatest opportunities for investment in British Columbia’s social service system. The good news is we know what works and we have the infrastructure. Community-based organizations provide accessible, relationship-based wraparound support that helps youth and families receive help earlier.
One of the most effective investments we can make is in youth worker and early intervention programs, such as our life skills workers or our supported independent workers, who help youth up to 24. These youth workers build trusted relationships, help young people navigate challenges, connect them to resources and provide support before issues escalate into crisis.
We also know that family support services are critical. Increasingly, our youth and family support services are seeing parents and caregivers seeking guidance and practical support as they look to help their young folks become good adults. They are navigating increasingly complex challenges alongside their youth, and we know that youth do best when adults around them are supported.
Finally, youth need safe, low-barrier spaces where they feel comfortable seeking support. At YES, more than 40 percent of youth first connect to us through basic needs support, such as food, hygiene or safe places to spend time. These initial connections often become pathways to mental health support, family support, life skills development, shelter and housing assistance and long-term well-being.
Our alliance club provides this type of space. It offers a welcoming environment where youth can access meals and activities, trusted adults and meaningful connection without stigma or barrier. More importantly, it serves as a gateway into a broader continuum of support. These spaces and workers act as a critical community safety net. By creating places where basic needs can be met and relationships can be built, young people are more likely to seek supports earlier and access help before challenges escalate.
Can you imagine when a young person gets to walk into a space like this and says, “I need help,” and they are met with: “How do we do this today?”
[9:55 a.m.]
This model also reduces pressures on shelters, health care systems and child welfare systems. When we are able to provide prevention early, we know that reduces costs across the board. Put plainly, dealing with one bad day or one bad week is much more cost-effective than dealing with the bad years that we know come after if it hasn’t been dealt with.
Our recommendation is threefold.
First, increase investment, through MCFD, in community-based prevention and early intervention services, including youth outreach and other supports that help young people access assistance before challenges escalate into crisis.
Secondly, increase investment in accessible family support services that provide practical, relational-based assistance before families require more intensive interventions.
Thirdly, increase investment in safe, low-barrier youth spaces that provide integrated access to wraparound supports and connect youth to a broader continuum of care.
The good news is that British Columbia already has a strong network of community organizations delivering these services today. These investments can be small. For example, for us, $80,000 would allow us to double our youth and family support services, and $50,000 would allow our drop-in to be open seven days a week.
Thank you so much for your time. I have a bit longer, but I see I’m out of time, so I will leave it there.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now go to questions by members.
Rohini Arora: Thank you for being here and for filling us in about some of the aspects of the work that you do.
I’m curious. Do you work with other…? As you mentioned, there are organizations and other, basically, community-based infrastructure that exists throughout the province — something like Foundry, for example. Do you end up using or connecting youth with Foundry services? Do you find that happens?
Julie-Ann Hunter: Yeah, actually, the Foundry in Victoria is across the street from our building, which is really great, so we end up connecting each other, I find. Often it will be that we take them over for that medical support, and then often they’re bringing families over if they need additional family support or youth worker support.
Rohini Arora: Can I follow up?
When you say that you connect each other…. So they send youth to you. What is the gap that the Foundry is unable to address specifically so that they send them to you?
Julie-Ann Hunter: I think one of them…. The Foundry model in Victoria is slightly different than other Foundries as well. I just want to preface that it’s a smaller model, so that might be part of it. For instance, because we have the drop-in space…. We’re open five days a week. Youth can come over, access food, showers, laundry. I would say that would be one of the pieces that comes.
We also have support services that go from 12 to 24 for youth. Often that youth worker support is more of a wraparound piece that they might not necessarily have as much space that they can access.
Rohini Arora: From 12 to 24, ages 12 to 24?
Julie-Ann Hunter: Yeah, that’s what we do.
Rohini Arora: And I think Foundry starts at 14.
Julie-Ann Hunter: I believe so. Please don’t quote me on that, but I believe so, yes.
Rohini Arora: Okay. That’s important to know.
Then you talked about how $80K would allow you to double your…. Was it the drop-in that would be open for $50,000?
Julie-Ann Hunter: The drop-in — $50,000 would allow us to be open for seven days a week. We’re open for 4½ right now, based on funding. And the 80….
Rohini Arora: What time to what time?
Julie-Ann Hunter: We are open Monday through Thursday, nine to five, and then on Fridays right now, we’re open nine till two.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for your presentation. It was very informative.
Early in your presentation, you had talked about how the cases were becoming more complicated and that you saw the need to get in earlier. What kinds of activities or funding do you require to get into that earlier intervention to get into, obviously, keeping family together and all of the work?
Julie-Ann Hunter: I would say it’s twofold.
One is having the right structure of family workers and youth workers together to work with younger youth so that we’re supporting both at the same time. Often you have funding for one or the other. You’re either supporting parents or you’re supporting youth. So that family support.…
Then having opportunity to provide things like wellness support activities. Young people, especially those younger ones, 12 — if I’m being frank, we often get referrals for ten-year-olds at our services now — require a different model, and a lot of it is social-based. You need to be able to give them accessible social opportunities within funding so that you build up that trust with them. At the end of the day, they’re still young kids.
I would say youth and parent support in the model and then also the capacity to do wellness activities with those younger youth.
[10:00 a.m.]
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for taking the time to come and present to us today.
Okay. Now we’ll have the next presenter, Roger Hind from B.C. Marine Parks Forever Society, come to the front.
Thank you for joining us. Well, you’ve seen how it’s done before, so we have five minutes for presentation and five minutes for questions after.
You may begin whenever you’re ready to go.
B.C. Marine Parks Forever Society
Roger Hind: The Council of B.C. Yacht Clubs, a non-profit society, has represented recreational boaters on both salt water and fresh water since 1956. It is composed of 45 British Columbia boating organizations. The council maintains representation on provincial and federal committees to provide and receive information pertinent to our interests and expertise.
We fulfil a role as protectors of marine areas, reporting violations such as pollution, industrial debris on shores, etc. We support small communities on the coast, bringing significant revenue, providing income and jobs.
The council formed the B.C. Marine Parks Forever Society to advocate for and financially support the creation, expansion or enhancement of B.C. marine parks. We’ve contributed more than $2.6 million to the betterment of over 20 marine parks and installed mooring buoys and over 186 stern ties to protect sensitive holding grounds and support safe anchoring.
Recreational boating is a major economic driver in the province, supporting more than 17,000 direct jobs. Clearly, recreational boating is very important to the province’s economy, and as such, in our role as spokespersons for 15,000 members, we make the following suggestions regarding the 2027 budget.
One, protection of anchorages in marine parks and other protected areas, including conservancies and ecological reserves, through increased installation of infrastructure, such as mooring buoys, dinghy docks and stern tie pins.
Two, enhanced provincial staff park ranger coverage of marine parks and expansion of volunteer park host programs. These programs both offer protection to sensitive areas. The park host volunteers greet visitors and provide useful information about the various marine parks and are often the eyes and ears to ensure park protection. B.C. Parks staff report their presence, and it’s very helpful to the contracted park operators and to the provincial staff responsible for the parks.
Three, sewage pump-out stations. Boaters along the B.C. coast are finding that the low number of sewage pump-out stations along the coast or that are not working, especially further north, is problematic. Holding tanks aboard vessels have limited capacity, and skippers are left without an environmentally responsible solution for the disposal of blackwater.
That’s my initial…. I got through quicker than I thought.
Paul Choi (Chair): That’s always good. Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll move on to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you very much for your presentation. You talked about protection of anchorages. Is that a funding request or a policy request, where you need permissions to be faster for them installed, or is it a funding request?
Roger Hind: Primarily, the Marine Parks Forever Society has funded most of the stern tie programs as well as, recently, some of the mooring buoys — for instance, at D’Arcy Island. Although that’s in the Gulf Island national marine park system, we actually have extensive experience with the Gulf Islands and Desolation Sound.
Primarily, what has been happening is…. We have actually purchased a lot of the facility to put those things in, and then, subject to B.C. Parks funding models, sometimes we’ve been provided some money for that. Other times we’ve actually put it in on our own, using our own budgets themselves, so kind of a bit of both.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): For clarification, then, is the ask for more funding for that, or is it, again, a policy request where you’re having problems getting the policy to get them installed?
[10:05 a.m.]
Roger Hind: A bit of both. What we’re finding is it’s more difficult to actually get the proposals through because of archaeological requirements.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Bryan Tepper: Just for example, Cabbage Island, the moorage there — it’s B.C. Parks that takes care of it?
Roger Hind: Correct. Yeah.
Bryan Tepper: Are the islands, then, federal…? It’s got a closure on it, basically, right? Is that a federal or a provincial closure?
Roger Hind: That, I believe, is federal.
Bryan Tepper: On things like that, then, do we have any concerns on moving forward and getting permissions, permits, when we have federal closures on the land and then provincial orders for the water?
Roger Hind: At the moment, we’re actually trying to get the federal government to explain why they did close that. The help of the provincial government, in terms of lobbying for….
For instance, American boaters do spend an awful lot of money and time up here, and what we’re suggesting to the feds right now is that they’d perhaps consider what Washington state and the federal government of the United States have done, which is basically put into place a visiting fee, if you will.
The Americans have had that for many years, as you may be aware, what’s called a cruising licence, but Transport Canada and CBP have actually been a little bit slow in agreeing to do that, I think, probably because of the cost of actually implementing such a program.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): On the sewage pump-out stations, are those stations managed by your organization or B.C. Parks?
Roger Hind: They actually are managed by marinas, as well as federal docks. Whoever actually is agreeable to having one, we’re thrilled to have them. Americans are actually quite used to having sewage pump-out stations. B.C.’s and federal laws are that you can’t pump within three nautical miles of a land area.
For instance, I was up in the Broughtons last year, and regrettably, two of the pump-out stations that were there were just not available for use because they’d broken down, one in Alert Bay and another one in Port MacNeill.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): If we were to try to install more, it would have to be through some kind of incentive program, for those particular types of businesses to invest in that?
Roger Hind: Yes, for any marina facilities that a lot of people tend to go to. I think the big thing is that the Central Coast pretty much has none. The farther north you go, the fewer there are.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
We will now go to our next presenter, who is online. We have Margareta Dovgal from Resource Works Society.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You may begin when you’re ready.
Thank you so much, Mr. Chair, members of the committee, fellow presenters, guests. It’s a pleasure to be here this morning.
We appreciate the opportunity to address the 2028 B.C. budget committee on behalf of Resource Works Society, based in Vancouver. We advocate for responsible natural resource development as the cornerstone of British Columbia’s economy — jobs, communities, public services.
We all rely on our resources sectors to get us to the quality of life that we enjoy here in B.C. Natural resources underpin our province’s fiscal health, funding hospitals, schools, infrastructure and families from urban centres, like the one I live in, in Vancouver, to rural and northern regions across the province.
As we shape the 2028 budget, British Columbia continues to navigate fiscal deficits. We have global economic uncertainty; trade pressures, including with our trading partners in the United States; and the imperative for sustainable growth.
[10:10 a.m.]
Resource Works has consistently emphasized, in our commentary, that a strong resource sector is essential to avoid deeper fiscal challenges. LNG and natural gas revenues, alongside minerals, provide critical support during volatile times.
I want to give some credit where it’s due to the B.C. government. Budget 2026 and subsequent measures included welcome steps forward, such as investing more than $40 million over three years to streamline permitting, reduce duplication and cut barriers across natural resource and tourism sectors. This built on gains like issuing nearly 35 percent more mineral exploration permits in 2025 compared to 2024 and reducing timelines for major mine applications by 35 percent since 2019.
Forestry also received targeted supports amid industry pressures and new strategic investment tools that aim to attract capital into clean energy, sustainable manufacturing, responsible mining. These actions demonstrate recognition of the need for efficiency and growth in our foundational sectors.
We also value the deep expertise offered by leading industry associations, including the B.C. Business Council, Mining Association of B.C., Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers and the Council of Forest Industries. Their submissions and analysis have provided valuable insights on permitting reform, competitiveness and the sector’s outsized contributions — over $40 billion in exports and a significant share of provincial GDP and revenues.
We align with their calls for practical measures to unlock investment while maintaining environmental and social standards. Many of these groups have highlighted ongoing opportunities such as B.C.’s portfolio of advanced mining projects with potential for substantial economic activity, jobs and tax revenues. A focused effort to increase resource output could generate billions more in GDP. Given the size of the deficit that we’re currently facing, we believe these are integral, must-be-considered opportunities.
Forestry, energy and mining are vital for economic security, and as we are diversifying markets and building resilience against external shocks, we really urge the government to be looking at ways that we can make use of these abundant opportunities. Calls for faster permitting, regulatory certainty, competitive taxation and a strong emphasis on getting major projects built efficiently reflect widely shared priorities across the resource community. These align with the need for fiscal discipline, red-tape reduction and maximizing the benefits of our natural endowment for all British Columbians.
Some of the challenges that we’ve seen emerge recently include the expansions of the provincial sales tax to certain professional services that have increased input costs for resource projects. Forestry continues to face fibre-access issues, cost, market pressures. Despite the targeted aid, there are large deficits and growing debt-servicing costs that require careful management, even as resource revenues driven by LNG and minerals are projected to rise.
We need policy stability and predictability to attract the long-term capital our province needs. For the next budget, Resource Works recommends:
One, further accelerate mining permitting and permitting generally with fixed, enforceable timelines; digital modernization; and coordinated one-project, one-review processes.
Two, strengthen competitiveness by continuing to work so that royalties, taxes and regulations ensure that B.C. remains attractive for investment relative to other jurisdictions that we compete with on a variety of dimensions, balancing public returns with overall project viability.
Three, invest in people and partnerships through skills training aligned with resource careers and expanded, practical Indigenous economic participation models that deliver tangible benefits.
Four, support market diversification infrastructure to mitigate trade risk, enhance ports and transportation corridors and advance a clear vision for a working forest land base alongside value-added manufacturing.
Five, pursue a growth-oriented fiscal policy that protects core services while leveraging resource revenues responsibly. Targeted incentives for processing and innovation in the resource sector will deliver broad returns.
British Columbians recognize that responsibly developed resources are essential to our quality of life and future prosperity, from northern mining operations and coastal LNG facilities to managed forests, sustaining communities. These sectors reconcile economic strength with environmental stewardship.
Resource Works is committed to constructive collaboration with all parties. Let’s make next year a year in which British Columbia can confidently advance its resource advantages, delivering jobs, revenues and resilience for every region and every family.
I look forward to your questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you very much for your presentation.
We’ll move on to questions by members. Any questions?
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the five. There was no actual financial ask and/or policy ask in that that we could help. Further accelerating permitting, obviously, is a big policy ask and vague, in the sense that permits go from everything from water to land tenure.
I’m just wondering if Resource Works themselves have a specific financial or policy ask that would advance those objectives.
[10:15 a.m.]
Margareta Dovgal: Thank you for that question. We’ve done some version of this committee a couple times, and we’re more of an aggregator and facilitator of conversations with resource industries. We’re here in this capacity just to reinforce the broader themes that are emerging from the resource sector and definitely defer to colleagues at the respective associations — COFI, BCBC, CAPP, MABC and others — in terms of the specific asks.
We’re very much advocating for an awareness and ability to leverage those sectors as ways to solve some of our fiscal challenges and would reinforce their calls for specific funding components.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for taking the time to present to us today.
We’ll now move to our next presenter, Carson Binda from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions.
You may begin when you’re ready.
Carson Binda: Some $356,000 on three novelty wood-and-leather soccer balls, $165 cups of coffee and $1,200-per-month vehicle leases for government executives.
Good morning. My name is Carson Binda, and I’m here with the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. I’m here on behalf of hundreds of thousands of taxpayers who have three simple demands for this government in the next provincial budget: (1) stop wasting so much of our money, (2) cancel your tax hikes, and (3) stop recklessly adding to our provincial debt.
Our first recommendation is that this government urgently needs to stop wasting money. Ministers shouldn’t be billing taxpayers $6,600 for SUV limousine services during four-day junkets to the United States. We can’t afford to spend $356,000 on three novelty wood-and-leather soccer balls that the Premier used in a photo op in Japan, $165,000 for 1,000 cups of coffee for a publicity stunt and $370,000 a year on luxury vehicle leases for government executives.
If this government can’t even find savings on $165 cups of coffee, then it’s no wonder B.C. taxpayers are overpaying for the big things too. Hosting a handful of FIFA World Cup soccer games? It was supposed to cost us $230 million. Now that bill has ballooned by more than 200 percent to $729 million.
This government wastes hundreds of millions of dollars per year on corporate welfare and handouts to multinationals. For example, this government is taking more money from families in this budget, turning around and doling it out to multinationals. This government announced a brand-new corporate welfare slush fund which will cost taxpayers $400 million. At the same time, Budget 2026 raises the lowest income tax bracket on British Columbians. That tax hike will cost us $470 million — money right from families to multinationals.
Our second request is that this government cancel its tax hikes from Budget ’26. Your government is hiking taxes on average families by about 16 percent this year. A two-income family of four making $100,000 per year is paying $450 more this year in provincial taxes compared to last year. That $450 is a week’s worth of groceries. It’s four full tanks of gasoline you’re taking from that family.
At the same time, you’re driving businesses and job creators away through your PST hikes. Architects, security guards, engineers, accountants and geologists are all being driven through our provinces through your PST hike on professional services that will cost taxpayers $1.36 billion over the next three years alone. That makes B.C. more expensive, and we’re already seeing the results: 60,000 private sector jobs have been driven away by this government since January alone. The government is squeezing families and chasing jobs away through your tax hikes.
[10:20 a.m.]
That brings us to our third and final recommendation. This government must stop recklessly piling debt onto the backs of B.C. families. Your government has driven up per-capita debt by 95 percent in the past five years alone. Every single British Columbian will owe $41,000 by 2028. Interest on that debt is costing us $6.5 billion this year. It is the third-biggest line item in our provincial budget. Big debts like that are why credit rating agencies, like S&P Global, warn that we have the worst budgetary performance among our peers, not just domestically but internationally too.
Taxpayers have three simple asks. End your wasteful spending, cancel your tax hikes, and stop the debt avalanche that threatens to crush families.
Thank you so much. I look forward to your questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you for your presentation.
We’ll go to questions.
Rohini Arora: Thank you for your presentation. I’m curious. There were some comments regarding the cups of coffee. I think you’re referencing some of the work that was being done by the government to attract U.S. health care workers.
At this point, we’ve reached 700 that have accepted jobs and are going to be coming here. Some have already made their way here. When you say $156 or $165 for cups of coffee, can you clarify exactly what you mean by that? As you know, investments have to be made in order to attract people to the country, and as you know, in this province, doctors, nurses and nurse practitioners are incredibly paramount across the province, especially in rural areas.
The fact that we have seen 700 U.S.-based health care workers accept jobs and are now on their way here…. I’m curious where you stand on that. For taxpayers, one of the top issues has been ensuring we have more health care workers. Based off of the work that was done to attract people, 700, a number that continues to grow…. I would feel it’s a good use of the taxpayers’ dollars, especially because health care is so paramount.
Could you explain to us a little bit about where you’re coming from?
Carson Binda: Absolutely. If anyone thinks a doctor or nurse moved their families across international borders because they were given a $165 cup of coffee, then I’ve got some oceanfront property in south Saskatchewan to sell you.
Look, at the end of the day, this government is driving away families and professionals through tax hikes and debt increases that make British Columbia a less competitive place to do business. Nobody in the world moves their families because government bought them a $165 cup of coffee. It was such a wasteful use of taxpayer dollars. Your government could have gone to Starbucks, bought 1,000 venti caramel Frappuccinos, 1,000 focaccia sandwiches with tomato and mozzarella, left a 50 percent tip, and you still would’ve saved more than $140,000.
This government chose to hand out coffee to American health care workers in the most wasteful way imaginable, and that’s why taxpayers have such a problem with wasteful spending from your government.
Rohini Arora: As a follow-up, just to clarify, what I’m hearing is that you’re saying that taxpayers across the province are not happy with the money that was spent to attract these workers. That, to me, is not making sense, because people are relying on more health care practitioners in this province. That is something that has come as a direct result of that work.
I am hearing you continue to repeat that it was wasteful, but I would like more of an understanding of where you’re coming from on that because it’s not making sense to me.
Carson Binda: When a government tries to justify spending, wasting $165 on a cup of coffee, then it’s no wonder British Columbians are overpaying for the big things too. That kind of justification, rationalizing, is why we’ve seen 200 percent cost overruns on big projects like the FIFA World Cup. It’s why ministers feel comfortable burning 6,600 taxpayer dollars on a four-day junket’s limousine service. Taxpayers are losing faith in your government because your government is hiking taxes and borrowing billions while wasting money.
[10:25 a.m.]
Rohini Arora: Just to clarify, my question was not on the FIFA World Cup. My question is, in particular, about health care workers and the need. British Columbians have been saying themselves that there’s a need for more doctors, a need for more nurses and a need for more nurse practitioners. We have been successful as a result of that investment that was made to attract U.S.-based health care workers to the tune of 700 and growing.
Carson Binda: Do you really expect British Columbians to believe that anyone moved their family across international borders because your government gave them a $165 cup of coffee? Rationalizing answers like that are exactly why we’ve seen our per-capita debt double in the past five years alone. British Columbians are being crushed by a wasteful government that tries to justify $165 cups of coffee instead of looking for savings, looking for questions and looking to be responsible.
Paul Choi (Chair): That is all the time for questions. Thank you for presenting to us.
We will now move on to our next presenter, Bruce Hallsor from Downtown Victoria Business Association.
Thanks for joining us. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Downtown Victoria
Business Association
Bruce Hallsor: Thank you for having me. The 2026 budget comes at a time of great economic uncertainty caused by foreign wars, tariffs and supply chain issues around the world. But there is a domestically caused crisis affecting local businesses in downtown Victoria and elsewhere which has led to an explosion of vandalism, theft and public drug use. These issues not only impact business, but they make people feel unsafe in their own communities.
We know this is having an effect because the DVBA had a record response to our annual survey, with nearly 48 percent of businesses in Victoria indicating they would consider closing or leaving downtown if their lease came due this year.
In order for Victoria’s downtown to survive, here is what we need from the provincial government.
First, the closure of public supervised consumption sites in the downtown core in favour of redistribution of these across the region.
Secondly, the decentralization of social services away from the downtown core, including shelters and supportive housing.
Finally, an immediate increase in funding for detoxification, addiction and mental health treatment beds.
The drugs being used today are supercharged. They have effects on the brain that make it difficult for most to seek voluntary treatment. We need the province to provide involuntary care for those affected. Now, naturally, a process to determine when involuntary orders are made needs to be created, but the constant drain on community safety, police resources and public well-being make involuntary care a necessary option.
While harm reduction is an admirable goal, the geographic concentration of facilities can destroy the community around them. If these sites were relocated and spread out, then people could seek safer usage without running the same risk of attracting criminals who prey on marginalized people, selling drugs to them, encouraging targeted thefts and generally worsening the situation for everyone.
One shelter, supply site or housing site in a community doesn’t have as troublesome an impact as the concentration of services within a few square blocks. Criminals selling drugs and targeting this community have easy access if a greater number of homeless and marginalized people are found in the same location day after day.
For these connected issues, we have petitioned the federal government, seeking bail reform for repeat offenders committing property crimes. We’ve asked the municipal government to provide more funding for police support, bylaw enforcement and community beautification.
Those things have made and are making positive steps, but criminal justice changes and street cleaning will not solve the problem we face. The root cause is addictions and mental health, the treatment of which is the responsibility of the province. More police may be able to subdue fights, remove those breaking windows, but this deals with symptoms and not the disease.
[10:30 a.m.]
It is now ten years since the opioid crisis was declared a public health emergency, and unfortunately, a response of drug acceptance has not provided safe communities, has not reduced harm and has only made the crisis worse.
It is positive that the government has started to adapt to lessons learned, but after ten years, we cannot afford to wait for gradual change. Funding for involuntary treatment and a mandate to decentralize services are two actions which need to take place immediately. If they do not, the tax base to support these programs, which comes from downtown economies across the province, will start to evaporate.
Let me give you an example in downtown Victoria of how involuntary treatment or high-barrier treatment can exist with the community. Part of downtown Victoria, you all know, has a lot of street chaos. Businesses are boarded up. Rental stock is not used in those areas because they’re unattractive.
Just a few blocks away, you have the Salvation Army Addictions Rehabilitation Centre that’s been there for years, a high-end restaurant right beside it, thriving businesses right across from it because there are ways of delivering rehabilitation services that don’t create public disorder, that respect neighbourhoods. These kind of places that do have rules, that are also statistically far more effective at treatment, are what the province needs to be funding, as opposed to more low-barrier places.
Thank you for your time.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now move to questions by members. Questions?
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): I will try and leave space for others.
Thank you very much, Bruce, for your presentation. Your decentralization of services, I understand…. I was in Vancouver yesterday on the way to the helijet. It made me cry, actually, coming through the Downtown Eastside.
I’m just wondering. Is there a specific funding ask, or just the policy change of decentralizing services? Is there a need to increase funding?
Bruce Hallsor: Well, there is a need for increased funding. I know funding is tight, but involuntary, high-barrier treatment programs need to be created. There are not enough of them, and this has to be a priority. It is destroying our local economies to have this kind of street chaos.
That’s why I gave, since I had a little extra time, the example of the Salvation Army as something that can exist downtown. It does not disrupt and is saving lives and is rehabilitating people, versus what the initial response to the opioid crisis was, which was an explosion of low-barrier places concentrated together in neighbourhoods and in Vancouver and Victoria and in communities across the province.
It has carved out areas of downtowns that are not only a no-go space for ordinary citizens but are sucking up huge costs in terms of resources and are destroying economic activity, which ultimately means other taxpayers have to bear the burden. When businesses are closing, that’s a cost. I know of a building in Victoria that had just had its assessment reduced from $20 million to $10 million, just because of where it is. No one wants to buy a building in that area, even though it’s tenanted.
These are economic costs that need to be dealt with, and they’re going to have to be dealt with by spending some money.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Thank you for your presentation. You mentioned in your presentation the increased dollars for detox beds. Do you know how many detox beds are in Victoria, and what you would think would be a number to increase?
Bruce Hallsor: The Downtown Victoria Business Association…. I think we’d be hesitant to get into the forecasting business. We don’t pretend to be health care experts. We just know that more is necessary, and a change in emphasis is necessary.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Do you know how many are in Victoria though, like how many beds? I know how many are in Cowichan Valley, which, I agree, is not enough.
Bruce Hallsor: I couldn’t tell you off the top of my head. I could provide that to you, if you want it.
[10:35 a.m.]
Bryan Tepper: One of my frustrations is the lack of foresight into costing on some of these things. Putting people into secure compassionate care — high barrier, as you said — costs money in advance. Downstream, of course, we’re spending more money than ever on dealing with the effects of, basically, our drug crisis.
Do you have any statistics on costs for, I guess I’ll call it, upstream versus downstream costs, if we’re doing treatment and rehabilitation as opposed to just treating the after-effects?
Bruce Hallsor: It’s extremely hard to be precise with these sorts of things, but certainly, in Victoria, it’s estimated that as much as one-third of the entire police budget is dedicated to problems created by this issue.
Now, I realize that’s a municipal amount, although there are provincial contributions made to it, but as a taxpayer, for society in general, if you could spend less than one-third of the Victoria police budget, you could make a big dent in creating more spaces.
The other thing I would say is, there are a lot of non-profits that are very interested in this and can help with the cost. I think there is space to reach out to faith-based organizations and others that maybe haven’t been tapped in the past.
Bryan Tepper: Yeah, I would tend to agree with that and the policing budget. It’s all taxpayer money in the end. The same people are paying municipally, provincially. I’m sure if the people of Victoria could get some savings municipally, they’d be very happy to have a little contribution from everybody else.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
We’ll have our next presenter, Ryan Mitton from Canadian Federation of Independent Business, come forward.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for the presentation and five minutes for questions after.
You may begin when you’re ready.
Canadian Federation of
Independent Business
Ryan Mitton: Thank you, committee members.
My name is Ryan Mitton. I am the director of legislative affairs in British Columbia for the Canadian Federation of Independent Business. As you may know, the CFIB is a non-profit, non-partisan organization representing more than 103,000 small and medium-sized businesses across Canada, including 10,000 here in British Columbia.
Small businesses make up 98 percent of all businesses in our province. They are resilient and adaptable, but they are operating in an increasingly challenging environment marked by rising costs, regulatory complexity, labour shortages and economic uncertainty.
British Columbia’s SMEs have long provided stability in uncertain times, anchoring communities and driving local economies, but ongoing economic instability is making it harder for many small firms to plan, invest and grow. That’s why when we ask B.C. business owners if they would recommend someone start a small business here in B.C. right now, 63 percent say no — well above the national average of 55 percent.
B.C. is experiencing an entrepreneurial drought, a sustained period when business exits consistently outpace new business starts, leading to a shrinking entrepreneurial base and reduced confidence in the viability of entrepreneurship. To reverse this trend, CFIB is making three recommendations to be included in Budget 2027.
Our first recommendation is to immediately reduce the cost of doing business by permanently lowering the small business tax rate to zero percent by 2030, raising the small business income threshold to $700,000 from $500,000 and indexing that threshold to inflation.
CFIB surveys consistently show strong support for cutting the small business corporate tax rate. For many entrepreneurs, this tax rate improves their ability to pay staff, invest in their operations and ride out economic shocks. It also compensates for some of the disadvantages they have compared to large multinational corporations, like access to financing and large legal teams.
Other provinces are already cutting small business tax rates. Manitoba has had a zero percent tax rate since 2010, while B.C.’s small business tax rate has not been reduced in more than a decade. By growing the grass roots of B.C.’s economy, we can provide long-term sustainable revenues for the province.
Our second recommendation is to compensate local businesses when they are being crushed by government construction projects and enable municipalities to do the same.
[10:40 a.m.]
I simply point to the Broadway line. We have called on the government to create an infrastructure lifeline grant so Broadway small businesses can survive another full year of closures and make sure that when the line is built, they’re still there to welcome customers and enliven their communities.
We’ve heard from local business owners who have had to re-mortgage their houses, who are working multiple jobs, who call us in tears because they don’t know how they’re going to make it through to the next day. This is a provincially funded project. There is a provincial onus to make sure that the community that it serves is still there.
Our third and final recommendation is to stop the PST expansion and the red tape that goes with it. Eighty percent of businesses surveyed have told us they oppose the expansion of the PST to essential professional services like accounting and bookkeeping, and 72 percent say that they’re likely to pass this on to their customers. Entrepreneurs routinely identify PST compliance paperwork as one of their top red-tape irritants, with half citing it as the most burdensome form of regulation.
For example, new rules published by the government of British Columbia say that if you are a national organization or you have retail chains in more than one province — your headquarters is in Toronto, and your accounting is done out of Toronto — if that accounting serves businesses in B.C., you will now have to prorate your PST and accounting costs and calculate it based on the amount of retail presence you have in British Columbia.
Why would anyone want to open a business in B.C. if they’re simply going to pay a tax for the privilege of it? It’s these kinds of red-tape irritants that are fuelling entrepreneurial drought.
I urge the province to stop the expansion of the PST to essential professional services. Ultimately, budget policy should reflect the needs of small businesses, not just the realities of larger firms that are better positioned to absorb higher costs and complexity.
I look forward to your questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you very much for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you very much for the presentation. I think you called it the infrastructure stabilization fund. Is there a number that you have in mind that would meet the need of that or a specific percentage of the project? What do you see as the best way to fund that, and how much is it?
Ryan Mitton: I don’t want to be overprescriptive with designing this. Really, when we hear from businesses, they’re just looking for anything at all at this point.
I think of people like Tara, who owns Üphoria Yoga studio. She and her husband are working multiple jobs to feed their kids and make sure that they can still take them to school and try and keep their business open. Whether it’s tax relief, whether it’s a direct-funding grant, whether it’s interest-free loans — anything at all — any sort of financial assistance would greatly help these small businesses.
I would also point out that this project is funded under a community benefits agreement. We know that these drive down the number of bidders on these projects, drive up project costs. If the province can find it in the budget to run the Broadway line on a CBA, then, presumably, they can find it in the budget to find help for local businesses that are supposed to be benefiting from the project as well.
What they do tell us is that that’s not the case. When you’ve got someone who’s dug a two-storey hole in front of your business, no matter how much signage you put up, people just aren’t going to walk in the door.
Really, what they need is financial help, but I’m completely open to whatever ideas the province may have. That’s just the bottom line.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
I have a question regarding the accounting example you gave, having to sort of prorate and figure out the proportionality of your presence here. Does it work the other way as well? If there is a business in Ontario that is using service in B.C., then do they have to do that as well, or is it different?
Ryan Mitton: Our current understanding, based on guidance published by the province online, is that the 7 percent PST applies to all accounting services and bookkeeping services provided in the province, so that would be a matter of fact. But if you’re also….
I’ll give the example of a Toronto headquarters with a Toronto accounting contract. Say you get a national firm to do your accounting, you’re based out of Toronto, but you have brick-and-mortar presence in B.C. That’s where this kicks in — the pro rata. You have to actually proportion: how much of our presence is in B.C., and then how much do we pay for accounting?
It’s a percentage of a percentage, but then it’s the full 7 percent on any accounting and bookkeeping services provided in the physical location of B.C.
[10:45 a.m.]
Paul Choi (Chair): Ontario, for example, has HST, in my understanding, where everything is covered. If it’s reversed, if there are any businesses that get service from B.C., do they have to…? Is there some component where they’re exempt?
Ryan Mitton: I can’t profess to be an expert in Ontario’s tax code, but what I can tell you is a big, big difference between Ontario’s HST and B.C.’s PST is that Ontario has input tax credits. That’s something that B.C. does not have, and it really hampers our competitiveness as a province when you can’t write off business expenses.
PST applies every single time a service or good is purchased. It stacks up through the supply chain. If you have a widget and it passes through three stages of the supply chain and gets sold each time, that’s 7 percent, and it stacks up each time through the supply chain. We’re getting into 21 percent tax that gets passed on to the consumer at the end of the day.
Now we’re applying it to accounting and bookkeeping services. There’s no real mechanism in B.C.’s tax code to write these off and lessen the amount of burden that’s placed on the end consumer.
Input tax credits are another thing that we would recommend as a big reform to B.C.’s provincial sales tax. It’s not contained in our recommendations today, but that’s something we’ve long called for — reforms to the PST that actually incentivize new investment. It’s been a while since that has been looked at, but it would actually go a long way to making B.C. a more competitive place to do business.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Thank you very much.
Questions? Okay.
Thank you for your presentation today.
Ryan Mitton: Thank you for your time.
Paul Choi (Chair): We will move to our next presenter. We have Greg Moy from Insurance Bureau of Canada.
Thank you for joining. You have five minutes for your questions, five minutes for presentation, in that reversed order.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Greg Moy: Appreciate it. Thanks very much, Mr. Chair, and good to see you again.
Thanks to the committee for allowing me to address you today. My name is Greg Moy. I’m with the Insurance Bureau of Canada. We’re the national association for Canada’s home and business insurers. My industry is often on the front lines rebuilding after a disaster.
Today I come with three recommendations that are focused on improving resiliency towards major floods, wildfires and earthquakes. Final recommendations will be on car insurance, to allow my industry to be part of the solution to bring competition and choice for B.C. drivers.
The second page shows our recommendations, so it’s clear as mud.
Recommendation 1, flood and wildfire. Increase investment in disaster risk reduction for these events.
Two, earthquake. We’re asking for B.C. government and elected officials to advocate with the federal government to make Canada more resilient to a major earthquake. I’ll explain a little bit more on that — why we focus on the feds.
Three, give drivers a choice. Open up auto insurance to competition, and look to Quebec as the model for solutions.
Third page is the slide that we show to all elected officials across the country. You’re seeing a trend that our industry has seen since we started tracking in the 1980s. So 2025 was a lighter year for B.C. and Canada at $2.4 billion in insured loss; 2024, off the scale — $9.4 billion in insured loss.
Insurers are in the business of pricing risk. More wildfires and floods equals more damage through severe weather events. Think of events like Lytton, West Kelowna, the atmospheric river in 2021. B.C. is certainly not immune, and premiums reflect the pricing of risk.
The solution is clear. We must invest more in making our homes, businesses and communities more resilient. It’s important that we start to treat severe weather as a question of when and not if and to begin to act quickly.
Fourth page is our recommendation on flood and wildfire. This year’s budget saw no new funding in adaptation resiliency to flood and wildfire.
One, need to fund B.C.’s adaptation and flood strategies. We have a plan in place. Government has already written it. Let’s invest in it. It’s important to protect from the future costs of recovery.
[10:50 a.m.]
Second piece is that we need to continue using our contingency funds from the provincial government to fund the response and recovery phases of a major wildfire and flood.
Then other items on that page are part of the puzzle for new direct funding, which includes an increase in FireSmart in high-risk communities, updates to building codes, land use planning.
Fifth page is our recommendation for earthquake. Our number one ask is to ask for all B.C. officials to provide their support when engaging the feds to complete the work that they’ve started. That’ll benefit us most here in B.C. when the big one strikes.
Last fall the federal government committed to working on a partnership to address the financial systemic risk from a major earthquake. Addressing this is the first step to working further on earthquake insurance here in B.C. Other provinces will see wildfire and flood as more important, and I think that’s why it’s more important for B.C. to champion the work to increase our resilience to a major earthquake.
One area in my industry, as well, that I know the provincial government and the provincial regulator agree on is that any solution should include B.C.-based insurers as part of that federal solution.
Last, on the sixth page, is our third recommendation — to give drivers a choice and to open up auto insurance to more competition. B.C. drivers, on average, pay roughly 40 percent more than the next no-fault province with the lowest premiums, which is Quebec. B.C. should take a look at Quebec for solutions. Quebec is a no-fault province like B.C., except their insurers can compete to repair the car, and it shows in the price that they pay.
There’s no public policy rationale for having an ICBC monopoly over insurance that repairs your car. Competition can also bring efficiency, such as bundling with home insurance, other innovation efficiencies, by opening up the market to the competition. Our industry would certainly love to be part of the solution here in B.C.
Those are my three recommendations, Mr. Chair, and thanks to the committee again for taking the time to hear me out.
I’m happy to answer any questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll go to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): You mentioned the contingencies for major wildfires and floods. Is it intended that those contingencies would kick in before insurance, or does that lower the insurance costs by having a set amount in contingency?
Greg Moy: I think what I meant by that was…. In past years, government touring major wildfire or flood events will have and utilize…. I think it’s statutory requirements, and I just couldn’t remember if it was the case for this year, when I was going through the provincial budget documents, to ensure that if, say, government resources, B.C. wildfire service, emergency management, EMCR require additional funding, that that funding continue to play an active part.
We’re going into spring freshet and wildfire season, as you would know, and we just wanted to ensure that contingency funding is there for communities to be able to utilize in the event that a major event takes place.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): A follow-up. Yeah, I’m thankful but not that we did not get big spring freshet this year. Princeton is still waiting to repair their flood plan.
You talk in here about the smarter land plan and not building new homes in these areas. Does that include areas where we have…? Will insurance look at flood mitigation measures like Grand Forks has done, for instance, where they’ve invested — I think it’s up to $63 million now — in the flood mitigation around Grand Forks? They did buy up some land to put into floodplain. Would an investment in the flood mitigation cover that off, or do you think those are still places we should not build?
Greg Moy: They will certainly take into account insurers when communities invest in flood mitigation matters, and we’re under no illusions that the country needs to build a lot more housing, not just here in B.C. but right across the country.
Our message to government…. I understand land use planning is more of a municipal jurisdiction and it can be very fragmented and everybody is doing a little bit of different things.
[10:55 a.m.]
That said, it’s our encouragement that all of these pieces be, I guess, examined. Insurers are constantly taking a look at what every level of government is doing for their specific region.
I mean, obviously, we would encourage folks not to build in a known floodplain or known area with high risk of wildfire. That being said, mitigation efforts, FireSmarting of your home, the efforts that you’d mentioned in Grand Forks — that is all taken into account in terms of pricing of risk.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): I’ll go for a clarification if nobody else has one.
On the FireSmart program, I’m assuming you are supportive of continuing that investment in FireSmarting homes?
Greg Moy: Definitely.
Rohini Arora: Thank you for your presentation. I’m curious about FireSmart in particular. You mentioned that we need to continue with investments for smaller municipalities, rural communities, high-risk areas. I’m curious about insurance rates.
We’ve invested $15 million into FireSmart, ongoing, to ensure that…. I think it’s up to 75 communities that can continue with their FireSmart programs, and also, it has protected and saved a community like Logan Lake from fire.
I’m curious. What does that look like at the rate level for the smaller municipalities and rural? Are there savings that are important for us to know?
Greg Moy: That’s a good question. Insurers will take into account what’s taking place at the local level. The companies, each of them, will compete against each other, in terms of where rates are being had and what type of FireSmart programs are being enacted at the community level.
I’ll just also say that for B.C. specifically and the rest of the country, there’s no place that my organization is aware of where you can’t get fire insurance. Fire insurance is essentially built into standard home policy. That’s the line that we’ve said to ministry officials, and that’s the line I’m sharing with you as well.
Rohini Arora: I also wanted to touch base on…. I’m unsure if you’re aware of this, and maybe you are. EMCR is providing $10,000 grants for communities — rural and smaller ones that may not have the administrative professionals that are needed to be able to develop those plans for emergency management. That’s something that’s being rolled out as well.
Greg Moy: Yep, we are aware of that, so thank you for raising that here today.
We do know that there are smaller communities that just don’t have the technical expertise. I’ll give, for an example, Lytton at the time. That was something that was more of a challenge for that community. I don’t know if there are any contemplations of some sort of provincial program within ministry officials to look into smaller communities that don’t have the capacity. That might be a question that I’ll also probably raise when we chat to them next, so thank you for that question.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
We’ll now go to our next presenter, who is online. We should have Michelle Di Tomaso from Breast Density British Columbia with us.
Thank you for joining. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Michelle Di Tomaso: Good morning, Chair and committee members. I’m very grateful for the opportunity to speak with you all today. My name is Michelle Di Tomaso. I’m founder of Breast Density Screening British Columbia, and I co-founded Dense Breast Canada.
British Columbia was the first province in Canada to implement breast density notification to their women and doctors. This policy came into effect October 15, 2018.
For those who may be unfamiliar with breast density, approximately 43 percent of women have dense breasts. Dense tissue can mask cancers on mammograms, making them harder to detect and increasing the likelihood that cancers will be missed. It’s like finding a snowball in a snowstorm.
[11:00 a.m.]
Before notification was introduced, women were not informed of their breast density, despite the known implications for breast cancer detection since the inception of B.C.’s mammography screening program in 1988.
At the time notification was implemented, it was also understood that women with dense breasts would require access to appropriate supplemental screening through a physician’s referral. However, while notification has been successfully implemented, access to the follow-up screening has not. This gap in implementation is the issue I raised when I first appeared before this committee in 2021, ensuring that notification is matched with timely and equitable access to supplemental screening.
Today women are being informed of their breast density, but many still face significant barriers in accessing the additional imaging required for early cancer detection. Notification without access is not enough. Research in British Columbia shows that supplemental ultrasound detects approximately seven additional cancers per thousand women screened that mammography misses. Most are early-stage cancers when treatment is less invasive and outcomes are better.
The economic evidence has also evolved. Recent Canadian economic analysis demonstrates that early detection through supplemental screening is less costly than treating later-stage cancers. Early diagnosis is not only better for patients; it is a more sustainable use of health care resources.
This year’s budget consultation paper emphasizes protecting core health services, fiscal sustainability and effective use of public dollars. Supplemental screening supports all three by improving outcomes while reducing treatment costs.
The challenge today is not evidence or technology; it’s implementation. In British Columbia, automated breast ultrasound has been approved, clinics are ready to participate and government has already committed through its ten-year cancer care action plan to improve cancer outcomes through early detection, but the system has not yet been fully implemented.
This gap has created unintended inequities. Some private providers now offer screening at significant out-of-pocket costs. At the same time, insurers face uncertainty because the Ministry of Health has indicated the service is intended to be publicly funded, but implementation remains incomplete. This creates uneven access based on geography and ability to pay.
In addition, British Columbians are accessing the same screening in Alberta, where B.C. already pays approximately $236 per exam. Public dollars are being spent regardless but not always within a coordinated B.C. system. The system is already paying for this care, just not delivering it consistently at home.
Today I have three recommendations.
First, fund and implement a provincial supplemental screening program for women with dense breasts.
Second, fully operationalize automated breast ultrasound and other evidence-based supplemental screening within the public system.
Third, establish MSP reimbursements that enable delivery within British Columbia and better align with the interprovincial billing rates already being paid when women access this service out of the province.
Five years ago, I came before this committee asking for progress. Today I am asking for implementation. The evidence is established. The technology is available. The accreditation work is complete. The economic case is stronger than ever. British Columbia has already started this work. Now it’s time to finish it.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now go to questions by members. Any questions?
Rohini Arora: Michelle, thank you so much for your presentation. You are such a staunch advocate about this critical issue.
You mentioned three recommendations. I missed the first one. I wrote down the automation and then the third, MSP reimbursement. What was the first one?
Michelle Di Tomaso: The first one was to fund and implement a provincial supplemental screening program for women with dense breasts, ideally complementing our mammography program through B.C. Cancer.
Rohini Arora: And you said that…. Is it seven additional screenings per 1,000?
Michelle Di Tomaso: Seven additional cancers are found per 1,000 in women with dense breasts who have already had a mammogram. That may not sound like a lot, but mammography only — well, not “only” — finds three to four per 1,000. That’s double the amount of cancers being found in women with dense breasts versus mammography.
[11:05 a.m.]
Rohini Arora: Thank you so much, Michelle. I appreciate all your insights.
Michelle Di Tomaso: You’re welcome.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the presentation. To fully operationalize the plan, is there a funding amount that was included in the plan that we need to operationalize, or is this strictly a policy, where government just needs to make the policy to make it go?
Michelle Di Tomaso: That’s a good question. I do have an answer to how much it would cost. I could send you with that one. I said a better question is what it costs not to do it. We now have evidence suggesting that diagnosing cancers later and treating more advanced disease costs more than finding those cancers earlier with supplemental screening. This is why I believe implementation deserves serious consideration as part of a fiscally sustainable health care system.
One thing that I did look up was that if we were to implement all 36 of our fixed centres and the three mobile units that we have, it would literally save 18 to 24 women being diagnosed with stage 4 cancer. To treat a woman for stage 4 cancer averages about $500,000. There’s a study that came out of Stats Canada that proves that now.
To buy an ABUS machine for each one of our clinics, including the three, is $230,000 to $250,000 per machine. We would be spending in excess of $9 million on these ABUS machines, and we would make up the cost in those 18 to 24 people that we’ve saved with a stage 4 cancer.
In British Columbia — I looked at the stats — we are averaging between 270 and 370 women that are being diagnosed with stage 4 cancer. Multiply that by $500,000. That’s a lot of money that you guys are paying just in…. All you need to…. I mean, ideally, supplemental screening will save that, considerably.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for presenting to us today.
Michelle Di Tomaso: Wonderful. Thank you all. Have a good day.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you. You too.
Okay. Moving on to our next presenter. If I can have Tom Hackney come forward, please.
Thank you so much for joining us. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
B.C. Sustainable Energy Association
Tom Hackney: Hello, Mr. Chair and committee members. Thank you very much for having me here to present. My name is Tom Hackney. I’m the policy adviser for the B.C. Sustainable Energy Association, also called BCSEA.
BCSEA and its members support strong, urgent action by the government and society to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and transition B.C. to a clean energy future. We deliver courses on sustainability in middle and high schools. We stage free public webinars on topical energy issues. We stage networking events for professionals and practitioners in B.C., and we intervene at the B.C. Utilities Commission on the BCUC reviews of B.C. Hydro’s and Fortis’ gas energy plans and spending.
Our three recommendations for Budget 2027 are:
First of all, to maintain or enhance funding for CleanBC and the Roadmap to 2030.
Two, to shift spending on economic and industrial development away from fossil fuels and to renewable energy.
Third, to shift spending on transportation away from fossil-fuel-based modes to clean and active transportation.
[11:10 a.m.]
On the first point, BCSEA strongly supports the government’s reasserted commitment to achieve its legislated greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets, and we believe that through energy is one of the key ways to achieve that.
The recent climate change accountability reports do confirm that increased efforts are needed to achieve those goals. We believe that the CleanBC and the roadmap programs should be adequately funded, both for their planning and convening functions and for their incentives to practitioners and pilot projects. Funding for planning should be adequate to engage stakeholders in all sectors and develop credible decarbonization pathway scenarios.
Incentive levels should reflect the magnitude of effort needed to achieve the provincewide reductions. For example, heat pump and energy coach incentives should be ramped up to levels that will optimally reduce total emissions for B.C.’s buildings.
On the second point, shifting spending away from economic and industrial development, away from fossil fuels and to renewable energy, we support no tax dollars for fossil fuel projects and fossil fuel exports. Instead, we should be investing in electrification infrastructure, and we take note that the federal government is now moving in that direction in doubling the size of the electric grid. B.C. should be investing more in job training to support green jobs.
On my final point, to shift spending on transportation away from fossil-fuel-based modes of transport and to clean and active transportation, one of the key points there would be to reduce spending on highway expansions and particularly urban, general-purpose lanes. Support transit more. Support the electrification of transit more. B.C. Hydro is already building out the EV grid, so that’s being done on ratepayer dollars, but there needs to be more support for customers to buy more EVs.
I’m sorry. I went a bit over time.
Paul Choi (Chair): That’s okay. Thank you so much for presenting and your presentation.
We’ll move to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): You mentioned not investing in highways and infrastructure, but in order to use even electric cars, we still need highways and infrastructure. Just wondering how those two things tie together.
Tom Hackney: Yes, ma’am. I see sustainable transportation as a kind of hierarchy, where the best transportation is walking or bicycling. Then the next would be public transit, hopefully electrified, and then electric cars. Then the worst would be internal combustion engine and personal vehicles.
If there’s a greater effort to do urban development where you have more walkable communities, you have less traffic. You have more transit, likewise, that takes less space on the highways.
To agree to your point, if everybody is driving an electric vehicle, you have fewer emissions, but you still have the congestion problem.
[11:15 a.m.]
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): I guess I was looking at it from more of a rural lens. I’m eight hours from here. I would still need a highway, even with an electrical car, to get to an urban centre to have that walkability.
I don’t have health care most of the time in Keremeos. I need a vehicle to get to a hospital. We don’t have buses. We don’t have transit. We don’t have all of those things. Just wondering how that fit into the overall ….
I don’t see a future where we’ve got rid of highways, and I’m just wondering. I can see it in the city, but as you move out into rural B.C., how is that workable?
Tom Hackney: Yes. Well, in five minutes, I didn’t have enough time to present the distinction.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): No, that’s fair.
Tom Hackney: I agree that the urban and the rural solutions will have to be different. I’m not saying get rid of highways altogether, but don’t use them as a kind of…. We should limit the amount to which we’re growing them.
Bryan Tepper: The electrification for the vehicles and everything…. We’re at our limit. We’re importing most net, I guess, importers. What does BCSEA…? What’s the view of the future on — I don’t want to say “sustainable”; that’s the wrong word — a consistent form of electricity?
We’re moving sustainably, as you said, here in the province. Does your organization support any more dams, nuclear? Do we continue to import from the U.S. until we have a solution to that? I’m looking for a solution, from your point of view.
Tom Hackney: Well, B.C. Hydro has…. The water flows go up and down, so there are going to be years when B.C. Hydro is more in deficit and more in surplus. I think that may answer part of what you said.
On top of that, B.C. Hydro is moving into a growth phase in expanding its system, and we support that. We believe that there are lots of renewable energy resources that B.C. Hydro can tap into and with further calls for power that would be developed by the private sector and contracted to B.C. Hydro.
I’m sorry. Did I miss your…?
Bryan Tepper: Yeah, I was sort of looking at: what’s the form you were looking for? Like I said, is it hydro, nuclear? What are we looking at here?
Tom Hackney: Well, I think wind and solar right now are the big ones. There aren’t too many more dams until you go up to the Liard River on the Yukon border. As to whether that’s practical…. I think wind and solar, right at the moment.
Rohini Arora: Thank you for your presentation. I found it very important in the context of the direction that people will have to go to be able to protect this planet adequately. Obviously, that requires global participation.
I’m curious about the federal aspect — for example, solar balconies. We need the federal government to be able to move on pieces like this because, of course, we want to be able to sell electricity, as well, and not just to be buying it. Of course there’s, as you know, work being done here.
I’m curious. Because you have a lot of knowledge about this, what are your thoughts on AI data centres and how they could be run? In China, they’re off of the land and actually on water and powered by wind turbines.
Tom Hackney: Oh, good heavens. I didn’t know they were on water. I recommend being somewhat careful on AI. The issue I’m concerned about is the possibility that these AI centres will become just a huge source of demand for electricity, competing with the demand for regular people, for their homes and for running their things.
[11:20 a.m.]
I don’t want to be a Luddite and reject AI entirely, but right at the moment, the grids across North America are suddenly getting this massive rate of demand.
In American jurisdictions, there’s: “Oh no, we have to build more gas-fired power plants to power all these AI systems.” I hope that’s not the way we go. I see the government of B.C. has touched the brakes a little bit on AI development, so B.C. Hydro is kind of rationing who’s going to get on the grid. I think that makes sense, for now, until we get a better idea of society’s real needs for these AI and data centres.
Paul Choi (Chair): Well, thank you so much for your presentation today.
We’ll move to our next presenter, who is online. We have Tara Hayes from CUPE Local 5536.
Thank you for joining us. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
CUPE Local 5536,
B.C. Harm Reduction Workers
Tara Hayes: Fantastic. Thank you so much.
I know that this is going to be a very, very different conversation than what was just had, but I’m going to do the best I can.
Good afternoon, and thank you so much for the opportunity to speak today. My name is Tara Hayes, and I’m the president of CUPE Local 5536. We are the B.C. harm reduction workers, and we represent front-line harm reduction workers working in the community health sector, who staff overdose prevention sites, supervised consumption sites, supportive housing programs and emergency shelters.
I am very grateful to be joining you today from the unceded traditional territories of the Coast Salish Peoples, including the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm, Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ Nations.
Today I am so grateful to be able to offer some recommendations coming from our union on areas that we believe are vital for next year’s budget, which do include the terms, specifically, “harm reduction” and “affordable housing.” Also, I would really like for everyone, when we’re talking about harm reduction, to understand and consider that this is community health. It’s not necessarily an ideology.
I’m going to just jump into it. Harm reduction is health care, but right now our system does not treat it that way. For us, it’s the intentional daily work of reducing harms associated with drug use. We are currently, as of April 14 this year, ten years into a public health emergency. It includes reversing overdoses, offering peer support, providing clean supplies and creating safe-use spaces, which connect people to services that provide them with the means to integrate back into society. It’s an evidence-based public health approach, grounded in compassion, that also intends to reduce street disorder.
Since the B.C. government declared the toxic drug crisis an emergency in 2016, more than 18,000 British Columbians have lost their lives. When overdose occurs and lives are saved, the medical consequences of the toxic drugs being used can follow an individual, have devastating effects for their lives and the communities they live in and put significant pressure on the health care and justice systems.
Each loss of consciousness during an overdose is a potential brain injury due to partial or total oxygen deprivation. In non-fatal cases, people with these injuries may experience problems with memory, motor coordination, emotional dysregulation, decision-making and problem-solving. Cognitive deficits like these can make it difficult to engage with and maintain substance abuse treatment and brain injury rehabilitation.
[11:25 a.m.]
These consequences represent a hidden epidemic of brain injury after overdose that, when it’s allowed to continue, will increase health care and justice system costs for generations. Our union believes that if governments meaningfully collaborated with drug policy experts and people with lived and living experience and prioritized access to a safe and regulated supply, we could prevent many of these consequences.
We’re asking the province to treat harm reduction and mental health services as essential parts of B.C.’s public health system. These services reflect the spirit of the Canada Health Act — comprehensive, universal, accessible care — but they are often treated as add-ons, not essentials. We need government to continue to expand funding for overdose prevention and supervised consumption services — sites like Insite that our members work at, as well as the dozens of peer-led and community-run programs across B.C.
Our recommendation is to scale up access to regulated safe supply and supervised consumption services that operate under appropriate staffing levels with stable, long-term investments in peer-led, community-based harm reduction programs that save lives and reduce costs associated with health care and justice system use, as well as emergency room visits and hospitalizations.
The next topic is affordable housing, and it’s very, very related. The toxic drug crisis and the housing crisis are deeply connected. No one wants to use drugs outside in an alley, risking death, health complications and/or police engagement. When people are unhoused or in substandard housing, they’re often left with no other options.
Our members work in supportive housing projects where we see the impact every single day. When housing is safe, stable and adequately staffed, people have a chance to stabilize, access services, manage health needs and build community. Too often housing policy is inconsistent, and local decisions reflect stigma more than evidence. I will directly reference, specifically, municipal — Vancouver as a perfect example.
Therefore, we are in a situation where we need provincial leadership to intervene where municipalities fall short. That means funding public and non-market housing with a housing-first approach, ensuring it comes with wraparound supports like peer services, trauma-informed care and voluntary treatment options. Our recommendation is to invest in supportive and non-market housing tied to community health services and to act when local policies fall short of meeting the needs of unhoused and underhoused people.
In closing, B.C. has been and could continue to be a national leader in responding to this toxic drug crisis, but that takes meaningful investment in front-line services and the people that provide them. As a union representing workers on the front lines, we know what works. We’re asking for you to support solutions rooted in evidence, care and dignity. Scale up harm reduction, which really is community health care, and invest in affordable housing-first strategies to prevent long-term health care and justice system costs from ballooning, which is the current situation that we’re in.
I thank you so much for hearing me out today, and I welcome any questions that you might have.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you for your presentation.
We will turn to questions by members.
Bryan Tepper: Hi. Recognizing the budget situation we’re in and where money is going to be spent, we have talked earlier about secure, compassionate care. What would be your preference on that? Is harm reduction in housing or…? Basically, it becomes secure, compassionate care. We’re dealing with the drugs and the housing through that way.
Tara Hayes: On behalf of my members and the folks that work in this sector, I think that everything that was just mentioned could be very easily combined. When we’ve got secure, affordable housing for folks that incorporates compassionate care, as well as…. I know that, as the harm reduction workers, that comes with a little bit of something to think about, but I think it’s truly community health care. When you combine all of those aspects together into one place, we’re solving multiple problems at the same time.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you very much.
Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for presenting to us today.
[11:30 a.m.]
Tara Hayes: Thank you. I would be happy to answer more questions if anyone had them, but that’s great. I’m grateful to have been able to speak.
Paul Choi (Chair): We do have one last question from MLA Toporowski.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Thank you, Tara. Thank you for all you do. I was just wondering how much of the housing with wraparound service you have already where you are.
Tara Hayes: Well, currently…. I represent workers that work in the Downtown Eastside of Vancouver, as well as in Victoria and in Ladysmith, B.C., which has all of those wraparound services. But we’re seeing an uptick in municipalities, specifically Vancouver, that are reducing those. We just lost one of our sites due to mayoral decisions.
I’ve got around 1,000 workers doing this work, and we’re just one union. There are so many more people doing this work.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Yes. Okay. Well, that was my question.
I know we have a few of what they call the village model, and I know that UBCM has also brought things forward to ask for some more support on that.
Late Chief Seymour, who was our former Chief of Quw’utsun, asked for a task force to look into this crisis, and that was in 2020. I know there’s probably some more updated information on that as well. I did see how the wraparound service does work in our community. Then compared to other places, a different kind of model…. I know there are two different kinds of models out there right now.
I don’t really have a question on that, but I just wanted to share that there is a lot of work to do. Also, just seeing what’s rolling out in our communities right now and then hearing from you and others that share your concern about how this is much needed in our communities…. Thank you.
Tara Hayes: Absolutely. Thank you so much. If I could just respond, I appreciate so much everything that you just said. What we are truly seeing is that in our community, specifically the Downtown Eastside; in Victoria, where we have sites; and in Ladysmith…. We are truly seeing the differences in British Columbians’ lives when they are provided with affordable housing and accessible services. It not only helps the people in need. It also continues the support of community health of the workers providing those services.
It’s truly life-saving. We literally watch it in the Downtown Eastside daily. Without these services, we would be losing far, far too many lives on a daily basis. I appreciate your commentary there.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you very much to members and for presenting to us.
We will move to our next presenter. We have Casey Edge from Victoria Residential Builders Association.
Thank you for joining us. We have five minutes for your presentation and five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Victoria Residential
Builders Association
Casey Edge: Good morning, Chair and committee. Thank you for the opportunity to present today.
I’m Casey Edge, executive director of Victoria Residential Builders. VRBA has about 180 members, of which the majority are builders.
Our recommendations are, one, that the provincial government should establish reasonable DCCs based on responsible analysis of housing supply and affordability. The B.C. government has expressed concerns about rising development cost charges on new housing, yet the costs continue to rise.
The city of Victoria recently boosted DCCs up to 258 percent. DCCs were originally intended to upgrade sewer and water, sidewalks, etc., adjacent to new developments. Now they include new fire and police stations, highways and solid waste facilities.
This year the CRD board added up to $9,044 per new home for a proposed upstream water supply project. CRD director Barb Desjardins proposed a motion postponing the DCC bylaw until staff could analyze an industry study and report on the impact on housing.
[11:35 a.m.]
The study says most new housing is not viable under current market conditions. The new DCCs would further reduce viability and delay recovery. Desjardins’s motion to review the study was rejected by the CRD board.
The province’s DCC Best Practices Guide says the Ministry of Municipal Affairs may refuse bylaw approval if the DCCs discourage construction of new housing. This can be determined by consulting with stakeholders. Local government bypassing the DCC Best Practices Guide is not uncommon. It is time for the province to step in and establish reasonable DCCs based on responsible analysis of housing supply and affordability.
Two, require mandatory housing development education for new municipal councils. Following up on our first recommendation, new municipal councils should be required to attend education seminars on housing development, including rezoning and costs of construction.
One of the challenges of being a builder is explaining the business model to elected officials. If councils expect amenities, green space and affordable housing, there must be a way to pay for it, along with permit fees, taxes and new building code regulations. The cost of a project must be at a price point purchasers can afford.
Presently this education is limited to public hearings, a less than ideal environment for education. Now is the time, prior to the municipal elections on October 17, to make housing development education mandatory for new councils. A test program could be demonstrated at UBCM in September.
Three, enable skilled-trade electives for university students. A recent labour survey says that youth unemployment is 13 percent, double the rate of Canada’s overall labour force. Meanwhile, trades shortages grow as baby boomers retire. Studies predict 83,000 job openings by 2032.
We have vast numbers of university students choosing electives in the humanities and sciences. Many would enjoy practical electives in framing, welding and other skills. This provides employable skills during the summer and immediately after graduation. Construction represents good-paying jobs in every community across B.C. Some students may choose construction as a career.
It’s time for a more flexible education system promoting the skilled trades, boosting youth employment and accommodating our changing economy.
Thank you for your time. I’d be pleased to answer any questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now turn to questions by members.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Thank you for your presentation and being so thorough and straight on your asks. I just wanted to ask about…. You said development education for elected officials, and you said a test at UBCM. Have you reached out to anybody at UBCM that plans to maybe do a test with this?
Casey Edge: Well, it’s got to be mandatory. It’s something that….
I’ll give you an example. A past North Saanich mayor told me one time: “Casey, your builders just want to build luxury homes.” I said to the mayor: “Mayor, you won’t subdivide a hectare of land.” The business model is you can’t build a 2,000-square-foot affordable home on a hectare of property. Understand how the business model works.
As a matter of fact, North Saanich recently refused to subdivide a 20,000-square-foot property into two homes. Unless you make these things mandatory for municipalities, they don’t care. I would say Bill 44 is probably the most effective housing legislation that’s been put in place in decades, and I’ve been doing this job for 25 years.
You had to override municipal obstruction in order to get townhomes, small multis, built for young families. In fact, if you look at the data, one of the few products that is actually rising and being boosted in B.C. is those small multis, and the entire reason is Bill 44.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: A follow-up. I guess you misunderstood my question, but that’s okay. I really liked what you said.
Is there opportunity for you to go and make a presentation, like others go to UBCM and be a guest speaker, to actually explain some of these things that you just said?
Casey Edge: Certainly, there’s an opportunity. We actually participate in the trade show and we speak to municipal councillors across B.C. every year at that trade show and chat with them about some of the challenges. Certainly, there’s that opportunity, if UBCM is prepared to entertain it.
[11:40 a.m.]
Bryan Tepper: Just a quick question, because I missed the number. Right at the beginning, you were talking about some of the development cost charges. The water one that is coming up on that — what was that number you said?
Casey Edge: Adding $9,044 per new home. On townhomes, that is a bright spot in B.C. right now, and they just slammed on a $9,000 fee and disregarded a motion to review a study done by the industry to explain — it was a really well-done study — how this new charge was going to undermine housing affordability.
Bryan Tepper: Yeah, it’s wild. Anyway, thank you very much.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Do you believe that some of the reasons those DCCs are rising is because municipalities are trying to find new revenue sources to meet the download demand that government is putting on them?
I come from rural B.C., so it’s a little different. I know our municipalities are really struggling, and the only place that they see to capture that money is on new development, because they hold the cards on new development, whereas raising taxes on existing homes is not palatable for people that live there.
Do you think that that is part of that pressure and why you’re seeing that scope creep on the DCCs?
Casey Edge: Well, what you’re saying is that municipalities are avoiding accountability with respect to the property taxes and instead putting the charges onto new-home buyers, who are also paying the property taxes on top of that. There’s got to be some kind of provincial oversight that says: “You can’t do that. You have to have some accountability to the taxpayers.”
If you’re not fiscally responsible and you’re adding significant taxes, then come election time you’re going to have to answer to the taxpayers for that. Instead, it’s a shell game. We’re going to jack up the DCCs on new-home buyers, making housing more unaffordable in the most expensive province in Canada by far.
Paul Choi (Chair): Well, thanks for presenting to us today.
The committee will take a quick recess.
The committee recessed from 11:42 a.m. to 11:48 a.m.
[Paul Choi in the chair.]
Paul Choi (Chair): I will call the committee back and go to our next presenter. We have Danielle Paydli from Cowichan Watershed Board.
Thanks for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Danielle Paydli: Thank you, huy ch q’u, huy tseep q’u, to everybody here. Good morning, and thank you for this opportunity to meet face to face.
As the executive director of the Cowichan Watershed Board, I greatly appreciate what a difference it can make when you are in the room together and working together and hearing and listening to each other. I greatly appreciate this opportunity to build deeper understanding. I raise my hands to all of you, as I’ve been taught to do in the Quw’utsun territory.
I’ll begin by introducing our board member, who’s sitting behind me, and acting co-chair, Councillor Calvin Swustus Jr. He’s gratefully joining me today, which I deeply appreciate — that kind of commitment and investment in the work of the board.
I have the deep honour of serving a unique partnership between Cowichan Tribes and the Cowichan Valley regional district, who sit as equal co-chairs on the board. The Cowichan Watershed Board really is, in my view, an example of British Columbia at its best — governments working together across different legal traditions, knowledge systems and perspectives in order to care for the shared watershed.
Each month elected leaders from both governments sit down with federal, provincial and local experts to discuss challenges that are facing our local watershed and especially the wild salmon who depend on it. This is done in recognition of Quw’utsun rights and responsibilities within their unceded territory and guided by Hul’qumi’num teachings and language.
[11:50 a.m.]
In a time when there’s a lot of division and mistrust, which seem increasingly common, I can tell you that around the watershed board, we’re building relationships, solving problems and working together toward a better future. People come…. Whether they arrive in hip waders or formal attire or blue jeans, they come really committed to the same goal, which is a healthy watershed for future generations.
I hope I can bring a little bit of good news today, even though the challenges that we face are really serious in the Cowichan and across B.C. Unfortunately, I’ve got to start with the bad news. In 2023, more than 100,000 fish died in the upper Cowichan River in a matter of days, possibly hours, and the cause wasn’t a single event but the accumulation of known stressors — low flows, warm water and declining watershed resilience during a hot, dry summer period.
It’s not common to see tears around our board table, but there were tears then. Salmon are viewed as relatives in the Quw’utsun culture. Both Quw’utsun and non-Quw’utsun board members and their constituents really felt that loss deeply.
I’ll mention my first recommendation now, and that’s funding for the Cowichan weir. The province has committed funding in the past, but as we know, the cost of materials, labour and more has gone up significantly. This is really a needed solution, storing more water in the wetter months to allow us to utilize it in the dry season to protect the salmon and the other creatures who depend on it.
Elsewhere in our watershed, the Xwulqw’selu, or Koksilah River, has become well known across British Columbia for water scarcity. This river is culturally significant to the Quw’utsun People, cherished by recreational users and is essential to local food production. Yet each summer we face challenges as declining summer water availability combines with decades of watershed impacts.
As you know, it’s the home of the first-of-its-kind water sustainability planning process. I’ll sneak in my recommendation 2 right here, which is further funding for water sustainability processes like this across B.C. These are like warning signs of what communities across British Columbia are increasingly experiencing.
But there is good news. I am getting to the good news part with my one minute and four seconds left. We’re seeing leadership and guidance by Indigenous nations like Cowichan Tribes, who have the depth of understanding, having cared for this land and these waters since time immemorial. They’re willing to work in partnership as neighbours, as mentors, to help protect the land and waters that we’re all so privileged to call home.
In addition, there’s funding available. The watershed security fund is demonstrating that strategic investments can make a real difference. The Cowichan Watershed Board was grateful to be among the inaugural recipients of the watershed security fund, and this investment is helping us to coordinate work across multiple governments and organizations, strengthen watershed monitoring and reporting and build shared understanding of watershed conditions and trends.
For many years, our board has worked towards seven shared watershed goals, and what we lacked was capacity to consistently measure and report on that progress. The WSF is really helping us to be able to do that.
I did not time this right, so….
The WSF is also including building jobs and local capacity, and that’s my final request for Budget 2027 — for the province to continue to reinvest in the watershed security fund. They’re able to do that through modernized industrial water rates that remain some of the lowest in Canada.
I’ll stop there. I had some more, but maybe they’ll come up through question period. I want to give everybody a chance to ask questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will go to questions now. Any questions?
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): You mentioned the water security fund and additional investment. The initial investment in there was $100 million. I think it’s giving out $7 million a year or close to it in interest. It was intended to be a legacy fund, where the interest is paid. Are you suggesting that additional funds be put into that fund to increase the interest payment, or are you looking for annual funding that would add up that $7 million out?
Danielle Paydli: I think that there’s opportunity either way. That could be taken either way, whether it’s to add to that legacy fund or to increase in specific annual commitments.
[11:55 a.m.]
Although it’s recognized that that has been an amazing resource and, obviously, we have had the opportunity to benefit from it and really encourage for other communities to have that same opportunity, the need is so great for watersheds that it’s really important to kind of be able to continue that work. The modernizing of industrial water rates would be a way to invest in that without taking from other pots.
Right now I think it’s $2.25 per million litres. In Quebec, they just changed their industrial water rates from $2.50 to $35. That can be a really amazing opportunity to have those funds to be able to reinvest in watershed security.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Okay. Quickly, I just wanted to say you listed one, two and three, basically. You didn’t say how much you were looking for, for the funding for Cowichan weir.
Danielle Paydli: Yeah. The funding for the weir…. This has been kind of a struggle in terms of determining the exact number that’s needed for that. One of the pieces of guidance that we got from Matt Leroy, who’s the executive director who we’ve been working with from WLRS, has been to get a really firm number and ensure that we have that kind of a basis so that we know that, with whatever we’re putting forward, that’s what’s needed.
We have consulted or contracted through MNP to be able to review the work and ensure that the number that we have put forward, which I was hoping to be able to bring today…. It looks like it’s still a week or two off of getting that final number, but we will have something that is concrete, that is reviewed and would give us that opportunity.
It’s projected in terms of the varying different start dates to construction, to be able to project, whether that’s starting in 2028, 2029, what the kind of cost would be.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Back to the watershed security fund. Sorry to jump back and forth. My understanding is the governance of the board of the water security fund is still being set up. Is your organization participating on that board or strictly a recipient of funding at this point?
Danielle Paydli: Yeah, we’re strictly a recipient of funding.
Bryan Tepper: I will say if you had something to finish up on, take 30 seconds or less and let’s hear it. You’ve got a few seconds.
Danielle Paydli: Okay. Well, I threw that quickly, the industrial water rental rates, in there. Just threw that in. Great. That’s perfect.
I would just end off by saying that healthy watersheds are really critical infrastructure. They support our communities and our farms, industry, transportation corridors, salmon and our health. I just greatly encourage the committee to consider that when you’re making your decisions and putting these recommendations forward.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Then No. 2, the further funding for the Koksilah initiatives or….
Danielle Paydli: The water sustainability processes?
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Yes, that’s it. Thank you.
I was just touching on that because you said “further funding across B.C.” Are you…? I know that this is being looked at probably from across B.C. Like you said, water is connected to all sorts of things — farming and all of those different things. I know the Cowichan Watershed Board has done a lot of work on contacting the farmers and having those discussions. When you’re saying that, is that…? You’re advocating for it to be modelled across B.C.?
Danielle Paydli: Well, I think we’ve recognized…. Through this process, there has been a lot of learning, being that it’s the first of its kind in B.C. There has been a lot of learning and a lot of understanding of exactly that, in terms of how the agriculture community is integrated and their information and their concerns considered. Then the same for the amount of capacity that it takes for these governments to get together to also recognize community input in multiple different spaces.
We have two different advisory tables, one made up of Quw’utsun members and non-Quw’utsun members, that also have businesses, agriculture.
There are just so many different nuances and different pieces of work that need to be done for a sustainability process, I guess, like learning from both the positives and the challenges that we’ve faced to be able to continue to do that good work that is on the government’s radar already and just encouraging the government to continue with these initiatives that will make a big difference in the communities in which they’re active and doing the work in.
Paul Choi (Chair): Well, thank you so much for taking the time to come and present to us.
Danielle Paydli: My pleasure. Thank you so much.
Paul Choi (Chair): The committee will now take a recess, and we’ll be back at 1 p.m.
The committee recessed from 12:00 p.m. to 1:00 p.m.
[Paul Choi in the chair.]
Paul Choi (Chair): I’ll call the committee back to order, and we’ll go to our first virtual presenter online.
Thank you so much for joining us today.
We have Ariane Fleischmann from Family Services of Greater Vancouver joining us.
Thanks for coming. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin whenever you’re ready to go.
Family Services of Greater Vancouver
Thank you for the warm welcome. Apologies that I couldn’t be there in person today. My name is Ariane Fleischmann, and I’m here today representing Family Services of Greater Vancouver.
I’m joining from the traditional territories of the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nation here in Gibsons, B.C.
I’d like to start by acknowledging that it’s been a really challenging year across all sectors. As a social services non-profit, we work directly with some of the British Columbians who are struggling the most right now. Today we’d like to highlight some of those struggles and propose some solutions for how we can get through them together.
FSGV has been here for almost 100 years, so we’ve experienced some tough times before and have a lot of optimism for the future. We recognize that this is a time for efficiency, for strategic investments, and I’m here to share two ideas to support people in B.C.
Directions Youth Services has supported unhoused youth for more than 30 years. From downtown Vancouver, Directions currently operates the only 24-7 youth drop-in centre in the province for unhoused youth. We also run two secure youth safe houses, a ten-bed supportive housing facility and the only emergency weather response shelter that’s specifically for youth 16 to 19.
To paint a picture about the population that we support, 47 percent of all unhoused people counted in the latest homelessness count noted that they first experienced homelessness under the age of 25. More than 33 percent have experience in government care, and there has been a nearly 200 percent surge in deaths amongst unhoused people since 2020.
Today the pathways to homelessness are expanding. Youth unemployment is rising. Grocery costs continue to be exorbitant. While rents are coming down, they are still really out of reach for a lot of young people. We don’t want more youth to slip into homelessness. Targeting support for the youth population is economically sound. It’s a great point of intervention and mitigation. It reduces future burden on the health care, justice and social services systems.
Today we ask that government create a housing plan specific to the youth population — one that includes a directive to B.C. Housing to develop supportive housing for youth so that they can successfully transition out of homelessness before they enter the adult system.
The second recommendation I’d like to touch on today is about non-profits and the role that we play in supporting British Columbians. I’ll stick with youth as the example here to demonstrate how we complement government services.
FSGV interacts with youth across many of our programs. A youth who has been involved with MCFD might get support from us if they have a developmental disorder and need support. They might come to us through Directions if they’re unhoused, through our CYSN program if they have a CYSN social worker or come to our family preservation program if the family has been involved with ministry. We also serve youth who have experienced sexual violence or exploitation.
[1:05 p.m.]
I really want to draw attention to all of these services because building trust with youth who have experienced trauma doesn’t happen overnight, and that’s really where non-profits thrive. We know how to build relationships with youth, and we know how to bridge them to all of the supports that are available, including government supports.
Really, we might even send them to…. I’ll use an example here. A youth comes to Directions. We might refer them to the sexual abuse intervention program. They might work with one of our victim support workers. They might get help from our housing support workers or develop some money skills through one of our financial empowerment coaches. Really, this serves as a reminder that non-profits are here to help and that we’re really well positioned to do so.
Unsurprisingly, the ask today is really about funding. To continue offering this level of trust-building, non-profits need a strong foundation. That includes all of the technology and the systems and the administration that an organization needs to keep running.
Our contracts really need support, to support our ability not just to administer really important life-affirming programs but to track and analyze data and to keep that data safe through strong cybersecurity; to develop more efficient working models through technology adoption; to have the capacity to collaborate with other organizations, including government; and to let people know that we’re here to help through advertising and community engagement.
That does come at a price. Non-profits have to be resilient. We’re thrifty. We’re creative. We’re nimble. It’s just getting a little bit harder to keep pace with technology.
Today we ask that government invest in our sector through existing contracts and funding models to reflect today’s changing world.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thanks so much for your presentation.
We’ll now go to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you. You’d mentioned the… I come from the non-profit sector previously, just so you know. Needing that strong foundation of technology and administration, are you looking for a one-time investment, or are you looking for an increase in…? Usually it’s a 10 percent or 15 percent administration fee. Are you looking for contracts to have a higher administration fee, or is it a one-time investment, where you need some innovation dollars?
Ariane Fleischmann: It depends. It can be case by case. The one-time investment helps with the upfront cost of transformation. If you’re looking at adopting a new system, like a database, it costs money just to get into that system.
Where the ongoing funding takes place is as we shift more to cloud-based solutions. Everything is a subscription these days, so the admin funding needs to cover more and more of those subscriptions just to keep our operations going.
The one-time injection is actually pretty small in comparison to the over time costs that we have to keep going with, I’d say, IT. It’s cybersecurity. It’s database. It’s all of those pieces.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Do you have a targeted percentage that you think that those contracts should be getting up to?
Ariane Fleischmann: Absolutely. It ranges, depending on the ministry that we’re working with. We work really closely with MCFD and Public Safety and Solicitor General. Sometimes even taking a look at what’s allowed to be considered an admin expense within our existing contracts would be step 1. Step 2 would be something like increasing the overall admin from 10 to 12 percent. We’ve seen, in Saskatchewan, rates as high as 18 percent even.
Rohini Arora: Thank you for your presentation. I was curious. From a policy perspective, which was going to be my question, you kind of touched on it…. To relook at the criteria for spending under the administrative envelope is what I’m understanding from you.
Ariane Fleischmann: Absolutely, yes, so much. This is very understandable. We want to be very responsible with the dollars we receive and put as much towards direct service as possible, but this foundation that we’re talking about is all the other things that go into running a business, ultimately. That can also include things like being able to market our programs to clients and make sure that people know that we’re here to support them. That wouldn’t be allowed as an administrative expense in most current contracts.
[1:10 p.m.]
Rohini Arora: Just as a follow-up, you’re saying marketing and promotional ad-buys would not be a part of it. In your thinking, is this a skill set that you hold in-house? Hiring someone externally can be very costly, to do the ad-buys.
Ariane Fleischmann: It’s also paying for staff people to be in-house. We’re a fairly large organization, not all full-time. It’s part-time, contract, full-time staff. Of 375 people, give or take, our admin is only about 30 people across the entire agency, and that’s including roles like marketing and communications. We have one person to help run all of the communications for the agency. That’s pretty small.
That’s very common across the sector, that people are making do with very small teams or very lean teams. People are doing lots of different roles to try to make it work as much as possible.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you very much for your presentation today.
Ariane Fleischmann: Thank you. I appreciate your time.
Paul Choi (Chair): Moving on to our next presenter. If I can get George Scott to the front, from International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees Local 168.
Thank you so much for joining us today. As you’ve seen, you have five minutes for presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You may begin when you’re ready.
George Scott: A pleasure to be here. I’m George Scott, and I represent the workers of the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees here on Vancouver Island. We are live entertainment workers engaged in a variety of work, with nine employers across the Island.
This past week we supported a multicultural festival here in Victoria, multiple dance recitals at various venues and Trooper at the Cowichan Performing Arts Centre. That is a small example of the scope of work we undertake daily, because we’re here for a good time, not a long time.
The province provides a tax credit on production labour for filmed entertainment shot in British Columbia, which has been recently increased for foreign-based productions. We understand these credits. They support jobs that see local workers spend in the economy. But these credits are not tied to telling Canadian stories. These credits often go back to U.S.-owned studios having told U.S. stories for U.S. audiences.
Our first ask of this committee is the creation of a credit system that would build capacity and artistic creation in the province by allowing arts creators and presenters to defray some of the costs of a live show. Requirements would be that the story be written by British Columbians; based on a B.C. story; be directed, composed, choreographed and designed by B.C. residents; to be presented by B.C. performers and in B.C. venues.
There are stories in B.C. worth telling, be they historical, modern or visions of a shared future. Not unlike other investments in the new economy, this support will go to workers who then spend, supporting small and medium locally owned businesses. These stories won’t get told without financial support.
B.C.-based storytelling — be it music, theatre, opera or dance — is even more important now in the current geopolitical climate. In the face of challenges to our culture, is not now the time to engage in a little cultural sovereignty exercise of our own? Let’s tell B.C. stories in B.C.
We propose a live entertainment labour tax credit to mirror the one that supports our film industry, which in fiscal 2023-24 cost the province $909 million. We propose an initial investment in the next budget cycle of a mere $9 million, a little rounding error in the amount spent on film labour credit.
Our second ask is related to a challenge we face that affects many B.C. workers. Our shows happen in evenings or on weekends. While we applaud efforts to make daycare more accessible, the system as structured does not help our workers. The system was built for those who work regular daytime schedules, but there are thousands of workers who do not work on those old-economy models. There must be a remedy so that workers can be supported in their lives.
I will note that the province has challenges gaining and retaining health care workers. Imagine how many parents could return to that work with daycare that speaks to actual health care schedules.
[1:15 p.m.]
This second ask we frame this way. If a $10-a day child care program can work for a nine-to-five, Monday-to-Friday worker, cannot a $15-a-day program work for those who are not? We believe it can. Given that work outside 1950s-style schedules is only going to increase, there needs to be a daycare plan that works for all workers.
I will close by restating our requests: a comprehensive child care system available at all hours of the day and week at a cost that is manageable to working parents and a labour tax credit on B.C.-created live performance to be enjoyed by British Columbians.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you for your presentation.
We will now turn to questions by members.
Rohini Arora: Hello. Solidarity.
I have a couple questions for you on the workers in your local in particular, 168. How many workers are there?
George Scott: Only 400, roughly.
Rohini Arora: Okay, 400.
Where are they based?
George Scott: The vast majority are here, but we do have workspaces in Duncan, at the Cowichan Performing Arts Centre; in Chemainus, at the Chemainus Theatre Festival; and in Campbell River, at the Tidemark Theatre.
Rohini Arora: As a follow-up, I’m curious. You were saying that the tax credit that we have is for foreign films, but my understanding in some of the conversations with the film commissioner and folks is that there’s been a focus on driving local productions, B.C.-based, especially workers that are coming out of B.C., whether it’s producers, the Writers Guild.
I’m curious. When you say…. Because I haven’t talked with you recently, I wanted to touch base with you and get a sense of the labour tax credit — that’s what you called it — versus the film tax credit.
George Scott: We’re looking for something that supports the live side. There currently is nothing. Basically, labour moneys are spent by film studios that then get…. Call it a credit, an incentive, whatever language you wish to use. It then comes back to those studio employers for shooting in British Columbia. It is at a large scale and in very small productions, but there’s no mirror that is there.
There’s also no requirement to meet that the stories be B.C. stories. A $100 million movie that’s set in space, shot by an American studio with big-name American actors receives the same percentage tax credit as a little Canadian story.
Rohini Arora: Right.
Then also thinking about third-party vendors, too, because something like a prop shop or a one-stop are also not part of the ecosystem. We know production requires so much, especially if you’re bringing stuff in from the U.S., too, or on Facebook Marketplace doing 35 meetings a day to try and get whatever it is you need for the film.
What is an average spend, would you say, in the live…?
George Scott: Well it depends a lot. If you look at the Arts Club or Bard on the Beach over in Vancouver, they’re spending upwards of hundreds of thousands of dollars to build a single theatrical show, engaging actors for an extended period of time.
Bard on the Beach, for example, obviously, given the name, is a Shakespeare festival. These are not B.C. stories. Yes, they’re supporting B.C. actors, directors, designers because they’re going to work, but we’re still not telling B.C. stories. I think it’s an opportunity to use a small spend to actually support arts and culture that tells B.C. stories.
Rohini Arora: Got it.
George Scott: Also, many venues across B.C. would present these shows if the cost of the production labour in-house, the technicians and front-of-house staff to present the show in Keremeos, for example, were reduced. Right now there’s no credit that way.
Rohini Arora: Thank you so much.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Okay. That is it. Well, thank you so much for coming and presenting to us today.
We’ll move to our next presenter. We have Kim Mackenzie from Canadian Mental Health Association, B.C. division.
Thanks for joining us today. You have five minutes for presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
[1:20 p.m.]
Canadian Mental Health
Association, B.C. division
Kim Mackenzie: Thank you so much, Chair and committee members, for having me come today.
My name is Kim Mackenzie. I’m the senior director of policy and systems transformation at the Canadian Mental Health Association, B.C. division.
Today I want to talk about the importance of protecting and strengthening community-based voluntary mental health services in B.C. delivered by organizations like ours and our 14 local branches across B.C.
In Budget 2026, government’s attention on mental health and substance use understandably focused on supporting people experiencing the most acute and complex challenges. These investments are critically important, and people need to have access to intensive supports when other systems have failed them. But we cannot lose sight of the broader mental health needs of people in B.C.
Over the last decade, government has invested in services that support people earlier on in their mental health journey — programs like Confident Parents, Thriving Kids, which is a free phone-based coaching service that’s helped tens of thousands of families support children experiencing behavioural or anxiety issues. Today this program and others like it are at risk.
An annual $82 billion in federal funding for mental health and substance use services in B.C. is currently tied to bilateral agreements that are set to expire at the end of this fiscal year. For the last decade, this funding has supported many of the initiatives in the Pathway to Hope strategy that you’re probably all familiar with.
While advocacy efforts are underway at the provincial and federal levels to renew these agreements, the uncertainty poses a serious risk to mental health and well-being in B.C. If this funding is not renewed or replaced, the consequences will be significant. People will lose access to important upstream early intervention. Wait-lists will grow longer. More people will fall through the cracks until their needs become more severe, complex and costly to address. Emergency departments already under pressure will experience even more demand.
Other impactful programs not funded by the bilateral agreements at risk include CMHA B.C.’s links to employment, which is an evidence-based vocational program for people with complex mental health and substance use challenges. Links has boasted a 58 percent employment rate for individuals in substance use treatment, improving client outcomes, helping them meet their recovery goals and supporting the transition from treatment.
These services should be protected not only because they improve lives but because they represent a sound public investment that strengthens B.C.’s workforce, communities and provincial economy.
A new report published last week estimates that Canada’s mental health crisis costs the economy $180 billion annually across health care, emergency services, criminal justice and homelessness. This is more than three times the national estimate in 2011.
Community mental health programs help people remain employed, reduce long-term disability and absenteeism and support productivity across every sector of the economy. Research suggests that for every $1 spent on a program like Confident Parents, society gets back close to $10, savings that come from things like reduced crime and less use of the health care system.
Investing in community mental health care is also an investment in overall community safety and well-being. When people can access timely mental health care, stable housing, peer connections and employment navigation, communities are safer and healthier. People are less likely to experience crisis, homelessness or involvement with the criminal justice system.
The role of community mental health in B.C. also extends beyond upstream supports. CMHA B.C.’s crisis response, community led, or CRCL, teams — these are mental health crisis teams — have responded to around 20,000 calls for service across seven communities in B.C., resolving approximately 80 percent of calls without the need for emergency services. Funding and sustaining services like CRCL improves outcomes by helping people access timely, appropriate care, reducing unnecessary reliance on more costly systems like policing and emergency departments. Community mental health services like CRCL are not nice-to-haves. They are essential health, social and economic infrastructure.
Today we are asking government to take two key actions in Budget 2027.
First, protect existing community mental health and substance use services by ensuring there is no interruption in the $82 million annual funding if the federal bilateral agreements are not renewed. We cannot afford to lose existing services that provide important return on investment and support people in community.
Second, commit to sustained and predictable investments in community mental health across the continuum, from early intervention to crisis response to treatment and recovery. The choices made in this budget will shape whether people can access mental health support early or only after they’ve reached a crisis. They will determine whether government will pay less now or pay more later.
Protecting and sustaining community mental health care as a core public service will help build a healthier, safer and more economically resilient British Columbia.
[1:25 p.m.]
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you for your presentation.
We’ll move to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): I don’t know if my brain blanked out. What was the second ask? I was typing the first one, and the second one didn’t land.
Kim Mackenzie: It’s to commit to sustained and predictable investments in community mental health. Normally for these types of things, we would come with really specific programs we’d be asking funding for. This time around, I think, as you can probably tell from my remarks, we’re really worried about what might go in this next budget, particularly because if the federal government does not renew the bilateral agreements, that’s a significant price tag then thrust on the provincial government.
If you go look at the bilateral agreements, this is funding five key priority areas of investment: mental health and substance use in primary care, mental health and substance use services in Indigenous communities, a seamless system of care, student access to prevention and early intervention, and treatment and recovery. There’s a lot at risk. That’s what I wanted to kind of highlight today. We have to make sure that we’re sustaining these programs into the future.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): A follow-up, just quickly.
It’s not the space that my critic role is in, so I’m going to ask a clarifying…. The $82 million commitment to keep it going — is that how much the federal is contributing, or is that the total program?
Kim Mackenzie: That’s how much the federal government is contributing, yeah.
Bryan Tepper: Just to follow up on that so that we don’t lose it, how much does the province commit to that then?
Kim Mackenzie: Oh, that’s a great question. You should ask the CFO of the Ministry of Health. What I can say and what I do know is that since 2017, my understanding is the province has spent about $3.15 billion on mental health and substance use, of which the $82 million annually would be a part.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Rohini Arora: Thanks so much, Kim, for your presentation. Can you remind me…? You said $180 billion annually was the cost to…. There was something you said there that I kind of missed. I was trying to keep up.
Kim Mackenzie: The $82 million annually, you mean?
Rohini Arora: No, $180 billion.
Kim Mackenzie: Yeah, it’s $180 billion annually to the Canadian economy, related to the mental health crisis.
Rohini Arora: Then you talked about Confident Parents, Thriving Children and the calls. You said 20,000 calls across seven communities?
Kim Mackenzie: That’s the crisis response, community led — the CRCL teams. Yeah, they’re mental health crisis response teams, civilian-led, and they have responded to over 20,000 calls across seven communities that have a staged-in launch.
I can list the communities, if that’s helpful. It started in North and West Vancouver, expanded to Victoria and New Westminster and then to Kamloops, Prince George and Comox Valley. More recently Kelowna has stood up a team there, primarily actually with federal funding in partnership with the municipal government there as well. Those are the seven communities.
A very good example of investing in the right response at the right time, freeing up resources like police to be able to focus on the substance of their jobs in dealing with community safety and catching the bad guys.
Rohini Arora: Just one more follow-up.
In terms of these communities, do you have disaggregated data of who’s impacted, like youth 18 to 24 versus people in their 30s versus seniors?
Kim Mackenzie: Yeah, we’re about to publish an evaluation report. That is coming out very soon, looking at the first six communities. Kelowna is too new to have collected data. We do collect demographic data. It is challenging at times to collect demographic data in the context of a crisis response. We do our best.
I can’t tell you, off the top of my head, the demographics for each community, but I can ensure, maybe through contacts here in the committee, that you get a copy of that evaluation when it’s released.
Rohini Arora: That would be wonderful.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): For those 20,000 calls, what is the time period? Was that a year, five years?
[1:30 p.m.]
Kim Mackenzie: Since January 2023, and teams have launched at different intervals.
The longest-standing team has been North and West Vancouver, followed by Victoria and New West.
Then phase 2 was Kamloops, Comox Valley and Prince George, which launched, at this point…. Wow, it’s 2026, so they would’ve launched in 2024, over 2025.
Rohini Arora: Was it January of 2024?
Kim Mackenzie: January of 2023 for Victoria and New Westminster.
Rohini Arora: And phase 2?
Kim Mackenzie: Phase 2 was dependent on the community because each community had a different kind of timeline. I’d have to go back into the recesses of my memory. I think Prince George launched in the summer of 2024, and then Comox Valley launched in the fall of 2024, and then Kamloops was in the spring of 2025.
Rohini Arora: Got it. Thank you.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Thank you so much for coming and presenting to us today.
Kim Mackenzie: Thank you for having me.
Paul Choi (Chair): We’ll go to our next presenter online. We have Paul Adams online from B.C. Rural Health Network.
Thanks for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Paul Adams: Good afternoon, hon. Chair, hon. co-Chair, members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to present today.
My name is Paul Adams. I’m the executive director of the B.C. Rural Health Network, a provincial charity working to improve access to health care and to create better health outcomes in rural B.C. Our membership includes rural non-profits, municipalities, regional districts and residents from across the province. Our role is to bring lived rural experience into health policy because rural residents are often closest to the access problems but furthest from the decisions that shape the system.
Last year we asked this committee to recommend a permanent B.C. rural health equity fund beginning at $50 million annually, and we proposed some practical priorities, which included medical travel assistance, trusted rural communication and navigation and community-level recruitment and health education.
We want to acknowledge that the committee heard those concerns. Your report specifically noted our request for a rural health equity fund. It also recommended rural and remote community health centres; better home and community care, recognizing rural, remote and northern challenges; and improved transportation options, including public transit into city transit and air options so rural patients can access health care generally. Those recommendations mattered. They showed that the rural access problem is understood, at least at this committee level.
Unfortunately, Budget 2026 did not follow those recommendations. We recognize the fiscal pressures government is facing, but from a rural lens, we do not see a dedicated rural health strategy nor the investment it needs.
The core issue is this. Provincewide health investments do not automatically create rural equity. Rural health cannot be built by taking urban models and scaling them downward. Rural communities face different geography, different workforce realities, different transportation barriers, different emergency pressures and different community capacity. A service model that assumes short travel distances, available specialists, reliable transit, dense staffing and multiple nearby care options simply does not translate into many rural places.
B.C. needs rural health planning that recognizes two realities at once. Urban and rural systems are connected, but they cannot be designed as if they are the same. Rural communities need a distinct rural health system approach, not a smaller version of an urban one.
[1:35 p.m.]
That is especially true in primary care. Many rural residents still lack reliable access to a family doctor, nurse practitioner or consistent team. When primary care is missing, everything else becomes harder — chronic disease management, seniors care, mental health, maternity care, emergency department stability, prevention and early intervention. This is why team-based care must expand in ways that fit rural communities.
Community health centres are one practical model. They can bring together physicians, nurse practitioners, nurses, social workers, mental health supports, allied health providers, Indigenous and community partners and navigation supports under one roof or one coordinated structure, but they must be designed with rural communities’ involvement, not imposed as urban templates.
Transportation and accommodation must also be treated as a health infrastructure issue. If there is no transportation option and no adequate medical travel support, then a referral is not access. It is just a piece of paper. People miss appointments, delay care, depend on exhausted family members or absorb costs they cannot afford.
This year we again recommend that Budget 2027 establish a permanent B.C. rural health equity fund starting at $50 million annually and secured in the fiscal plan.
Secondly, ensure that the fund supports medical travel, rural health navigation and communication, community health centres and team-based care development, community-level recruitment, health education and rural transportation solutions.
Third, require public, rural outcome reporting, not just provincial averages. Then we move beyond attachment and take a serious look at health outcomes and well-being.
Rural British Columbians are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for fair access to care without unreasonable barriers or burdens. The committee heard this clearly last year, and this year we’re asking you to help turn recognition into budget action.
With the tragedy of Tumbler Ridge very much still front of mind for us and many rural communities, we need to ensure that this tragedy should not be forgotten, and we should do everything possible to prevent similar events happening in the future. To do that, we must have better rural health strategies and investments.
I thank you, and I welcome your questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Hi, Paul. Good to see you.
Yeah, definitely. I understand it made the report. Was any of it reflected in the budget, do you see, for rural B.C.? Are there sections of the recommendation that made it into the actual budget?
Paul Adams: Unfortunately, the only items that we saw which were rural-specific in Budget 2026 were increases to costs to rural residents. That included increase in the deferral rate, if you were to defer your property tax, and a removal of homeowners’ grants for people purchasing properties in rural community.
We didn’t see any rural-specific budget items, and the line items, obviously, conceal many different aspects of spending. It’s not that there is no money being spent in rural B.C. It’s just the need to have a focused rural allocation so that we can start addressing some of the inequities that exist across the rural health space.
Paul Choi (Chair): Seeing no other questions….
Do you have a follow-up?
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): I could do a follow-up, yeah.
Paul, you know that the South Similkameen Health Centre now is open 24 hours a week. Our emergency department is Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, eight to five, and we’ve even had some closures on those days in the last month. I do really appreciate your advocacy for rural and would love to have more detail about what we could include in the report to ensure that that inequity is recognized and that we do find a solution.
[1:40 p.m.]
Unfortunately, Keremeos is not alone. In my riding alone, we’re struggling in many areas to maintain even just basic service, never mind getting to a specialist or getting a CT. Even blood work is getting to be more and more of a challenge.
If $50 million in the budget, specifically earmarked, is what we should say, then that’s great. If there was more detail around how you think that should be distributed, maybe we can touch base offline.
Paul Adams: Yeah, I’m happy to do that, Donegal.
I think that the challenge becomes that, without having a line item in the budget that is specific to rural health, we don’t get any direct reporting. The estimates don’t really happen unless you see that as being a line item, and $50 million is really the low amount in order to get into a line item on the budget itself.
I think that we see so many closures. Obviously, you’re my MLA. You’re aware of the challenges in the South Okanagan as well as throughout the Similkameen Valley, but it’s not an isolated situation. As you know, we’re seeing closures continue throughout all regions and health authorities.
We’re also seeing numbers increasing on attachment but attachment really not demonstrating that there is a continuum of care or an access within a timely period. Some of the disadvantages that we’re seeing…. I can give you a full list of ways that we can invest money. I think that many of you are aware of those.
It’s a matter of how we’re actually recording that information and determining the health outcomes of people when you have Port Hardy that has a life expectancy that is eight years less than where you’re sitting in Victoria. That is a consistent problem across rural versus urban that we need to address — the actual mechanisms being put in play to provide people with reasonable access to care.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for that presentation.
We will move to our next presenter. We will call Cindy Anderson to the front, from Laryngectomee Association of B.C.
You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions.
You may begin when you’re ready.
Laryngectomee Association of B.C.
Cindy Anderson: Okay. Thank you.
Good afternoon, and thank you for the opportunity to speak with you. You already know my name is Cindy Anderson. I’m here on behalf of the Laryngectomee Association of B.C. It’s a volunteer-led organization supporting laryngectomees and their families across the province. We provide advocacy, peer support, education and community.
My husband and I helped establish LABC after realizing that the isolation, emotional strain and daily challenges we experienced following his laryngectomy were shared by many others. Through conversations with laryngectomees, families and health care professionals, it became clear that a coordinated provincial response was necessary.
Our ask is for funding for medically necessary devices for laryngectomees. I would like to provide a bit of a definition of a few of the terms, especially because I’m reading it and you’re hearing it and don’t see it. Just to have clarity, a laryngectomy with a y at the end is a surgery that removes the voice box or the larynx, often due to cancer, and creates a permanent breathing opening in the neck called a stoma. A laryngectomee with double e at the end is a person who has undergone a laryngectomy.
A laryngectomy permanently changes how a person breathes, speaks and lives. Because air no longer passes through the nose and mouth, laryngectomees are more vulnerable to respiratory infections and pulmonary complications.
Medical devices — such as voice prostheses, heat and moisture exchangers and adhesives that help create a proper seal around these devices — help laryngectomees communicate and protect their lungs. These are not optional products. They are medically necessary devices that allow people to breathe safely, communicate more effectively and participate more fully in daily life.
Despite this, there is currently no dedicated funding in B.C. for these essential laryngectomee products. Many laryngectomees are forced to pay out of pocket for devices they rely on every day to breathe, communicate and protect their health. The costs are significant and lifelong, often forcing people to make choices between their health and their financial stability.
[1:45 p.m.]
The impacts of a laryngectomy extend far beyond physical health. Losing the ability to communicate easily and participate fully in everyday life can have profound and lasting effects on a person’s quality of life, mental health and connection to their community.
I witnessed this firsthand with my husband. Over time, his relationships were affected, including those with the people who mattered most to him. A significant loss was stepping away from his lifelong passion as a recreational hockey goalie. This not only reduced his physical activity but also took away an important source of friendship, purpose and community connection. The combined impact of physical and mental health challenges together with the ongoing cost can place considerable emotional, social and economic strain on the family.
At its core, this is an equity issue. Right now when someone can speak comfortably, protect their lungs and participate fully in society, it depends on their ability to pay. This is not consistent with how B.C. approaches medically necessary care.
We initially submitted a budget proposal in 2023. It was acknowledged by then Minister Adrian Dix in 2024. In September ’25, we were told that it remained under consideration by senior leadership, but to date, we still have no funding in place.
I would also like to briefly talk about the tobacco settlement. Many laryngectomees developed cancer linked to tobacco use when the risks were not fully understood. Governments have since received billions through tobacco settlements intended to address smoking-related harms, yet British Columbia directed its share towards deficit reduction.
Our proposal would cost less than 1 percent of B.C.’s portion of these settlement funds while providing meaningful support to a small, high-needs population living with the severe, lifelong consequences of tobacco-related illness. They deserve equitable access to medically necessary devices and supplies.
Therefore, we recommend the province of British Columbia introduce dedicated public coverage for medically necessary laryngectomee devices and supplies. It would allow laryngectomees to breathe safely, communicate effectively and participate fully in their communities.
Thank you for your time.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now turn to questions by members.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Thank you for your presentation. You did mention funding requests, but you didn’t say how much the funding was when it was recognized previously.
Cindy Anderson: Okay. Actually, I don’t know the answer to that, the reason being we’ve been dealing with PharmaCare. The costs are really associated with the supply companies. PharmaCare has done the financial development, so I actually don’t know the final cost other than that it rolls up to approximately 1 percent of the money that B.C. received.
Rohini Arora: I want to thank you so much for the advocacy you’re doing. It’s very clear that not only are you a loving spouse but this is something that…. When it affects a smaller population, it takes so much more effort to uplift the issue.
One of the things I wanted to ask you is…. You said that this is an issue particularly with the suppliers or the medical devices that are provided by the suppliers.
Cindy Anderson: Yes, that’s correct.
Rohini Arora: Can you tell me the approximate cost of some of the devices like the stoma? What’s the cost? And the moisture…?
Cindy Anderson: I can’t tell you exactly the specifics of each device. What I can tell you is a rough ballpark figure of what people use. However, you have to take those numbers in with caution because some people can’t afford all the supplies, so they’re actually not using as many supplies as they should.
Some people have the voice prosthesis that’s inserted between the trachea and the esophagus. That can last somebody six months. It may last somebody else two months. The costs are extremely variable.
I believe if you look at the recommendations of what people should be receiving to actually enable them to buy the supplies they need when they need them, it would be approximately $10,000 per year per person.
Our numbers are a little hard to establish because the population tends to change fairly quickly, but we estimate at the most there’d be 300 to 400, and my guess is it’s more like 200 to 300.
Rohini Arora: Laryngectomees in the province.
Cindy Anderson: Laryngectomees in the province, yes. It’s a very small number but a very needy number that are dramatically impacted by the surgery. I’ve only highlighted certain pieces of it, but there are a lot of things that people have to deal with on a day-to-day basis, and it is very stressful to families — of course to laryngectomees but also their families.
[1:50 p.m.]
The financial implication, whether they’re spending a few thousand or $10,000…. Most people can’t afford the supplies, so they’re not using what they should be using.
Rohini Arora: I’m just thinking this through. If somebody requires some of these devices and they are able to pay, which is the inequity piece that you spoke to, they may get taxes back at the end of the year, but it’s not nearly what it needs to be to actually support them in being able to purchase the devices.
Cindy Anderson: That’s correct, yeah.
My husband passed away almost four years ago so….
Rohini Arora: I’m sorry for your loss.
Cindy Anderson: Thank you. The information I had about how much we actually spent on his supplies was probably in the $5,000 range. He was also one of those people that, although we could afford it, was concerned about his usage. You’ll hear stories of what various laryngectomees have done to prolong their equipment, which is not appropriate, but they do it.
Again, we would have spent at least $5,000, but given that was over four years ago, prices and cost of living, etc., have gone up dramatically.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Bryan Tepper: With proper equipment, does that bring the infection rates down, or do you have any idea about infection rates?
Cindy Anderson: No, I don’t. The reason is that when people are admitted to hospital, they say they have pneumonia. They don’t say it’s pneumonia because they have a laryngectomy and weren’t using appropriate resources.
I will quickly go over the supplies. The stoma is usually in the centre of the throat, and usually, the prosthesis for their speech goes inside. That’s installed by a speech-language pathologist, usually in the health authorities.
Then on top of that, you have a filter that goes in, which hopefully prevents a lot of the dust and grass and whatever in the air, and bacteria, entering through that. Then in addition to that, you have to have a little plastic thing that the device fits into to make it stay within the stoma. A lot of people need to have adhesives that go around to hold those all in place.
Those are kind of the basics. I believe the manufacturer is presenting to you sometime, and I believe they’ll go into more detail about the supplies and the cost with you. That’s one of the reasons I didn’t include that.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you very much for your presentation.
I will call the next person, Dominic Rockall from Clements Centre Society, to come forward.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for the presentation, five minutes for questions.
You may begin when you’re ready.
Dominic Rockall: Good afternoon, and thank you for the opportunity to speak today.
My name is Dominic Rockall. I’m the chief executive officer of the Clements Centre Society. We’re a registered non-profit based in Duncan, B.C. Since 1957, we’ve provided front-line therapeutic and support services for infants, adults, children and youth with developmental and intellectual disabilities throughout the Cowichan region.
We are deeply committed to improving the lives of underserved children and families and expanding access to inclusive, specialized care in our community. However, the reality is that services for people with developmental disabilities have long relied on charitable organizations like ours, while provincial funding has not kept pace with the growing demand.
Referrals to Clements Centre have nearly tripled in the past ten years, increasing by 178 percent. While the recent increase in funding for children and youth from MCFD through children and youth, CYSN, expansion will definitely be helpful, we do not have enough therapy space or specialized equipment to meet our current needs. Our wait-list has grown to more than 300 people, with some families waiting up to 15 months for services.
Rural and Indigenous families continue to face even greater barriers to access. As the only centre providing these services in the region, rural families are often required to travel long distances to access specialized services, creating additional financial and emotional strain. For Indigenous families already navigating systemic barriers, these delays can further widen inequities in care and access.
These pressures are also contributing to growing inequities and delays in early intervention, and early intervention is critical for the children that we serve. When children and families can’t access support early, their needs often become more complex and more costly later on.
[1:55 p.m.]
Families are left struggling without adequate supports. Children fall behind developmentally. Pressures increase on schools, health care and crisis services. Investing earlier not only improves outcomes for families, but it reduces long-term costs to the public system. That’s why we’re bringing three recommendations forward for the province today.
First, invest specifically in adult mental health services for people with developmental disabilities. This remains a significant gap in British Columbia’s mental health system, and it requires dedicated funding and resources to serve this population.
Second would be to create capital grant programs that support purpose-built infrastructure for specialized care. Clements Centre has secured the land and has strong support from both our local and municipal and Indigenous First Nations. This project is part of a broader campus-of-care vision which would expand services to meet growing regional demand while co-locating with Island Health to improve coordination of care.
We’ve had some ongoing discussions with Island Health about co-locating. By bringing services together into one integrated space, we can reduce barriers for families, improve access to care and create a more efficient and connected model of support for the region. We are ready to help fill a critical gap in our community.
Third would be to reinstate the community housing fund 2025 intake and allow applicants from the cancelled July 2025 intake to be prioritized when the next funding stream is announced. In partnership with a private developer, we have a project on a street called Vian Street in Duncan. This would provide much-needed housing for adults with developmental disabilities in the region.
This project is a five-storey, 28-unit development that we spent two years advancing, with strong municipal support. However, it’s now at risk due to the cancellation of that program. For the people we serve, this is not simply a development project. It’s a question of whether they’ll have stable housing at all. Adults with developmental disabilities are among the most vulnerable to housing insecurity and isolation, particularly when living on fixed incomes. We already have a growing wait-list for individuals in urgent need of safe, affordable housing, and we can’t afford to leave them behind.
In closing, Clements Centre has proudly helped to fill the critical gaps in British Columbia’s care economy for decades. We remain committed to supporting underserved community members, but the current level of funding no longer reflects the scale of need in our growing region. The needs are growing; so is the opportunity to invest earlier.
Thank you for your time. I welcome questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Thank you, Dominic. You’re coming to the right places and advocating for the need in the Cowichan Valley. I just wanted to go back to…. You said “triple in the last few years.”
Dominic Rockall: Ten years.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Oh, last ten years. Okay. Triple — what was tripling? Sorry.
Dominic Rockall: Referrals.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Referrals. Okay, thank you. Sorry. I missed it.
The other question I had was on the growing wait-list for housing. What is your number?
Dominic Rockall: It kind of fluctuates because we find housing for people, and then people fall in and out of housing. At any given time, we have between ten and 20 people that we serve that are either precariously housed or completely unhoused. They call it living rough. There are usually up to half a dozen that have no housing at all.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: So ten to 12?
Dominic Rockall: I would say ten to 20.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Ten to 20? Okay.
Dominic Rockall: Yeah, that are precariously housed. They’re staying with a relative or a friend or on a couch, but they just have no home of their own. There’s, I would say, about a half a dozen — it fluctuates at any given — that are completely homeless.
[2:00 p.m.]
Rohini Arora: Hi, Dominic. Very nice to see you again.
I’m curious about the amount. I do remember having this discussion when we were in MLA Toporowski’s office. Can you remind me what the funding request was under the CHF? You had an initial application in 2025.
Dominic Rockall: Yeah. The CHF, the community housing fund, was a $17 million project.
Rohini Arora: And you’d asked for the full $17 million? It was a certain amount. I can’t remember.
Dominic Rockall: Yes, that was what went in the application. We’d already received predevelopment funding as a forgivable loan, which I understand is going to be forgiven if it’s truly cancelled. Well, they’re already trying to figure out paying people back the predevelopment funding.
We also have a child development…. We were hoping…. We’d asked for capital funds for a child development centre, a program building. That was $10 million. That wasn’t through the government program. That was just an ask.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for your presentation and for being articulate in the ask. For the July 2025 intake that was cancelled, you did say that this put your 28 units at risk. What is the date when the decision will be made that that project is not moving forward?
Dominic Rockall: The private developer now is sitting on this property that is empty. It was previously a house that was being rented, so she can’t wait indefinitely. There are also legal covenants and all kinds of building permits that have been applied for and received. We’re ready to break ground immediately, so she can’t wait. I think she said she’d give it six months and see where we are at that point.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): How much money did you receive in that preplanning…?
Dominic Rockall: Predevelopment funding?
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Predevelopment. Was it government funding, and how much did you receive?
Dominic Rockall: It was $220,000, approximately, received from the government. The private developers put in an additional $200,000 of their own money that they’ve invested, so it was $420,000, I think, but only half of that was government.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): The $420,000 — will it all be recoverable, or is there some of it or all of it that will be not recoverable?
Dominic Rockall: The $220,000 is a loan from the government that they’re saying that they’re going to forgive — $220,000. The rest that the private developer put in…. I imagine they’ll have to figure out a way to recoup that if they replan and build something different.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): So that money is spent. It’s done. Okay.
Dominic Rockall: Yeah.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
I’ll call our next presenter, Leanne Utendale from Options Community Services Society.
Thank you for coming today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Options Community Services Society
Leanne Utendale: Thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today. My name is Leanne Utendale, and I am the director of mental health and substance use with Options Community Services. Options is a non-profit organization that has been serving Surrey, White Rock, Delta and Langley for over 50 years. We provide services across the social service sector, including housing, homelessness, youth, family, mental health, substance use and more.
Today I am here to discuss a growing gap in British Columbia’s addiction treatment system and a proven solution that is already helping hundreds of people access care.
Four years ago, Options developed a home-based detox program to address barriers preventing people from accessing traditional inpatient detox services. Initially, this program was created to support members of the South Asian community who were experiencing cultural barriers to treatment, but we saw a growing need through this.
We work with individuals who want help but cannot leave their jobs, families or the children that they might be caring for in order to enter residential detox. We support tradesworkers, commercial drivers, parents involved with MCFD, people on probation and many others who face significant barriers to traditional detox. At the same time, access to detox services remains limited across the Lower Mainland, resulting in long wait-lists and delayed access to care.
[2:05 p.m.]
The consequences of untreated substance use are significant. The Canadian Mental Health Association estimates that approximately one in four British Columbians will experience a substance use disorder in their lifetime. Alcohol-related harms alone cost British Columbia over $2.18 billion annually through health care utilization, lost productivity, injuries and deaths. When people cannot access treatment early, many end up cycling through emergency departments, hospitals, shelters and the justice system. These are some of the most expensive systems that government can operate.
Our program provides an alternative. The home-based detox program provides physician oversight, nursing support, addiction counselling, relapse prevention services and ongoing outpatient treatment. Clients complete a medical, supervised detox in their own homes over five to seven days and continue receiving support through our outpatient treatment programs.
The results have been remarkable. Over the last four years, we have detoxed more than 300 individuals and connected more than 400 additional people to recovery and community supports. Our program has achieved a 77 percent completion rate. Anybody can come back and receive additional detox sessions if they need to.
Our annual operating budget is approximately $972,000, which primarily goes to clinical staff. The program costs about $500 to $1,000 per client, per day, depending on the complexity of care required. The cost includes medical oversight; counselling; medication support; and, in some cases, housing, meals and 24-hour care. By comparison, a single emergency department visit related to substance use can cost between $1,500 and $2,500 per day, and a two-to-three-day hospital admission can exceed $6,000.
Today we are requesting a funding commitment of $1 million annually to sustain and expand this program across the Lower Mainland. This investment would preserve an innovative, evidence-informed service that reduces barriers to care, supports recovery, decreases pressures on acute health care services and improves outcomes for individuals, families and communities.
Without stable funding, this program will end within the next three months, despite strong outcomes, demonstrated demand and clear alignment with provincial priorities around mental health, addiction, health care sustainability and community safety. We know this model works, we know the need exists, and we know the cost of doing nothing is much greater.
Thank you for your time, and I welcome any questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now turn to questions by members.
Bryan Tepper: I’ve got some questions. You said there’s a 77 percent completion rate. What entails a completion rate?
Leanne Utendale: When they complete the five- to seven-day detox and our doctor would then say that they’ve completed successfully, they can then choose to move on to ongoing treatment. That’s something that we offer every client.
Bryan Tepper: How much in donations does Options bring in that is used for this program?
Leanne Utendale: It initially was funded through Health Canada, through a grant there, and then we received a grant from the Vancouver Foundation to continue. That’s how it has been funded for the last four years.
Bryan Tepper: Okay, and we’re here for next year’s budget. I just heard you say that we’re in trouble in the next three months. Depending on what happens with that, how hard is it to restart the program if there is funding for next year?
Leanne Utendale: Yes, and I should have mentioned that we are also discussing this in partnerships with the Surrey police force, fire service and other trades unions, so we are hoping to find some funding to get this going. We have the model in place and the staffing in place, and our organization can maintain that and start that up.
[2:10 p.m.]
Rohini Arora: Thank you so much for your presentation. I had a couple questions.
One is that you said that the 77 percent completion rate is when the clinical expert will say: “Yes, five to seven days of detox has been completed.”
What happens after, if there’s a relapse, for example? Are they able to come back? If they are able to come back, is that also counted within the 77 percent completion rate if they’re doing it again, or do you disaggregate that data?
I’m just so curious, especially because you mentioned partnerships with unions, front-line responders. I think that’s really important. We know that 70 percent of these substance use issues are for men aged 45 and mostly in the trades. That’s an area that caught my attention right away.
Leanne Utendale: Yes, we do. It’s per person, the 77 percent completion rate. Absolutely, if people do relapse and they need to come back, they can come back multiple times, and our doctor assesses. She is an addiction specialist. She’ll assess and make sure that it’s a good fit. Unless they need inpatient treatment options. Then she will refer.
Rohini Arora: Just to follow up, you said that this is low-barrier because you can access it at home — jobs, children, caretaking of any kind. But I thought I heard you maybe say in housing at times. Did you say that, or did I just mishear you?
Leanne Utendale: No, you’re correct. We also will provide this service to people who are unhoused. We have shelters that we can.… We have rooms that are dedicated, with 24-hour staff who will provide meals. We provide the medications. The entire service is free regardless, whether they’re housed or unhoused, but if they’re unhoused, they have a bed so that they can go through the detox process. Then we do try and line it up so that we can work with our other treatment centres, if they want to go and receive treatment.
Rohini Arora: If they have complex needs, like you said, it might require meals, a bed and full-time, 24-7 staff. Does that mean you operate in a sort of no-barrier kind of way, or is it low-barrier? Low-barrier for people that are housed, low-barrier for people that are unhoused — it can look different, depending on complex needs. In a safe environment….
Especially, you mentioned South Asians. In some communities, there’s a lot of stigma around substance use and mental health, so they’re often hiding it from their family members. I don’t want to assume, but I am sure there might be circumstances where people want to stay there just because it’s safer for them to be able to go through the process without family sort of keeping an eye on them.
Leanne Utendale: That’s right. This initially was started for the South Asian community. They had reached out to Options. It was a collaboration between the community and the organization to provide this service, and that’s why it’s low-barrier. Then for people who are unhoused, we provide that shelter system and everybody available so that we can make it as low-barrier as possible. There will always be barriers, so I would hesitate to say no-barrier.
Rohini Arora: At least, I guess, my intention by saying that is: that’s your intention, to make it as no-barrier as possible.
Leanne Utendale: Absolutely.
Rohini Arora: That was the sense that I was getting. Thank you.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
Next we will be hearing from Janine Theobald from Mental Health Recovery Partners of South Island.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Mental Health Recovery Partners,
South Island
Janine Theobald: Good afternoon, and thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today.
As noted, long name, I’m Janine Theobald, executive director with Mental Health Recovery Partners, South Island. For over 40 years, we have provided community-based mental health and substance use support, or MHSU, across the capital region, primarily on the homelands of the Songhees, xʷsepsəm and W̱SÁNEĆ Nations.
Alongside direct services, we also lead system transformation initiatives. This includes the Mind the Gap project, supporting youth in the vulnerable transition into the adult mental health and substance use system, and the regional Lived Experience Professional Network, which strengthens the peer workforce and leadership.
Today I will highlight the role of not-for-profits and the continuum of MHSU care, the impact of peer support and system navigation, and two practical recommendations to strengthen government-funded services.
[2:15 p.m.]
MHSU care is an ecosystem of regional health authorities, non-profits, Indigenous-led services and community partners. We don’t do this work alone. The south Island is resource-rich compared to rural communities, yet people still struggle to find and access services. For those reaching out for help, the system can feel like a tangled spiderweb — confusing and easy to get stuck in. We’re working with partners to turn that web into a safety net.
Non-profits are nimble, adapting in real time and filling gaps before they become crises, but we still face rising operational costs — wages, rent, insurance, technology — without corresponding increases in funding and administrative allocations. Doing more with less is no longer sustainable.
Peer support is a consistently validated intervention. Research shows it reduces hospitalizations, increases engagement with care and improves long-term stability. It is a therapeutic relationship where individuals with similar lived experience offer emotional and practical support.
Think of it like this. Someone is stuck deep in a hole. A clinician may look into the hole and offer a treatment plan. A family member may share encouraging words. A peer supporter climbs into the hole and says: “You’re not alone. I’ve been here before, and I know the way out.” That lived experience builds trust and hope.
Peer supporters bring expertise, rooted in living experience that no other discipline can replicate. They model recovery and help people engage with services. Yet peer support remains chronically underfunded, particularly in training and supervision.
System navigation is another high-impact and low-cost intervention that prevents people from getting caught in the spiderweb of services. For someone experiencing a first crisis without a GP, the pathway to care can feel like a maze.
The province’s Pathway to Hope strategy explicitly identifies navigation challenges as a barrier to accessing MHSU care and calls for more seamless, coordinated access. Navigators know the pathways and timelines. They help individuals understand where to go; make referrals; coordinate appointments; complete applications; and connect people to housing, income and food security resources.
Navigation prevents crisis escalation, reduces inappropriate emergency use and supports voluntary care before situations become acute. It strengthens every service government already funds, reducing pressure on expensive involuntary and acute care.
When people are supported in the community, we see fewer police calls and emergency room visits. This results in measurable cost avoidance across health, justice and social services.
For recommendation 1, we’d like to see standardized contract administrative allocations, ensuring that every community mental health contract with a health authority provides a minimum administrative allocation of 15 percent. Current allocations vary across the province, and the legacy 10 percent cap no longer reflects economic realities. Aligning health authorities with provincial standards will stabilize the workforce the government relies on.
For recommendation 2, funding for community-based peer support and system navigation, please provide dedicated funding to ensure peer supporters and system navigators are skilled, supported and sustainably integrated into the continuum of care. When every dollar must work harder, the highest return comes from keeping people well in community. Strengthening non-profits will reduce crisis demand and relieve pressure on acute care.
I have provided a handout with a summary of my comments, but one of the things I want to point out is a bit of a heat map. We’re doing our best with our limited funds to collect data, and this demonstrates the impact on wellness that we have in community.
The one I really want to draw your attention to — these are before-and-after surveys — is that people feel hopeful about the future. There are other, more measurable ways that we’re impacting wellness in community.
Thank you so much, and I welcome any questions you might have.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now go to questions by members.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: It says you’re south Island. How far do the services reach?
Janine Theobald: We’re in the capital region, so anywhere that is kind of in the CRD area. We do endeavour, when people reach out, to reduce barriers. There is an MHRP that’s in Nanaimo, but they’re much smaller and focused on that family support.
Sometimes we do get calls from farther away, and we’ll do remote services and whatever we can, but we’re primarily in this area.
[2:20 p.m.]
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Okay.
Follow-up question. Your little graph here with the data collection — it says January 1, 2024. Is that when…?
Janine Theobald: Yes, this is a newly implemented system that we’ve been working to get everybody on board with the team. I would say that collecting the paired samples is probably one of the more challenging pieces, but this is the scope of that collection of data to date. We do have all our small but mighty departments enrolling in the data collection system slowly and steadily to make sure that we can really reflect that work we’re doing.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Well, it was a great visual to see the comparison of the change that you’re making on the ground.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the heat map. I love graphs.
For the administrative allocation, going up to 15 percent from 10 percent, which is kind of the standard, though some go up to 20…. With matching money, it doesn’t actually work out, we all know.
We heard earlier from another presenter that not only was it the needed extra 5 or 10 percent, depending who you talk to, but it was also what you could put in the envelope. Are you having issues with what’s considered administrative versus programming?
Janine Theobald: We do keep it pretty clear what that is. In our contracts that we’re working with, we haven’t had any challenges. I would say that my understanding is that here in this region in particular, we have that lower envelope to be able to put funding into. It does make a difference, particularly when we’re just seeing those kind of small incremental….
Actually, the region here has, I think, the slowest cost of living increases, as well, that are added to the contracts year over year. It’s kind of…. We’re seeing the same amounts, but we’re seeing really increased need in community and acuity as well.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for coming and presenting to us today.
Moving on to our next presenter. If I can have Elissa Robb come forward, please. She is from Help B.C. Hear Better.
Thank you so much for joining us. If you are okay to proceed and if you can hear me, that’s good. That’s great. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin whenever you’re ready to go.
Elissa Robb: Just to let you know, I am following along using closed captioning that you’ve provided, so thank you for that.
My name is Elissa Robb, and I’m a registered audiologist and hearing instrument practitioner.
Hearing is one of the ways we stay connected to the world around us. It connects us to the voices of our loved ones, to learning in the classroom, to conversations at work, to our safety and to our communities. When hearing is lost, those connections can become more difficult, not because solutions don’t exist but because they’re often financially out of reach.
I know this personally. I’m hard of hearing. I wear two hearing aids and will require ongoing hearing health care. I’m fortunate to currently have access to devices which allow me to work; converse with my six-year-old son; and, confidently but not well, play on a soccer team. Many British Columbians are not as fortunate.
Today I’m speaking on behalf of Help B.C. Hear Better, a growing coalition of health care professionals, researchers and people with hearing loss united by a common goal — improving access to hearing health care in British Columbia.
Our efforts are endorsed by both provincial and national organizations. Michael Smith Health Research B.C. awarded us a $20,000 grant, and we had a resolution endorsed by the district of Saanich at the Union of British Columbia Municipalities convention. We have engaged directly with government representatives, including Susie Chant, Bowinn Ma and Dan Levitt. We remain committed to working collaboratively with government to find practical solutions.
Here’s the problem. Hearing health care isn’t just a hearing issue. It’s a health issue, it’s an educational and employment issue, it’s an accessibility issue, and it’s an economic issue.
[2:25 p.m.]
Untreated hearing loss has negative health consequences and is linked to early cognitive decline, dementia, social isolation, loneliness, poor mental and physical health and greater risk of falls. There is a 44 percent increased risk of a 30-day hospital admission compared to individuals without hearing loss.
The province currently has a world-renowned early hearing program, which covers hearing health needs for children from birth to five years. Unfortunately, this is where the age-based coverage of our province stops — right when they’re about to enter the learning environment.
School-aged children with hearing loss are at a greater risk for language delays, literacy challenges and academic struggles. I witness many families face financial barriers for hearing aids in my job as an educational audiologist.
There is no funding for students in post-secondary studies. I remember I had to appeal to my parents when I was in 300th level physics to buy a hearing aid because I was having trouble hearing one of my professors. This affects those in career development and post-secondary. This leads to the workforce, and those in the workforce experience reduced employment opportunities.
Did you know that British Columbia is one of the few provinces that does not have a provincially funded hearing health care program? We lag behind. Since the development of the Accessible British Columbia Act, passed in 2021, we now have a responsibility to actively identify, remove and prevent barriers for people with disabilities.
Untreated hearing loss is causing a financial burden on British Columbia’s health care system. In 2021, the World Health Organization published that if governments invest in hearing health care, the return of the investment is 16 times the money invested. The cost of not treating hearing loss is greater than the cost of providing hearing care.
Realistic and achievable solutions, provincial healthy hearing program, a strategic investment in health and an investment in the future — these would improve support for individuals with hearing loss. It’s consistent with the government mandate, as set by the Ministry of Health’s strategic direction document. The program costs will be offset by the savings incurred through decreased health care costs.
In closing, I would like funds to develop a formal working group to look at the investment in this and am asking for legislators to join us in a change in policy. This program will keep the people of B.C. safer, healthier and more connected with their communities and will help B.C. hear better.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
I will now turn to questions by members.
Rohini Arora: So happy to see you here. I’m single-sided deaf and have been most of my life. I also rely on closed captioning to be able to do my job.
I just want to nerd out with you for a second actually. If you know about Amano Labs, they created an ultra-low-cost hearing aid device through McMaster University for $20. As you know, some of the hearing aid costs can be from $5,000 to upwards of $10,000.
For someone like me, I can’t even use a cochlear implant or a hearing aid because there are no nerve endings to send signals to the brain. I lost the nerve endings in the inner ear, in the cochlea. I think it’s just something that….
What you said about the task force — I think that’s a great idea and happy to help and support and advocate for that. I do my own advocacy as just one of a few people that are open to sharing about their hearing loss, but I know that many people experience it, some younger and older, depending on work or whether it’s congenital or happened during an accident.
I just really appreciate you being here, and we should stay in contact.
Elissa Robb: Absolutely. Thank you for sharing. As you may know, sometimes there’s a negative stigma associated with hearing loss and wearing hearing aids. We’re really trying to remove the stigma, remove the financial barrier and connect people with their loved ones, connect them with getting back into the workforce and contributing to our economy.
[2:30 p.m.]
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Yes, I want to thank you as well. I had a couple of constituents who are hearing-impaired come to my office and demonstrate to me how hard it is to interact with government services, and it was very impactful. We had to bring somebody from another community in to do the ASL, and we had to use Zoom, actually, to have closed captioning for them. It was very eye-opening to see the barriers.
I have some hearing loss. You’ll see me in the House. I have an earbud that I wear, which is nowhere near the same. I’m not saying that.
You mentioned the investment specifically to get your working group going. I know that my constituents are also trying to get a working group going. We’ve done some work here in the Legislature around providing some feedback around services that could improve legislative access.
I’m wondering what investment is required to get your working group going and who you envision in that group.
Elissa Robb: Yeah, that’s a good question. We’re looking for $200,000.
We’re looking to have stakeholders — the health authorities, people in the Ministry of Health and hearing health care professionals — to oversee conversations and look at what implementation looks like and examine the other provinces.
Alberta has the Aids to Daily Living program, the AADL. This is a cost-share program based on your income. Ontario has the ADP program, assistive devices program. Many of the other provinces have their own programs. Looking at what works well with them and where the gaps are would be something that would be involved in this working group and what the funding would provide.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): One clarifying?
For the $200,000, do you see that being a one-year work, two years? What do you…?
Elissa Robb: Probably two years. A lot of the people involved…. We have a really awesome team. There are a lot of researchers. We like to present evidence-based information, and we’re all volunteering in-kind our time, on top of our full-time positions, so sometimes it takes us a little bit longer. The funding would probably be over two years.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you for coming and presenting to us today.
Elissa Robb: Thank you so much. Have a great day.
Paul Choi (Chair): The committee will take a quick recess at this point.
The committee recessed from 2:32 p.m. to 2:42 p.m.
[Paul Choi in the chair.]
Paul Choi (Chair): I’ll call the committee back to order and welcome our next presenter. We have Krista Bekkema from Habitat for Humanity Victoria.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Krista Bekkema: In this time of economic uncertainty and rising costs, the province is prioritizing core public services; investing in B.C.’s future; managing government expenses responsibly; building sustainable long-term solutions; and creating safer, stronger communities. If I were going to pursue these worthy goals on behalf of British Columbians, I would start looking for solutions where they all converge. I would start with housing.
Hon. members of the committee, good afternoon. I’m Krista Bekkema from Habitat for Humanity Victoria, and I’m here representing the B.C. caucus of Habitat for Humanity. I have the privilege of working in an organization that delivers a needed solution on the housing continuum — affordable home ownership. I thank you for this opportunity today to demonstrate how the province’s ambitions are supported by our charitable mission.
I’m a CPA, and I understand that any dollar invested by this province needs to produce the highest returns. Investing in our limited-equity affordable home ownership model will provide one of the best returns possible for our province, one that I feel British Columbians could be proud to stand behind.
It is within that context that I ask that you make Habitat for Humanity’s limited-equity affordable home ownership model eligible for funding through the community housing fund so when it inevitably reopens for projects, it can fund the entire spectrum of housing solutions. Broadening the acceptance criteria of the community housing fund is an action you can take now, during hard years of financial tightening, which will set us all up for success in the future.
For the first time in 20 years, there is a net migration away from B.C. The Business Council of British Columbia’s 2025 report revealed that 77 percent of this migration is in our younger demographics, workers under 40 who are more skilled and better educated than those remaining.
[2:45 p.m.]
Why does a pool of talented individuals who can likely afford renting homes here leave? In search of communities where they can own homes.
At Habitat, we like to introduce ourselves by saying we’re like an affordable rental but so much better. Our housing model helps build financial stability and security while answering the profound dream of home ownership. It offers British Columbia a way to retain young talent. A one-time, upfront investment in Habitat’s affordable home ownership program creates a community asset where a household can set down roots and raise a family.
So too, you may be thinking, do purpose-built affordable rentals. The main difference is that Habitat’s program creates an inventory of affordable home ownership units in perpetuity, where homeowners gain some financial equity and a modest appreciation of 2 percent annually.
Unlike renting, Habitat’s home ownership offers additional benefits that align nicely with the province’s focus.
Improved physical and mental health outcomes reducing demand on the province’s critical services.
Economic and productivity improvements. Forty-four percent of adults in the program improve their employment situation and go on to earn almost 30 percent more than if they had continued renting.
Higher education achievements. Forty-one percent of Habitat homeowners start or complete additional education.
Safer communities. Fifty percent of households living in Habitat homes take part in more community events and volunteer, resulting in safer communities.
No additional burden or expenses for the public sector because Habitat administers and manages the housing inventory.
The power of any public funds used to support our program is amplified when our charity leverages corporate and individual donations of cash, materials and services. Imagine what we could achieve at scale, working together.
With seven Habitat affiliates across this province, an opportunity exists to amplify the benefits of our limited-equity housing model to more British Columbians through careful deployment of the community housing funds.
We often hear from governments and other funders that they don’t want to enrich individuals. Let me reassure you. This program provides a hand up, not a hand out. We help British Columbians who otherwise couldn’t get into the market to purchase starter homes right here instead of migrating and searching for lower living costs.
There is an immediate benefit to the household, but there are also powerful spillover benefits to the community and an overall lift to the B.C. and Canadian economies.
Investment in Habitat’s limited-equity affordable home ownership model through the community housing fund program will help meet British Columbia’s priorities of protecting core services and investing in the future of residents for generations to come. It is a sustainable use of public funds that will reduce social subsidies well into the future.
I am convinced that this ROI in public funds is one that current and future British Columbians can and will support.
Thank you for your time.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you for your presentation.
I’ll now turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the presentation. My question is around…. It says they get 50 percent mortgage from a traditional lender, and then you do the rest at zero percent. I’m wondering. The 2 percent that they get in appreciation — does that happen every year guaranteed, or is that based on market?
Krista Bekkema: It’s guaranteed. It’s every year, guaranteed.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): So if the market goes down, they still get their 2 percent appreciation, but if the market goes up significantly, they still only get 2 percent.
Krista Bekkema: They only get 2 percent, yeah.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Okay.
And then the 50 percent traditional mortgage — if they default on that mortgage, does…?
Krista Bekkema: Habitat buys the home back, so we recycle the home. That’s why we say it’s always for generations. We register options to purchase and right of first refusal on all our units, and we work with municipalities to place housing agreements that cap the price and the appreciation on the homes. We basically create a sub-inventory of housing.
Bryan Tepper: Just to clarify that, the 50 percent, basically…. If I go in, get a 50 percent mortgage from a retail lender, then Habitat for Humanity does 50 percent?
Krista Bekkema: Yep, we step in for the difference.
Bryan Tepper: If it was 25, you would put in 75 percent?
Krista Bekkema: Exactly, yeah. They do up to 50 percent of the purchase price of the home.
Bryan Tepper: Okay. I might as well ask then. Is it only the homes in your system? Or if you’re going to buy a home…?
Krista Bekkema: No. It’s only our homes, and you have to meet the qualifications, the income tests. It’s not for anyone who just wants to buy a Habitat home. You have to be under the B.C. Housing low- to moderate-income levels.
[2:50 p.m.]
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay, thank you. I just want to also clarify. The 2 percent appreciation cap — that doesn’t apply if the value goes down?
Krista Bekkema: No. It’s kind of independent of the market of housing. It’s really pulling these houses out of the market and saying: “You’re going to buy it at this price, and it’s going to go up at 2 percent per year forever,” which is well below what our current housing market’s returns are.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay, thank you.
Any other questions?
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Hi. In your presentation, you said there are seven through B.C.
Krista Bekkema: Yes, seven affiliates.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Where are you located?
Krista Bekkema: Our affiliate that I’m from is from Victoria, so south Island. We have three on the Island, the greater Vancouver area, Sunshine Coast, the Okanagan area and then southeast B.C., so a large portion of the whole province is covered through the seven affiliates.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Thank you for your presentation. The Habitat for Humanity that came into Ladysmith, my neighbouring riding, where was that?
Krista Bekkema: That’s mid-Island.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: Mid-Island? Okay.
Krista Bekkema: Yeah, they’re based out of Nanaimo.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Sorry. I have so many questions about this.
They have to qualify that they’re below a certain income threshold. What happens if…? Obviously, we’re focusing on the youth and younger generation, as you mentioned. They hit their earning power and start to make….
Krista Bekkema: Significantly more money?
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Significantly more money, and they’re paying 30…? Does it still…?
Krista Bekkema: It stays at 30 percent. We do an annual test, so it’s always 30 percent of their income. But we always say, for somebody who could then get lifted into the housing market because there are higher returns, they have an incentive to say, “Hey, I’m going to take my equity I’ve built, and now I’m going to go out into the open market,” and now we can serve another family. That’s our hope — that we can continually move people on that housing ladder.
Rohini Arora: Is that option within a particular timeline? For example, if someone does hit their earning power and you’ve recognized, doing your annual review, is there a certain amount of time within which they would have to move out, or is there an option? They’re not evicted or…?
Krista Bekkema: There’s no obligation for them to move out, but the incentive is there from the standpoint that we’re capping their appreciation at 2 percent annually. They can stay in the home forever, if they want to.
Rohini Arora: Okay.
Interjection.
Krista Bekkema: Yeah, 30 percent of their….
Rohini Arora: I had to look it up while…. I was listening, I promise, but I was looking up the Bobbie Craft thing because I remember that being in the news with the Habitat for Humanity in New Brunswick.
Krista Bekkema: Oh, okay.
Rohini Arora: I was just looking at that case to remind myself of what had happened, and it’s nice to know that there’s a difference in the model.
What happens if someone makes a nonpayment or can’t make a payment?
Krista Bekkema: We try to work with all of our families for a period of time, but if there’s a sustained challenge, then we have an option to buy that unit back, and they would get their equity out. But they do have to be able to maintain their housing costs.
Rohini Arora: What are the circumstances — or, I guess, exigent circumstances — that it would be accepted that they couldn’t for that month?
Krista Bekkema: The only circumstance I can think of is with their first position mortgage, if they could no longer maintain that with the bank. If they couldn’t make those payments, then, for a period of time, we’d probably have to look at buying the home back for them and then helping them move on.
Rohini Arora: What if they’re within the first six months, so there’s no equity built?
Krista Bekkema: Oh, they still get equity built in the first six months. However much they’ve paid down of their principal, they would have equity for that. There’s always something for them as soon as they move into the home and they’re starting to make their mortgage payments.
Rohini Arora: And do you take out…? I’m so sorry. I’m so curious about this system.
Krista Bekkema: No, no, this is good. I love this.
Rohini Arora: Do you take out a particular amount, then, that’s owing for the month where you may have had to cover costs?
Krista Bekkema: We would probably increase the Habitat mortgage for that amount. They also are making very small payments on their Habitat mortgage. The bulk of it is on their conventional financing with the retail lending, so there’s equity built up in their Habitat mortgage.
We have in our program, kind of like a home equity line of credit, that if there are some circumstances, a short-term circumstance where they need some help, we can help them through that.
[2:55 p.m.]
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much. We have lots more questions, but I’m sure we can follow up after.
Krista Bekkema: You can reach out to us any time. We’d love to chat.
Paul Choi (Chair): Absolutely. Thank you so much.
We’ll go to our next presentation. I would like to call Charles Brown up from Innovative Medicines Canada.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You may begin when you’re ready.
Charles Brown: Good afternoon, Chair Choi, Deputy Chair Wilson and members of the committee.
My name is Charles Brown. I’m the director of government affairs for Innovative Medicines Canada. Our member companies are committed to improving the health of British Columbians through discovery, development and delivery of innovative medicines and vaccines.
In British Columbia, our sector also plays a meaningful economic role, contributing approximately $1.4 billion in GDP annually, supporting over 10,000 jobs, generating $721 million in labour income and contributing nearly $460 million in government revenues.
Today I want to focus on a growing external pressure that has the potential for significant impact on patient access and investment in British Columbia — that being the U.S.’s most-favoured nation policy or MFN. In simple terms, MFN would require pharmaceutical companies to align on U.S. drug prices, with the lowest prices in countries like Canada and others to be referenced.
While that may seem like a U.S. issue, it has direct implications here in B.C. Global pricing decisions can influence where companies launch new medicines, where they conduct clinical trials and where they invest future innovation.
Consider a simple example. If Canada pays $100 for a drug and the U.S. currently pays $300 for the same drug, drug companies will sell to Americans at $100 or less, the most-favoured nation’s price, which is significant. When faced with the reality, many companies will forgo launching in Canada in order to protect U.S. profits.
The key point is this. Global pricing decisions can have a real consequence on patients and health systems here in British Columbia. At the same time, the province is facing fiscal pressures. What was seen in the last budget is relatively flat or constrained budget constraints. In fact, in the budget was a slight decline and then flat projected for the next three years.
This creates challenges in maintaining current listings and funding new therapies, which ultimately impacts patient outcomes. Innovative medicines are not just a cost; they are part of the solution. They can reduce hospitalization, avoid surgeries and improve long-term system sustainability.
Finally, I’d like to say that patients in British Columbia already face inconsistent access compared to other provinces, with delays and variability in drug coverage and other things in health care as well. This inequity risks widening current pressures. These pressures require a unified response. To help address these pressures, IMC is recommending three actions for inclusion in B.C.’s next budget.
First, we recommend B.C. work with the federal government to secure targeted funding for innovative medicines, helping mitigate the impacts of MFN.
Second, accelerate access pathways, including expanding the use of pCPA or pan-Canadian Pharmaceutical Alliance expedited processes, which is a pricing negotiation mechanism, to reduce time for patient access.
Third, to improve coverage consistency and transparency, ensuring equitable access for patients across British Columbia.
In closing, IMC and our members are committed to working with the British Columbia government to protect patient access, support sustainability and strengthen the province’s life sciences ecosystem.
Thank you very much for your time. I’d welcome the opportunity to continue this discussion.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll go to questions by members.
Bryan Tepper: The third one…. I think I’m well-versed in the first two there. The third one is new. Can you go through that again because I also missed a bit of what you were saying about it. Just cover the transparency.
Charles Brown: The third recommendation?
Bryan Tepper: Transparency.
[3:00 p.m.]
Charles Brown: Coverage consistency and transparency and ensuring equitable access for patients across British Columbia.
There have been many circumstances where drugs have gone through the approval processes, namely with the federal government through the CDA, which is the Canadian Drug Agency. From there, it usually goes to a pricing negotiation, if at that point in time they believe that it should be a lower net price in order to make it economically feasible for all Canadians.
In many situations, it has gone through both of those processes, and in certain cases, those drugs were still not covered in British Columbia, where they were covered in other provinces. I think that when it comes to transparency, we’re looking at more of explaining the rationale, if there is a reason why a drug wouldn’t be approved in B.C. and is approved in other provinces.
Second, to look at equitable access. The rationale between the pan-Canadian Pharmaceutical Alliance and CDA, which was formerly known as CADTH, was to include equal access across provinces, so you wouldn’t have “have” or “have-not” provinces. For example, if they could negotiate a better price in Ontario, someone in PEI or somewhere else shouldn’t be penalized. We should have equal access at a reasonable price for all Canadians.
Rohini Arora: Hey, nice to see you. Question. I was looking up, because I wanted to make sure and remember, that your member partner…. Amgen, obviously, is one of them. Amgen is in my riding.
I’m curious. If aligning with U.S. prices means a competitive advantage based on pricing, what then makes the Canadian company or product that they’re selling, which might be the same as the U.S. company, better or more worthwhile investing in? What’s the difference?
Charles Brown: Ultimately, it amounts to…. If net prices or pricing are…. Where a company has to follow certain rules based on the most favoured nation, it could mean that pricing might be more optical or net pricing has been negotiated, and also, in terms of these pricing differences, companies want to go where their innovation is being rewarded. Who’s paying for the innovation?
A large amount of this problem comes from, first of all, pricing differences but then also…. When the government was digging deeper, who’s paying for the innovation? Who’s paying for the new drugs? By and large, the U.S. was heavily contributing the lion’s share for the globe.
So many companies…. This also happened with NATO, for example, where they were looking at what is the percentage of spend, of a percentage of GDP, that was being paid for defence. Well, the same thing was applied to things like health care or medicines. What they found is that the amount that Canadians were paying or other countries in the G7 was significantly lower than the U.S. Some countries like — we’ve seen recently — the U.K. have said that they would increase the spending on innovation, and certainly, that’s what we were looking at.
Now, it’s very hard to ask the B.C. government, where a large lion’s share of your taxes is already contributing towards health care. How do you do more? What we’re asking is not, say, to rob schools or hospitals or building roads to increase your drug expenditure or health care expenditure. It’s more looking at how B.C. can partner with the federal government in terms of looking at a reasonable way to solve these problems.
Rohini Arora: Just to follow up, I’m trying to remember if there is a cost guideline with the CDA. I think I was talking to Nathan about this in greater detail. Do you mind running us through that just to remind me? I felt like there was a particular threshold that they try to stay within.
Charles Brown: Yeah, so they do. They look at a couple of things.
They look at the budget impact analysis — what are Canadians going to pay for this?
Second, they want to know what is the efficacy, and what are we getting for what we pay for it, and which is the…. They look at economic terms. Is this economically feasible for this to look at?
In many cases, the pricing that they would look at, at CDA level, is a price that was negotiated through PMPRB, the Patented Medicine Prices Review Board, which sets the maximum price that a company could sell in Canada. That’s not the price that B.C. pays. It’s the net price that’s obviously negotiated later.
[3:05 p.m.]
When they do these economic analyses, they would look at what the maximum price is and if this make sense from an economics point of view for Canadians. Quite often the answer is no, and then it would go to the next part, which is negotiating net pricing at the pCPA level.
At the CDA level, oftentimes they would make the decision to say: “A certain drug meets the end points in terms of efficacy. Is it something that should be made available to Canadians?” Yes. “Is it affordable?” In some cases, it’s no, in which case, then, further pricing negotiations would need to take place.
Rohini Arora: Which causes delays. I mean, it has already gone through the approval process, which takes forever in and of itself.
Charles Brown: Correct, yeah. Nathan is a good source, though, for any of these questions.
Rohini Arora: He’s a great source. He honestly is.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
We will call the next presenter. We have Devon Hill from Canadian Beverage Association.
Thank you so much for joining us. You have five minutes for presentation, five minutes for questions after, and you can begin when you are ready.
Devon Hill: Good afternoon. Thank you for inviting me here today to represent members of the Canadian Beverage Association and the broader non-alcoholic beverage industry in British Columbia.
My name is Devon Hill. I am the director of government relations, western Canada, for the Canadian Beverage Association.
Our comments today focus on a few key areas where British Columbia can take meaningful action: reducing costs on everyday beverages to deliver real affordability for British Columbians, cutting red tape to give our industry the business certainty it needs to invest and grow and harmonizing beverage regulations.
The Canadian Beverage Association, CBA, represents the manufacturers and distributors of the majority of non-alcoholic refreshment beverages in Canada. We are the national voice for more than 60 brands of juices, bottled waters, sports drinks, ready-to-serve iced teas and coffees, enhanced beverages, carbonated soft drinks, energy drinks and other non-alcoholic beverages.
The majority of non-alcoholic beverages consumed in British Columbia are manufactured in B.C. locally by CBA members, and 16 percent of Canada’s manufacturing and distribution centres are located in British Columbia. The sector contributes $600 million to British Columbia’s GDP. In 2024, the B.C. non-alcoholic beverage sector directly supported over 2,300 jobs in B.C.
Based on the themes identified by our members, we have the following recommendation for Budget 2027 to help improve environmental performance, create new jobs and attract new investment in the beverage industry. We’re calling on the province to work with the federal government and other provinces and territories to establish a national recycling framework and harmonized, outcomes-based extended producer responsibility for beverage container recycling across Canada.
The beverage industry helps serve B.C.’s economic prosperity, achieves sustainability and encourages the people of B.C. to keep plastic beverage containers in the circular economy and out of the environment. Under the current extended producer responsibility system in British Columbia, non-alcoholic beverage manufacturers are responsible for managing, reporting and funding beverage containers and related packaging at end of use.
In 2024, Encorp Pacific’s Return-It recovered 78.3 percent of the beverage containers that entered the market from registered brand owners, which represents almost 1.4 billion individual containers. As of 2025, 12 of 13 Canadian provinces and territories have extended producer responsibility programs. This has created a patchwork of definitions, reporting requirements and system designs that require increasing administrative burden and system costs, without clear evidence of improved environmental outcomes.
B.C. can play a critical role as a high-performing system and advocate to the federal government and other provinces in developing a national baseline of standards and definitions and a national framework for recycling. Improving performance in other jurisdictions improves affordability across the country, including in B.C. British Columbia’s deposit return system is widely considered as a positive example in Canada, with high recovery rates.
[3:10 p.m.]
A hallmark of B.C. recycling regulation is a results-based framework, where the government establishes the desired outcomes and allows industry to implement cost-effective methods that yield the greatest environmental benefits. Although many of these programs are meeting recovery and cost targets across the country, some systems are not managing rapidly escalating costs.
Greater alignment of EPR across the country is necessary to increase system efficiency, improve reporting standards and decrease the loss of valuable materials. A national recycling framework would enable economies of scale and minimize disruption for industry, ensuring a stable supply of recycled material to meet the industry’s recycled content targets.
Overall, B.C.’s beverage industry appreciates the significant fiscal and economic challenges the B.C. government is currently faced with and recognizes that the policy choices set forth now will play an important role in shaping the future success of our province. The sector needs a competitive business environment and the conditions to continue improving environmental performance.
I want to thank you again for the opportunity to appear. I look forward to your questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Rohini Arora: Thank you so much for your presentation. You mentioned 78.3 percent through Return-It, I believe. Just so I’m clear, that was a funding recommendation you made, in investment?
Devon Hill: No, it’s a recommendation to work with the federal government and other provinces and territories to create harmonized regulations across the country.
Really, what we’re seeing right now is a patchwork. So 12 out of 13 provinces and territories have a system, but none of the systems work together at the moment. There are a few in Atlantic Canada, but really, what we’re looking for is sort of one Canadian economy for recycled materials.
Rohini Arora: Just as a follow-up, would that mean that you move that 78.3 number to hopefully 100? Is that like…? What’s the internal goal?
Devon Hill: Well, the internal goal…. For example, B.C. is performing well at the moment in terms of both the goals set for ourselves and the goals set by the government. We’ve passed the minimum target set, and we’re getting closer to achieving sort of the higher target.
There are other provinces, such as Ontario, that are much, much lower at the moment because they simply don’t have the same systems in place that we do. Really, what we’re trying to do is raise the standard across the country.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): What I’m hearing, then, is that the B.C. model needs to be applied across Canada, to some extent. Everything in the B.C. model or only specific things? Is there anything in the B.C. model that should be omitted, if we try to leverage for that federal support?
Devon Hill: I would say that the best thing about the B.C. model in particular is the results-based framework that is currently in place. B.C. sets the target and says it is up to business to meet the target in the best, most efficient way possible, which Encorp Pacific and their Return-It program has done a great job of doing. That’s really the hallmark of the program here — that results-based model.
Rohini Arora: When you talk about the internal goal sort of maybe being able to reach the 78.3, let’s say, across the country in places like a not-comparative jurisdiction at this moment, Ontario, to increase…. Would that mean having the recyclables move from Ontario to B.C.? A lot of what we have is in-house within the province. It’s housed here.
Is that the intention, or is it also to have the B.C. model there locally?
[3:15 p.m.]
Devon Hill: Because we have a patchwork of definitions and models across the country, what we’re seeing is that each province has different definitions, reporting requirements and fee structures. This saddles companies with costly compliance.
If you have a more national focus, then you get into the economy of scale. You can sell across the country and fill in gaps where needed, whereas these things are much more local in scale at the moment in terms of the economy and where things get sold.
Rohini Arora: If you’re attracting recyclables, let’s say, hypothetically, from Ontario to B.C. or other provinces that are more nearby, do we have, within the Return-It model, the internal infrastructure to be able to deal with the increase that we might have in terms of processing time and things like that? I’m just curious because, of course, any attraction to the province, especially interprovincially, is obviously of interest to the government.
Devon Hill: Yeah, certainly, I think the national focus on the infrastructure there would unlock savings around economies of scale, so recycling affiliates could work together to invest in processing facilities across the country, optimizing transportation routes and creating a more predictable and stable market across the country and not as much constrained by geography.
Bryan Tepper: In today’s day and age, every city and town has a recycling program now. Would it not be advantageous to the Beverage Association to just have cities do the curbside collection, as we’re doing right now with everything else, instead of bringing the bottles to Encorp or whatever we’re doing?
Devon Hill: In Ontario, for example, they have just a blue box system. What we see in Ontario, for example, is they have a much lower rate of recovery of materials than we do in B.C. It’s the provinces where you get that ten cents back if you return it to the depot where you see the greatest returns from consumers, like Alberta, like B.C.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation today.
Okay, we’ll have our next presenter. If I can call Marie-Pierre Lavoie to the front, from le Conseil scolaire francophone de la Colombie-Britannique.
Thank you for joining us today. Thanks for coming. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for your questions after.
You can begin when you are ready.
Conseil scolaire francophone
de la Colombie-Britannique
Marie-Pierre Lavoie: Merci beaucoup.
Good afternoon, members of the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government Services. My name is Marie-Pierre Lavoie, and I’m the board chair of le Conseil scolaire francophone de la Colombie-Britannique, the CSF.
As British Columbia’s only public francophone school district, the CSF serves more than 6,000 students in 47 schools across more than 30 communities. Our school board is unlike any other in the province. It covers all of British Columbia.
Under section 23 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, we have the constitutional duty to provide francophone public education wherever eligible families live. It’s a mission like no other, and it shapes everything that we do.
Today I will focus on what I believe is the most important question before this committee for the francophone community. How do we close the gap between constitutional rights and the reality experienced by francophone families?
The central challenge is financial. The demand for francophone education is proven. The funding to meet it is not. More than 40,000 children in British Columbia have the right to education in French. Today the CSF serves only 6,000 of them. It reflects the gap of what is promised to francophone families and what is actually accessible.
[3:20 p.m.]
Let me give you an example. There are more than 240 eligible francophone children living in Fort St. John, and there is no CSF school. The nearest francophone school is in Prince George, 437 km away, a five-hour drive one way. For these families, accessing daily francophone education is simply not possible.
This situation leads to assimilation. Students who do not have access to French schooling now will not be able in the future to enrol their children in a francophone school, no matter where they live in the province and even in the country.
Unfortunately, the reality in Fort St. John is also the reality of many other communities across B.C., but geography is only part of the challenge. Opening new francophone services is expensive. Every new service operates at a substantial deficit before reaching viability. What the CSF is missing is the adequate operational funding to support new schools through their early years.
Another major funding gap facing the CSF is CommunityLINK. Budget 2026 committed $634 million over three years to support B.C. students. Our students need that support as much as any others, yet under the current system, the CSF receives $23 per student, the lowest amount of any school district in B.C. The provincial average is $100. Vancouver receives $204. New West receives $212. The ministry has acknowledged this inequity. Now it’s time to take action.
Unfortunately, this is not the CSF’s only funding gap. Through the federal official languages in education program, Ottawa provides funding for francophone education and expects the province to contribute its share. To this day, British Columbia has never met its required annual contribution of $7.5 million.
Investing in the CSF is investing in the future of our province. Every CSF graduate enters the workforce fully bilingual, ready to serve in tourism, public service, health care and international trade with francophone markets around the world. These students will help build the strong British Columbia we want, aligned with the province’s Look West strategy.
Members of the committee, in direct support of Budget 2027’s priority, we respectfully submit three recommendations.
First, that the province establish a dedicated start-up fund for new francophone services of at least $500,000 per year to allow the CSF to expand into underserved regions.
Second, that the province conduct an immediate review of the CommunityLINK funding formula and, at minimum, bring the CSF to the provincial average, unlocking $465,000 each year to support the most vulnerable francophone students.
Third, that the province honour its required OLEP contribution of $7.5 million annually.
Members of the committee, when the CSF succeeds, British Columbia succeeds. We’re not asking for special treatment. We’re asking for the resources to fulfil a constitutional promise, a promise thousands of children across this province are still waiting to see honoured.
Thank you for your time. I welcome your questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll turn to questions by members.
Rohini Arora: Thank you so much for your presentation, Marie.
I also just want to say thank you for doing the work that you’re doing to open the first school in Burnaby. I’m very excited. It opens in 2027. You’ll have 360 spots for students and, I believe, 62 spots for daycare. So very, very exciting.
Now, I heard, listening and trying to look up things at the same time…. Can you remind me? The dedicated annual funding is the $7.5 million, and the top-up to the provincial level would be that additional $465,000 annually. Is that what you’re saying?
Marie-Pierre Lavoie: Yes. The federal government is funding the program. In the agreement, it requires provinces and territories, because these agreements are throughout the country with each jurisdiction, to match the federal contribution. So far since this program has started, the province has never matched that contribution that the federal is asking.
Rohini Arora: Just as a follow-up, can you remind me…? I think I had this conversation with you at the celebration of the 25th anniversary with the board.
[3:25 p.m.]
How many French speakers currently are there in the province, and how many children across…? Of course, you said the school district is the entire province. Could you just give us those numbers so that we can wrap our heads around it?
Marie-Pierre Lavoie: Right. There are 40,000 eligible children who could attend the CSF. There are some rules to attend the CSF, and it’s under section 23 of the Charter of Rights. In the province, French-speaking people, I believe, are 700,000.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Okay. Seeing none, well, thank you so much. Certainly, we look forward to seeing more French language being preserved in B.C. as well, so thank you.
Moving on to our next presenter, we have Philip Steenkamp from Royal Roads University.
Thank you so much for coming today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after, and please begin when you’re ready.
Philip Steenkamp: Yes, good afternoon, Chair and Deputy Chair and committee members. My name is Philip Steenkamp. I’m president and vice-chancellor of Royal Roads University, and it’s a great pleasure to be able to join you today.
We’re living, I think, as everybody knows, through a period of transformational economic change, one driven by technology, AI, shifting labour markets and global uncertainty. That is fundamentally reshaping what post-secondary institutions must offer to students and communities. While the sector is facing huge challenges right now — I’m sure you’re familiar with some of them — there are tremendous opportunities as well. These are opportunities, I think, that are best realized through shared understanding and collaborative action.
I want to speak today to three key high-level recommendations.
One, getting support for program innovation through enabling policies, funding incentives and by streamlining regulatory approvals. B.C.’s universities help prepare the next generation of leaders, innovators and entrepreneurs. Also, as trusted institutions, they inform discourse, solve complex problems and also uphold democratic values, but the system has to respond at the pace of change that we’ve seen today as well.
Learners are increasingly seeking flexible, career-relevant modular pathways, and affordability and access remain persistent pressures. Meeting this moment requires a post-secondary system that enables modular and stackable credentials — things like micro-credentials, certificates, degrees and workplace learning — one that meaningfully recognizes prior learning and lived experience and, also, accelerates pathways from education to employment.
I think real progress here is really going to require modernized curriculum frameworks and streamlined program approval processes; a refreshed tuition model allowing more flexibility around tuition tied to student financial aid; a move away from four-year degrees to three-year, 90-credit undergraduate degree options; and expanded learner supports, including broader eligibility for the StrongerBC future skills grant. This kind of upskilling and reskilling is going to be vital to sustain a thriving, a resilient economy.
The second key recommendation is to increase support for collaborative, integrated post-secondary initiatives. I think the most promising innovation in higher education is happening through institutional collaboration, breaking down barriers between systems, reducing program duplication and expanding access for students, employers and communities.
To fully meet modern learner and labour market needs, we must move beyond traditional academic agreements towards stronger dual- and shared-credential models, expanded prior learning assessment and recognition supported by competency-based evaluation, enhanced work-integrated learning and co-designing programs with employers.
Royal Roads University is very proud to be building collaborative partnerships across the province. Examples would be our new John Horgan Campus in Langford — which is a partnership with UVic, Camosun College, Justice Institute of B.C. and school district 62 — and we are shortly going to be announcing a new partnership with BCIT.
The thing about these partnerships is that they improve flexibility, accessibility and learner mobility while maximizing public investment, pointing towards a more integrated, responsive post-secondary system aligned with how people actually learn, work and reskill throughout their lives.
[3:30 p.m.]
The third recommendation is to work collaboratively with the post-secondary sector to advocate for a strategic and sustainable approach to immigration. To remain globally competitive, B.C.’s public universities need a coordinated approach that supports long-term sustainability and our ability to attract and retain top global talent. What this means is shifting from a transactional recruitment model to a long-term strategy which is focused on talent, innovation and global partnership.
International students, graduates and researchers strengthen B.C.’s workforce, drive innovation, support economic resilience and deepen our global connections. To achieve this requires strong advocacy with the federal government to strengthen immigration pathways that are aligned with B.C.’s labour market priorities; greater integration of post-secondary institutions within provincial trade and economic development strategies; and expanded global partnerships supporting research collaboration, talent exchange and shared innovation.
Jurisdictions that can successfully attract, integrate and retain global talent will hold a significant competitive advantage in the decades ahead, and I really believe British Columbia has the opportunity to be one of them.
Thank you for your time, and I welcome your questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now go to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you very much for the presentation. On your first point, you talked about streamlining approvals as being one of the necessary steps. Can you articulate that a little bit, what that means?
Philip Steenkamp: Well, I was actually the deputy minister in 2002 of Advanced Education here in B.C., where we put in place the degree quality assessment process, and it was very effective. It has been effective over time, but it needs to change because the world is changing so quickly now. You know, 20 years ago, you had one or two years to develop programs. You don’t have that anymore.
We have to move really, really quickly. I know the ministry is aware of this and is looking at this issue, but I think it’s something that needs urgent attention. Many other jurisdictions are moving much more quickly than we are able to move. That’s the essence.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Just a follow-up to that. What would be the solution to get government moving faster? Is it a sense that government needs to get out of the way?
Philip Steenkamp: I do think there’s a…. This would apply to the immigration framework too. I really think there’s an opportunity to develop what I would call a trusted institution framework, institutions that have the track record of offering quality education, so that everybody is not going through the same process necessarily, and potentially also introducing a bit of an audit approach here instead of having to review everything that comes forward.
Rohini Arora: I found it very interesting, Mr. Steenkamp, that you referenced the DQAB and the process because, obviously, as you said, for the time, it was thinking about having access to a library and being able to access the documents and the articles, etc. Obviously, right now the speed at which we are moving and the speed at which DQAB moves is not the same, especially if you’re looking to start a new course that maybe doesn’t…. There are others that have been cleared for several years whereas, when you do that, you start that process all over again.
What I’m hearing from you is for institutions that are recognized — like Royal Roads, SFU, UVic and UBC — it is essentially a review process or an audit process that might be more broad versus every single course that comes through, which can take time. By the time you actually get access to it, like a pharmacy course, for example, the medication they may be talking about has reached its third, fourth or fifth iteration by the time the course is approved, so you’re learning some of the details of yesterday versus today.
Philip Steenkamp: That’s exactly right. The established universities do have exemptions up to a certain level, but the pace of change now is so fast. Just to change the name of a program, the content of a program or the modality of a program, you almost have to do that on a dime in order to respond.
I’m not picking out DQAB, because I think all of our regulatory processes are not sort of fit for purpose right now.
Rohini Arora: Sure, yes, of course. We’re in a different climate. That’s just the nature of the beast, and I think it’s important that we all talk about it, so thank you. Thank you for your presentation.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for coming and presenting to us.
[3:35 p.m.]
We will move on to our next presenter. We have Terence Baluyut from Camosun College Student Society.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Camosun College Student Society
Terence Baluyut: Thank you very much to the committee for having me this afternoon. My name is Terence Baluyut, a fourth-year accounting student; a member of the Camosun College Student Society; and a director at the B.C. Federation of Students, representing over 170,000 post-secondary students across B.C.
The province has recently called on Canada to look west. If British Columbia wants the world to look west for opportunity, innovation and economic growth, then I ask that the government first look here, to the colleges and universities educating the people who will build that future. The strongest economy is built by an educated population, and the strongest future for B.C. begins with investing in the students who will shape it.
That brings me to my first recommendation, and that is to restore public funding to 75 percent of post-secondary institutions’ operating budgets.
Camosun College is a community college that plays a vital role in the capital region. Beyond educating students, it is a major employer and an important part of our local economy. Like many institutions across the province, Camosun has become increasingly reliant on international student tuition revenue to balance its budget and fund essential services, not by choice but because of chronic underfunding in the sector. When the federal government introduced restrictions on international student visas, our projected international student population dropped by half.
Recently Camosun announced a projected deficit of between $7.2 million and $9 million for the next fiscal year, and the impact has been immediate. More than 90 jobs have already been lost, and our board of governors has announced another round of layoffs. These are not just positions on a budget spreadsheet. These are people in our community who support families, pay rent and contribute to our local economy.
What concerns me most is that the students who rely on support services the most are often the first to feel the consequences of these funding shortfalls. At Camosun, we have seen cuts in our Centre for Accessible Learning. Students with disabilities are experiencing longer waits for support, and we are hearing directly from students who are struggling to access the accommodations they need to write their exams.
Too often these challenges are framed as a result of federal immigration policy, but the reality is that the system was already vulnerable because provincial public funding had not kept pace with inflation for many years.
In the year 2000, government funding represented 68 percent of public post-secondary institutions’ operating revenue. Today provincial funding accounts for only 53 percent of Camosun College’s budget. The current federal policies did not create these structural challenges. It exposed them. If we want a stable and sustainable post-secondary system, we must address the underlying funding model that brought us here.
That leads me to my second recommendation — to expand the scope of the sector sustainability review to include a consideration of new public investment and ensure students are meaningfully included in future discussions.
Representatives from our student society have participated in consultations related to the sector sustainability review, and throughout that process, a wide range of options have been discussed, from reviewing tuition policy to considering institutional mergers. Yet one option has been notably absent, and that is new funding.
As stakeholders continue to wait for the results of the review, uncertainty is growing across the sector. Around me, I see campuses reducing services, programs being cut and institutions introducing new fees in an effort to stay afloat.
The first independent review of the sector, conducted by Don Wright in 2022, identified a need for at least $200 million in additional annual funding simply to avoid a zero-sum environment. Yet, once again, the current review has proceeded with the assumption that no new funding will be considered.
Without new investment, someone will absorb the consequences. The question is who. I ask the members of this committee: is it the students, who are already struggling with today’s high cost of living? If so, how much more do we expect students to absorb?
In the immediate term, institutions need emergency bridge funding to withstand the financial pressures they are currently facing. Longer term, the sustainability review must be empowered to examine funding solutions and develop a stable, equitable model that supports the future of post-secondary education in B.C. Without new funding on the table, the pressure to solve budget challenges will continue to fall on students who are already contributing their fair share.
[3:40 p.m.]
This brings me to my final recommendation, which is to protect affordability by maintaining the 2 percent tuition limit policy.
Through my role with the Camosun College Student Society, I hear directly from students who are struggling to make ends meet. The cost-of-living crisis is affecting everyone in Victoria, but students are among those feeling it most acutely.
The tuition limit policy, which restricts annual domestic tuition increases to 2 percent, remains one of the most effective and predictable affordability measures available to students. At a time when costs continue to rise, students need certainty that tuition will remain manageable.
My college serves as an access institution. Students choose Camosun because it offers an affordable pathway into careers that strengthen our communities and economy. Protecting affordability means protecting that pathway.
Thank you to the committee for allowing me to present in this consultation. The recommendations I have presented today are connected by a simple principle, and that is that investing in students is investing in British Columbia. As a student, I see every day the talent, determination and potential that exist in classrooms across our province. I sit beside future nurses, educators, tradespeople and community leaders.
Students are preparing themselves to contribute to British Columbia’s future. We, the students, are doing our part. Now the government must do its part as well.
Thank you, and I welcome any questions.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now turn to questions by members.
I will ask a question as well. From your perspective — I understand you may not fully know — what would be the difference in needs of a student like in Camosun, in a rural campus, versus other students in, let’s say, UBC or SFU, in the more Metro Vancouver area?
Terence Baluyut: Sorry, could you please repeat the question?
Paul Choi (Chair): Yeah, what do you think, if any, could be a different need that your school has in Camosun, based on its geographical area, versus other students in, let’s say, Metro Vancouver area?
The reason I ask this question is that we get presented from many universities’ and colleges’ students, and they tend to have very similar needs and asks. We want to learn more about if there is anything that’s specific to your needs, that’s unique, so that we can ensure we reflect everyone’s needs equitably across the province.
Terence Baluyut: Yeah, thank you for that question. As I’ve mentioned, Camosun is an access institution. Many students go to our college because it’s affordable and it allows them to find that pathway towards future opportunities in other institutions as well, such as those larger universities you have mentioned.
With the given crisis that we are currently experiencing, such as funding shortfalls and all the services being cut, it no longer represents the identity that is Camosun, which is to have an accessible education for our students. With many cuts that are happening in our services, a lot of our students are struggling in order for them to have a successful education, such as myself, who is already entering my fourth year in my degree program.
There have been a lot of wait-lists in my courses, and that means that my graduation could potentially be delayed. This situation is not isolated. Many programs on our campus are experiencing this as well, which means that delayed graduation could also delay people coming to the workforce in B.C. For them to be able to contribute to the local economy, we must ensure that we must offer those pathways for them to be able to successfully complete their education.
Rohini Arora: Thank you so much for your presentation. I think that you said you’re on the board of the B.C. Federation of Students.
Terence Baluyut: I am.
Rohini Arora: Welcome, and thank you for your advocacy on behalf of BCFS. I know the folks there quite well.
I’m curious. Just in case, if you do have the number, do you know how many provincial attestation letters were given to Camosun? Do you have any idea about that number?
Terence Baluyut: I have no idea about that number.
Rohini Arora: Okay. I can find out.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, well, thank you so much for coming and presenting to us today.
Okay. We’ll move on to our next presenter. If I can have Bahar Dehnadi come forward from Victoria Women’s Transition House Society.
[3:45 p.m.]
Thank you so much for coming to present to us. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready to go.
Victoria Women’s
Transition House Society
Bahar Dehnadi: Thank you for having me. My name is Bahar Dehnadi, and I’m the executive director of Victoria Women’s Transition House Society here in Victoria. For those of you who may not know, Victoria Women’s Transition House provides life-saving services to survivors of gender-based and intimate-partner violence in the greater Victoria region. We’ve been operating for over 50 years.
Every day our staff and volunteers answer crisis calls, walk alongside survivors navigating the family court system, help women secure protection orders, support children who have witnessed unimaginable things at home and work to find safe, stable housing in one of Canada’s most expensive rental markets. We see up close, every day what happens when policy fails to meet the reality of survivors’ lives.
Gender-based violence is not a background issue in British Columbia. It is a daily emergency. Just to give you some stats on the scale of what we are responding to, one in three Canadian women will experience intimate-partner violence in their lifetime. Over 40,000 people across this province access transition houses and crisis shelters.
That number is from 2019-2020, which is the last available public number from B.C. Housing, despite us reporting monthly to them. We know, since COVID, that those numbers have increased dramatically. This is to give you an idea of what it’s been in the past, but it’s far more than that now.
Also, 44 percent of women in B.C. report having experienced physical or sexual violence since the age of 15. The annual economic cost of gender-based violence in B.C. — which includes health care, justice and lost productivity — is over $1 billion at the last reporting by YWCA.
While Budget 2026 committed $139 million to reduce repeat violent offenders and improve access to the justice system, we’ve seen that those investments are still not enough to help us in the work that we do.
One of the priorities that we’re asking for is that family law must work for survivors. At Victoria Women’s Transition House, we support survivors through some of the most difficult moments of their lives, including family court proceedings that too often feel designed to defeat them.
We’ve sat with women who have been cross-examined by their abusers in court. We have supported clients whose abusive ex-partners filed motion after motion, not to resolve parenting disputes but to keep control and drain resources. We’ve watched women lose custody hearings in part because the family court system lacks the tools to recognize a pattern of coercive, controlling behaviour.
What we’re asking for in this priority is mandatory gender-based violence screening in family court — which includes evidence-based, trauma-informed screening for intimate-partner violence and coercive control that is administered by trained professionals — with appropriate follow-up. Without this, the system cannot know what it is actually dealing with. We and our coalition partners are ready to support the development of these protocols.
In this priority, we’re also asking for judicial and professional training on gender-based violence dynamics. Judges, family justice counsellors and mediators need mandatory, ongoing training on coercive control, trauma-informed practice and the specific risk of the post-separation period, when violence often escalates. This isn’t a criticism of individual professionals. It’s a recognition that the system needs current, evidence-based knowledge built in.
Our second priority is sustained adequate funding for gender-based violence prevention services. When someone accesses our programs, they’ve often been harmed. What we see is that when you invest in gender-based violence prevention services, every dollar shows a savings of $6 to $15 in downstream health, justice and social service costs.
Sustained funding for Indigenous-led gender-based violence services is inadequate. Indigenous women and girls are disproportionately affected by gender-based violence in B.C. and face significant gaps in accessing culturally safe services. When you provide adequate sustained funding, it’s a reconciliation imperative consistent with B.C.’s obligations under DRIPA. We work alongside Indigenous-led organizations in greater Victoria and witness firsthand the difference culturally grounded services make.
The other part of this priority is that gender-based integration with mental health and addiction services must come first. The majority of the women we support have experienced trauma. Many of them are also navigating mental health challenges and substance use. The investments that Budget 2026 made in mental health and addictions are welcome, but they need to explicitly be gender-based-violence informed.
We urge the province to require gender-based-violence screening at intake in mental health and addiction settings and to fund gender-based violence outreach workers co-located within community health hubs.
Our last priority is to recognize and respond to coercive control. The women who come to access our programs do not always arrive with bruises. Many of them have experienced years and sometimes decades of control. A partner who monitored every text, who controlled every dollar, who isolated them from family and friends and who threatened to take the children if they ever left — this is coercive control. For most of our clients, it is the most damaging and dangerous part of what they experienced.
[3:50 p.m.]
Coercive control is a recognized pattern of behaviour that is documented extensively in research. In Canada, it’s largely invisible to the law. Police cannot charge it, family courts cannot weigh it properly, and survivors who try to describe it are often met with skepticism because there are no photographs, no hospital records and no single incident to point to. The result is that the justice system responds to the wrong thing, isolated incidents of physical violence, while missing the ongoing, escalating danger that coercive control represents.
The majority of intimate-partner homicides are preceded not simply by physical assaults but by patterns of coercive control, which we saw with the case of Dr. Gover in Victoria in January. What we’re asking for in this priority is to amend the Family Law Act to recognize coercive control — this is a step that Nova Scotia is already making, while we’re waiting for the federal government to take that step — to train front-line responders and to invest in public awareness.
Many survivors still do not recognize coercive control as abuse. They’ve been told that their partner’s behaviour is normal or that they are overreacting. Public education campaigns name and describe coercive control and save lives by helping recognize danger earlier and by creating a culture in which bystanders know how to help.
Victoria Women’s Transition House has been part of this community for more than half a century, and the people that we serve are not statistics. They’re mothers, daughters, elders, young people and newcomers — people who come to us because they’ve had nowhere else that’s safe for them to go to. They deserve a province that takes their safety seriously, not just in words but in the budget decisions that determine whether the services they need actually exist.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: I don’t know where to start. Thank you for your presentation. I know that was a lot to cover in five minutes. I was trying to keep up to everything.
Also, your last part of your presentation…. I’m going to try to do this without crying. The coercive control — mentally, emotionally and threats. That’s what it comes down to, like you said. It’s a lived experience for me. I’ve watched a friend go through unspeakable trauma, also the control of financial…. She had to save pennies in a mattress to leave an island, to leave her abuser. It took not days or weeks. It took years for her to save because of the receipts.
My question. If there were some sort of legislation that came forward, what would that look like?
Bahar Dehnadi: This has already been done in England and Wales. They’ve already had this in place for the past ten years. While there is still a long way to go, we’ve seen over the last ten years that attitudes have shifted, and they’ve started to actually prosecute offenders that are using coercive control.
I think the biggest thing for us is that there has to be some accountability for people that are doing this, and currently none exists. Even if there were a law, we would see that there would be some offenders that would just step back because that is a behaviour. If there are consequences, some people won’t do it again, but there’s a long way to go.
There’s a lot of training that’s required. There’s a lot of work that needs to be done, across training judges and the courts, training RCMP, training folks to do this work, to recognize what coercive control actually is and what your legal rights are within that, once it becomes a criminal offence to have coercive control over someone. There is already evidence that it’s working.
I know I said a lot. It is a lot of things to cover in five minutes. I do have handouts that I’m happy to leave for all of you because I maybe covered 10 percent of what I was going to talk about.
[3:55 p.m.]
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: That would be really helpful and great. Yes, the training — I know that would be a lot to cover. Trying to communicate that to someone for training that hasn’t actually lived that experience and wouldn’t know about that….
I don’t know where I was going with that, but I’ll….
Bahar Dehnadi: Thank you for sharing. I know it’s really hard to talk about it, and I’m sorry for what’s happened to you and your friend.
This is the work that we do every day, and that’s why it’s necessary for the government to invest adequately in it. Women aren’t numbers. They’re not statistics. This is a life every time. We see that gender-based violence is one of the most preventable deaths in this province. It’s one of the highest prevalence amongst women. It is the leading cause of homelessness for women. When we adequately invest in it, we see that it really does make a difference.
Paul Choi (Chair): A quick question from MLA Arora.
Rohini Arora: Obviously, you’re aware of the Ahluwalia v. Ahluwalia case, which is precedent-setting across the country, thank god, so coercive control technically falls under…. It’s a class A felony or — I can’t remember what it falls under — a class B because it’s criminal. I’m just wondering. How do you see that interfacing with the province?
Bahar Dehnadi: It’s not recognized as a criminal offence right now.
Rohini Arora: Oh, sorry. I thought it was.
Bahar Dehnadi: No. Federally, that’s what they’re trying to do right now.
Rohini Arora: Okay. That must be the ongoing discussion then. Got it.
Bahar Dehnadi: Yeah, that’s an ongoing discussion. It has been tabled, so it hasn’t actually come to fruition yet. We’re hoping that the Attorney General will continue to work on the advocacy pieces to make sure that the federal government does make it a priority to pass it. It has been tabled for quite a while, many years, so we’re hoping that it actually goes through.
Despite that, the province does have an opportunity to actually enact it in family law provincially, to recognize it as a criminal offence.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for presenting to us today.
We’ll call up our next presenter. If I can have Bradd Tuck from British Columbia Funeral Association come forward.
Thanks for joining us. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions.
You can begin when you’re ready.
Bradd Tuck: Perfect. Thank you.
Well, good afternoon and thanks for taking the time to consider the budget recommendations brought forward today by the B.C. Funeral Association.
The BCFA is a member-based not-for-profit organization representing funeral, cemetery and crematorium providers across British Columbia. Our members serve British Columbians in every corner of the province, regardless of their social, cultural or economic status.
I’m here today to ask our government to recognize the importance of these essential services and to provide the funding to funeral homes so that they can provide those dignified services across the province. To achieve this, we have three interconnected recommendations for your consideration.
Our first recommendation is for an increase to the Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction funding so that the rates for the provincial cremation and burial supplement match the rates currently paid by the Public Guardian and Trustee.
We want to acknowledge that the ministry recognized the need to increase these rates in 2026 after more than 15 years of stagnation. However, while the current program raised basic services to $1,685 from $1,285, it did so at the cost of eliminating funding for additional services, such as embalming, visitations and funeral services. While we appreciate the ministry working to find solutions within their limited budget, this is only a first step.
Even with this reallocation of funds, British Columbia remains the province with the lowest funding for this type of program and the fewest services covered. This creates a critical, undignified gap where low-income British Columbians are entirely financially denied access to funeral and memorial services.
This change has had a particularly devastating impact on First Nations communities that rely on split or matched funding agreements through Indigenous Services Canada and the Ministry of Social Development. For many of the First Nations, a funeral service is considered an absolute necessity. Removing additional services funding from the program places an immense financial pressure on the greater family circle, the community and the nation to fill the gap.
Therefore, the BCFA recommends matching the PGT standard, $2,100 for basic services and $2,600 towards additional funeral services, alongside an annual mechanism for inflationary review. It is crucial that future adjustments to the rates be considered today so we don’t find ourselves back in a situation where rates remain unchanged for years to come.
[4:00 p.m.]
Based on the approximately 3,500 cases per year, this rate adjustment would shift the program cost to $16 million, representing a net budgetary increase of $5 million to $10 million. To put that into perspective for the committee, the top end of the range, a $10 million increase, represents 0.01 percent of the government’s overall spending increase. With the ministry’s own $6 billion budget, it’s a minor reallocation of less than 2/10 of 1 percent.
This brings me to our second recommendation, which directly offsets the costs I just mentioned. As part of the national CPP working group, the B.C. government should actively support raising the federal CPP death benefit to $5,000, a recommendation we’ve submitted in partnership with the Funeral Service Association of Canada to the federal budget committee.
Because the ministry offers a cost recovery program that recovers federal CPP benefits to repay provincial burial costs, raising this benefit would drastically increase the amount of money the province claims back. It would alleviate pressure on the provincial treasury for individuals who are CPP-eligible but still rely on the province to cover additional costs, as is often the case with burial arrangements, and it would lift many families out of needing the provincial subsidy altogether.
Finally, our third recommendation is for British Columbia to introduce a provincial tax deduction for prepaid funeral services. Encouraging British Columbians to prepay for their end-of-life care is smart fiscal policy.
When an individual passes away without a will or a plan in B.C., families often hesitate to step up out of fear of financial risk. This directly drops the burden onto the province, forcing the ministry or Public Guardian and Trustee to step in as a last resort. Incentivizing prepaid plans reduces the number of unclaimed decedents, protects grieving families and significantly reduces long-term demand on social services funding.
Together these three initiatives form a balanced, fiscally responsible strategy. By leveraging an increased federal CPP benefit and incentivizing private preplanning, we can dramatically reduce the pressure on the provincial systems; maximize cost recovery for the treasury; and, most importantly, ensure that every single British Columbian has access to dignified end-of-life service.
Thank you for your time. I welcome any more questions that you may have.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We’ll now turn to questions by members.
Bryan Tepper: Maybe you could expand a little bit more on the prepay and what the program would be.
Bradd Tuck: Currently there is a federal tax program where if money is placed into a prepaid funeral insurance or a funeral trust product, then that is income tax deductible. We would look for B.C. to reflect that type of program.
We are a heavily regulated sector in B.C., so all prepaid funeral service plans are known by and regulated by Consumer Protection. It would be a fairly easy mechanism to allow those files to be shared and for it to be known when those investments are made.
The hope is that by creating a tax incentive to prepay and preplan, more individuals would get their affairs in order. They would create a will. They would pay for their funeral services. There would be a lower demand on the Ministry of Social Development program as well as a lower cost for all British Columbians as, generally, with everything, the service cost will go up over time.
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Rohini Arora: Thank you for your presentation. There were some things you mentioned that sort of caught my interest, and I wanted to just ask because I’m not sure what the answer is.
You said that you support communities of all backgrounds. You mentioned cremations as well as burials. What does that break down into annually, in terms of if you were to disaggregate the communities you serve? What are those percentages like? Are there particular areas that have higher needs across the province?
Bradd Tuck: In general terms, cremation in B.C. is the highest in North America. The rate is about 88 to 90 percent cremation versus burial.
There are different cultural groups that would look to cremation or burial as the only form of disposition that would be available to their culture. There are some, particularly many Indian cultures, Hindu and Sikh, that would look to cremation as the only disposition method. Then there are other cultures, such as Muslim or Jewish services, that would only be burial.
We see the vast majority of the Ministry of Social Development cases also in alignment with that. There are about 80 percent to 90 percent that look for cremation, and the other 10 to 20 percent would look for burial.
There’s a particularly large impact on First Nations, and the vast majority of First Nations in B.C. do choose burial as their final method of disposition.
There are many other cultural components of a funeral service that are incredibly important and what I would think of as also essential, including, sometimes, prayers, visitation, spending time with the decedent in whatever way that looks. Those are services that are no longer covered under this program.
[4:05 p.m.]
Paul Choi (Chair): Any other questions?
Seeing none, thank you so much for coming and presenting to us today.
We’ll call our next presenter. I’d like to call Janet Morris-Reade from the Association of Service Providers for Employability and Career Training.
Janet Morris-Reade: Hello.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready to go.
Association of Service
Providers for Employability
and Career Training
Janet Morris-Reade: Thank you for the opportunity to speak today. I also want to point out that I brought my team with me so that they can witness the important work that you’re doing here and how it can impact the work that ASPECT is doing. I think it’s an important learning experience.
As you know, I’m with the Association of Service Providers for Employability and Career Training. We represent about 100 community-based employment service providers who are publicly funded. They provide services throughout all corners of B.C. Our members help people connect jobs and training and workforce opportunities while supporting employers in their labour market needs.
Today I am asking for an investment of $15 million annually to establish a community workforce partnership initiative that supports partnerships between employers, Indigenous communities and economic development organizations, municipalities, training providers and employment service organizations.
Here’s why I’m asking for this. When we talk about economic development in B.C., we often talk about roads, ports, housing, energy projects and trade corridors, but economies do not run on infrastructure alone. They run on people, and employment services are the scaffolding that connects people to opportunity.
Every day community-based employment service providers help workers prepare for a changing workforce. They support newcomers, Indigenous people, youth, persons with disabilities, older workers and anyone who needs extra support to create workforce development skills to find and keep employment. This learning stays with them throughout their lives.
ASPECT members also help employers, especially small and medium-sized businesses, with recruitment, retention and workforce development. Importantly, we are the first organizations people turn to when the economy shifts, when layoffs happen, when workers need training, when employers cannot find talent, when communities are struggling to adapt.
As you know, right now tariffs, global instability, automation and changing workforce demands are affecting industries and employers across the province. Workers are being displaced, and employers are trying to make decisions in a rapidly changing economy. This is where the community-based employment service providers play a critical role. We help displaced workers transition into growing industries. We help people gain new skills before they fall out of the workforce entirely. We help employers connect with local talent pools they may otherwise miss.
This work is not just about the programs. It’s about relationships, trusted local relationships between employers, workforce organizations, Indigenous communities, municipalities, training providers and government. Yet workforce development remains too siloed across ministries and disconnected from local labour markets and their realities. Community-based employment service providers already sit at the intersection of workforce development, employer engagement and community resilience.
Government is investing billions into projects and infrastructures. Our network is small yet mighty. We are on the ground making connections, but we can collectively do more with a small investment.
Today I’d like to offer three recommendations.
Provide funding to create the workforce development table that brings ministries together with employers, Indigenous partners, municipalities and community-based workforce organizations to better coordinate workforce planning across government.
[4:10 p.m.]
Recommendation 2 is to recognize employment service as essential workforce infrastructure and a partner in further developing these partnerships.
Three is the request for $15 million annually to create a community workforce partnership initiative. This funding would support workforce planning, rapid response to layoffs and economic disruptions, employer engagement and workforce transition supports across the province.
Strong economies are not built on projects alone. They are built by people having the supports, skills, relationships and opportunities — communities and government together. If B.C. wants a strong, inclusive and adaptable economy, then the workforce development cannot remain siloed. Now is the time to recognize workforce partnerships and employment services as a core part of British Columbia’s economic development infrastructure.
I thank you for your time.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
Now we will turn to questions by members.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you for the presentation. I just want to clarify. Is it 15 or 50?
Janet Morris-Reade: So 15. It’s not a lot of money.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): I heard 50 the first time, 15 the second time.
Janet Morris-Reade: I’ll take 50.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): I assume that is new money.
Janet Morris-Reade: That is new money. There are a couple of existing action-type organizations already operating. There’s the Social Services Sector Roundtable, which has successfully managed social care services through the pandemic. I think it’s a real example of what could be done.
I’m thinking that what this would do is support creation that would span all different ministries, that would bring employers and economic development core people to the table, as well as the service providers. The employment service providers could be the conveners within all of these communities because they’re already doing the work, but they’re not being financially supported for doing the work.
To me, it feels like a missed opportunity especially. There is an impact team. For example, if a mill closes in a community, the provincial government has an impact team, but quite often they don’t show up for five days. In those five days, all hell is breaking loose within the communities, and our members are already there helping people find what they need.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Just a clarification then. Do you see the workforce development table being the manager of this money, or do you see this money going to your association for distribution through your network of 100?
Janet Morris-Reade: I see it going to the employment service providers throughout the province to create these alliances within their communities and to convene the meetings and to support whatever may be done. They’re the experts in the community, so they have a really good idea of what’s needed. What may be needed in one community may not be needed in a different community.
This way you get community intelligence to have targeted supports. You need a convener to pull everybody together, which they are now doing for free. I think that if there was a small investment, they would do very, very well within their communities.
No, the money would not come to ASPECT. It would come to the people that are doing the work. That would not necessarily be ASPECT members. It would be employment service providers within communities.
Rohini Arora: I was taking in all the information, everything you’re saying, because I come from the labour movement. A lot of what’s in my mind is thinking about the impact on the labour market.
Are you working with the Federation of Labour to determine some of the workforce needs? There’s a lot of…. We’ve invested over $400 million in skilled trades training, as you know, over a period of years. That’s my previous employer. We represent over 500,000 workers in the province and across industry and sector.
Some of this work and the round table that you’re talking about already exists through the labour movement within their particular structure, executive council and executive officers. I’m just wondering. Have you had any conversations with the B.C. Federation of Labour, and is that something you’d be interested in?
[4:15 p.m.]
I think some cool stuff could potentially happen where if you have people reaching out to your employment services, there are places to support them with direct connection, especially for skilled trades or the federal public service employees union, or PSAC. There are a lot of different options, social services as well.
Janet Morris-Reade: Yeah, absolutely. Some of our employment service providers already have those relationships, but this is an exact example of the silos that are created through the funding.
What I’m asking for is that we have a convener that comes and brings everybody together and says: “Oh, this group, the labour movement in this community, is doing this kind of work. How can we support the work that they’re doing? How can we bring others to the table?”
It’s kind of like a party host trying to bring everyone together so that everyone prospers and feels better and the community is connected. A lot of that work is being done in community, but it’s just not being supported. I think small support spread throughout the province to different communities is a good use of taxpayer dollars.
Debra Toporowski / Qwulti’stunaat: You just asked my question about silos, so I’m satisfied with that.
Paul Choi (Chair): That is fine. We are out of time anyway.
Thank you so much for coming and presenting to us today.
Janet Morris-Reade: Thank you so much for your time and for the work that you’re doing on behalf of us all.
Paul Choi (Chair): We will call our next presenter, Leia Patterson from the B.C. Museums Association, to the front.
Thank you for joining us today. You have five minutes for your presentation, five minutes for questions after.
You can begin when you’re ready to go.
Leia Patterson: Great. Thank you.
It’s nice to see everybody on this hot afternoon. My name is Leia Patterson. I’m the interim executive director of the B.C. Museums Association.
The BCMA supports institutions, staff and volunteers, as well as other museum workers of all varieties, with professional development, support, advocacy, all on their behalf. Our association has over 450 members that represent every region in the province.
Definitions for museums, heritage organizations, arts, culture and heritage change, and it’s hard to find consistency across them, even in government sources. When I say “museums” here in the next four minutes, I’m going to include that as a broad range of organizations and institutions, so just kind of keep an open mind when I say “museums.”
I have just one ask today, and mostly that’s because I’m nervous. I am on the job for three months now as interim ED, so this is quite a new process to me. Public speaking and math — both my not-super-keen things. I’m a trained anthropologist. This isn’t my realm.
Today I’m here to ask you to consider increasing the B.C. Arts Council annual budget to $58 million from its current $39.156 million, and I’m going to tell you why that relatively small investment is going to give you really big gains in the province.
We already know that arts, culture and heritage matter to the economy. Culture generates $13.6 billion in direct economic impact on the GDP in B.C. That $13.6 billion is twice as large as the impact of agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting. I’m going to say that again because actually I found that a bit stunning. The $13.6 billion generated by culture is twice as large as the impact of agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting, which is $6.4 billion. This is made possible by the 132,400 people who work tirelessly in arts, culture and heritage across B.C.
Knowing that arts, culture, and heritage have immense financial value and are a good return on investment, I can tell you it’s not only a good return for GDP but it’s also a good return on investment for communities across the province. Roughly 90 percent of museums surveyed by the government of Canada are partnering or collaborating with communities that they serve to enhance programming, provide expertise and expand their audience reach.
Organizations from this sector serve as community hubs. They’re cooling stations in hot weather. They’re venues for community events. They’re educational facilities, research facilities and tourist attractions. Over 90 percent of museums in B.C. offered programming tailored for educators and school curriculum, bringing the classroom to life.
[4:20 p.m.]
Contrary to the belief that museums only hold really old objects, museums are always collecting things for the future so that the narratives of our current generations are available for future use.
There’s no identity or community without the belonging and sense-making that museums work tirelessly to preserve and protect. It’s much harder to restart and recreate these organizations than to maintain them, and we really need investment now because the sector is barely hanging on.
More than 50 percent of BCMA’s institutional members have budgets under $200,000 per year. In B.C., 50 percent of museums report facilities that either require attention, are at the end of life or are unfit for service, and 33 percent of those museums had their last capital infrastructure project, renovation or improvements well over ten years ago.
I’m asking you to increase the investment to B.C. Arts Council, and I know that budgets are tight. I’m asking you to recognize the contributions that museums are making in this province and to our communities as the really good investment that they are and to extend us a lifeline before it’s too late.
As a person who has worked in the sector for ten years, I can tell you that we do so much with so little. The COVID spending that happened during the pandemic was such a boost for us, and now that we’re levelling off without it, it is a challenge.
We’ve seen a lot of museum closures across the country, lots of provincial governments reducing funding, and I’m asking you not to follow suit. It would be devastating.
Paul Choi (Chair): Thank you so much for your presentation.
We will now turn to questions by members.
Rohini Arora: I just want to thank you for your presentation. One of my friends is a labour historian and worked on a book called Union Zindabad!, which she co-authored, and some of the stuff she found was from 1906-1907 up until the 1920s. The predecessor of my organization that I worked for had a magazine that really captured that moment in time.
When you were speaking about collecting…. Archives are serious business, and I don’t think people understand. My cousin is also an anthropologist, so I have a lot of respect for what you do, the work that you do. All of the staff that go into museums…. I hear you loud and clear about the importance, and thank you for being very direct, stating very clearly: “I’m asking you not to follow suit.” I think that’s a line that’s going to stick with a lot of us today.
Thank you, Leia.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Thank you very much. It was a great presentation.
In my riding, Boundary-Similkameen, are eight museums, several heritage sites. I’ve met with all the boards, and the message has been consistent — that they’re all just hanging on, doing way more with way less. I hear you loud and clear.
The Grist Mill in Keremeos is celebrating 150 years next year. Can’t help but put a plug in. I’m pretty excited to do that with the community.
My question is around the bump in the funding. Do you have…? It’s obviously heritage, culture and arts. Of that bump, how much of it do you see going for core function of the museums?
Leia Patterson: If most of it could be core operating funding, I think the sector would be grateful. We see a lot of project-specific funding. The problem is it’s always short term, and then as soon as the project is over, it dies.
I see that in my own organization. I see that in a lot of our members — the need for operating funding. That keeps the lights on, keeps the HVAC system working and keeps all of those things…. Unrestricted funding for operations is essential.
Rohini Arora: I’m just wondering about your operating funding. What would you say is the…? If you’re getting project-based grants, that’s one thing, but because those have limitations in and of themselves…. There’s how much you’re allowed to keep in terms of the surplus, what you have to give back depending on the HR envelope and the administrative portion of it. For operating funding, when you say from $39.156 million to the $58 million, you’re saying most of it could be operating.
Is there an average of costs that are just not being met in every…? Is some of that surplus from the project-based grant allowing you to help try and fill, where you’re allowed to obviously?
[4:25 p.m.]
Leia Patterson: I would say that if you asked B.C. Arts Council, I’m sure they would tell you their operating funding stream is oversubscribed. Most of them are. I have worked at multiple institutions that balance their staff salaries with project funding. If the project funding doesn’t come in, the staff get cut.
I’m not alone in that experience. I think that’s really common. I will say that in ten years, this is the first time I’ve ever had a permanent contract to keep my job beyond a project. That is standard.
Rohini Arora: Wow, so a lot of precariousness.
Leia Patterson: It is very precarious, which makes long-term planning, succession planning of staff and maintenance of an organization really hard.
Rohini Arora: Just as a follow-up, are you finding that you’re losing people in the field because they’re going elsewhere to find security?
Leia Patterson: Yes.
Donegal Wilson (Deputy Chair): Yeah, from meeting with my own museum groups, it’s not just the precariousness of staff. It’s actually the precariousness of: can they turn the lights on?
My local museum holds a meat draw, and that’s how they primarily fund their building. Without the meat draw, there’s no building.
I think that the core funding question…. My question. Do you currently receive any core funding, guaranteed funding? Does each museum get it, or is it application-based each year?
Leia Patterson: It’s application-based.
Paul Choi (Chair): Okay. Thank you so much for coming and presenting to us today.
Leia Patterson: Thank you for having me, and I hope you all make it to a museum event this summer.
Paul Choi (Chair): Certainly hope so. Thank you very much.
I will ask if there is any other business from our members. If not…. Yes?
Rohini Arora: Are we not doing two hours additional of deliberation today?
Paul Choi (Chair): No.
Rohini Arora: I just wanted to see the look on the Deputy Chair’s face.
Paul Choi (Chair): There’ll be plenty of days set out, dedicated — many, many days for that.
Thank you, everyone, for coming and presenting today, and also to the members, staff, Hansard, for making today possible to have the public come and present to us.
We will be returning tomorrow for more in-person and virtual public hearings.
At this point, I will seek a motion to adjourn.
Motion approved.
Paul Choi (Chair): The meeting is now adjourned.
The committee adjourned at 4:27 p.m.